Nfld. & Labrador

Eddie Joyce's 2-word apology, months in the making, doesn't ring as sincere for minister

Now that they've apologized, MHAs Dale Kirby and Eddie Joyce have to undergo respectful workplace training.

Liberals say tensions lifting now that harassment reports have been dealt with

Service N.L. Minister Sherry Gambin-Walsh said the apology Eddie Joyce gave her wasn't genuine. (Katie Breen/CBC)

Dale Kirby and Eddie Joyce were ordered to apologize in the House of Assembly, with Joyce uttering his in just two words Tuesday night: "I apologize."

That apology didn't sound particularly convincing to one of the MHAs it was meant for.

"It wasn't a very apologetic apology," said Sherry Gambin-Walsh, minister of Service NL, referring to Joyce's "I apologize" concession Tuesday.

"I don't think he's sorry."

Eddie Joyce apologizes, and more reaction in the House of Assembly.

4 years ago
Duration 2:43
Liberals say tensions lifting now that harassment reports have been dealt with

Kirby, meanwhile, didn't make his apology statement until the legislature reopened Wednesday afternoon, after leaving the House early the night before.

"I offer my apologies to the House, Mr. Speaker,"  he said.

Joyce, left, and Dale Kirby were both ordered to apologize Tuesday. (CBC)

Both independent MHAs will now have to take respectful workplace training, after fallout from reports into allegations of harassment and bullying. The investigations did not conclude that either former Liberal cabinet minister had bullied anyone, but both were found to have contravened a code of conduct. 

The House of Assembly was called back two weeks early in October to deal with the harassment issues that came out in April, and after seven hours of debate, that was the outcome.

'I only did it because I respect the House'

Both apologies were required after MHAs voted in the House of Assembly.

"I had to stand here tonight and apologize for something I never did," Joyce said, while defending himself against a different complaint made by PC MHA Tracey Perry.

"I only did because I respect the House [of Assembly], by the way."

Gambin-Walsh accused Joyce of trying to bully her into hiring his friend for a public service job in her department.

Joyce didn't respond to a request for an interview.

Premier Dwight Ball says he hasn't spoken to Joyce or Kirby in 'quite a while.' (Katie Breen/CBC)

Gambin-Walsh said what she views as a fake apology means Joyce doesn't feel he did anything wrong, but she hopes that will change. 

"He didn't really apologize but I think with time, he will realize the mistakes that were made here," she added.

"I'm hopeful that the process that we've gone through, and we've experienced, will enable us to change the process as the House of Assembly."

Premier Dwight Ball didn't say if he felt the MHAs apologies were sincere. 

"They were asked by the speaker to apologize, and this was the apology they gave," he said.

But Ball said the "broad" recommendations for Joyce and Kirby's reprimands in the reports allowed for such short apologies.

"I think we need more prescriptive, more well defined recommendations," he said.

Liberals say internal tension easing

Gambin-Walsh said the situation was stressful on everyone in government but as it unfolded, the Liberals grew stronger.

"What I have seen over the last 24 hours is our team come together. We are having much better caucus conversations now, we're more open in the caucus room ... And you can really see the stability start to come back in our team," she said.

The premier echoed that sentiment.

"People are smiling, they're talking to each other again," he said.

When asked about his MHAs not talking, the premier said, "Of course they were talking, but it was very guarded in discussions, in conversations, and rightfully so."

"You could see some of this weight that they've been carrying around for quite some time has been lifted, I think that's human nature."

What's next for Kirby and Joyce?

Regarding Kirby leaving the legislature early Tuesday, before apologizing, Ball said it speaks to the level of frustration everyone is experiencing.

He said he hasn't spoken to Kirby or Joyce in "quite some time," and that he will be taking time to reflect on everything that's come up.

In the meantime, Ball said he "[doesn't] have any decisions to make about these members — they are independent members right now."

Read more articles from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador


Katie Breen

Video producer

Katie Breen makes video content for CBC in St. John's. She's been working in news for 10 years. You can reach her at


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?