Nfld. & Labrador

Legal fees covered for House of Assembly harassment scandal may double, but who's paying?

The legal fees of more than $55,000 stemmed from allegations about MHA behaviour.

MHA Eddie Joyce says the Department of Justice is picking up his bill

The House of Assembly will be picking up the bill for legal fees incurred by MHAs during the recent bullying and harassment scandal.

Taxpayers will pay at least $55,000 — maybe closer to $100,000 — for legal fees racked up in the House of Assembly harassment scandal.

Some fees have been approved already, through what the Speaker says is the "only" process available for reimbursement, but one of the accused, who didn't go that route, says his bills are still being taken care of.

MHA Eddie Joyce — who, along with Dale Kirby, was ousted from the Liberal party last spring — says his roughly $50,000 legal fees are being covered by the Department of Justice.

Kirby, plus the MHAs who made accusations against him and Joyce, had their legal bills paid for through the House of Assembly Management Commission.

The 'only venue'

That group, comprising three MHAs in government and three in opposition, makes decisions around how money is spent at the House of Assembly.

When asked about the Department of Justice paying for Joyce, chair of the commission, Perry Trimper, said "I have no idea what you're alleging, I'm sorry."

The House of Assembly Management Committee was the only option for MHAs who wanted their legal fees reimbursed, according to Perry Trimper, chair of the committee. (Katie Breen/CBC)

"I can tell you that the management commission has not reimbursed him and that would be the only venue for him to seek and receive revenue."

Contacted late Thursday evening, the Department of Justice said it would look into Joyce's claim.

But Joyce says it's a done deal.

"They are covered, yeah," he said, in reference to his legal fees.

Eddie Joyce says the Department of Justice is paying for his legal fees that he says are in the range of $50,000. (Katie Breen/CBC)

He said he submitted his application to the Department of Justice the day after he was removed from Cabinet.

"I started out early… it was the only avenue available," he said.   

"There was no commitment from the Speaker so it was just normal for any Minister to go to the Department of Justice."

Management commission process

The decision to cover the fees for the other four MHAs was approved by the House of Assembly Management Commission during an in-camera meeting in the speaker's boardroom on Jan. 23.

Fees accrued up to Nov. 6, 2018 will be covered.

The total cost breakdown for the legal expenses being covered by the House are as follows:

  • Tracey Perry, MHA for Fortune Bay-Cape La Hune: $12,502.80.
  • Pam Parsons, MHA for Harbour Grace-Port de Grave: $2,219.51.
  • Sherry Gambin-Walsh, MHA for Placentia-St. Mary's: $14,559.00.
  • Dale Kirby, MHA for Mount Scio: $26,277.50. 
Dale Kirby will have $26,277.50 in legal fees covered. (Gary Locke/CBC)

Months of allegations of bullying and harassment between MHAs led Premier Dwight Ball to hand over the investigation to Bruce Chaulk, the commissioner of legislative standards, in May.

The commission directed that the decision to pay these legal fees will not be considered a precedent in similar matters. According to the minutes from the Jan. 23 meeting, future policy direction of the management commission on the reimbursement of legal fees will not be constrained by the commission's decision in this matter. 

Joyce was given a deadline of Jan. 31, 2019 in order to be considered for similar legal fee reimbursement.

The two-day waiting period to give effect to commission decisions was also waived during the Jan. 23 meeting. 

Read more articles from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador

With files from Katie Breen


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?