Nfld. & Labrador

Costs overboard: What you're paying for with emergency ferry fixes

The MV Veteran and the MV Legionnaire were supposed to be the stars of the province's ferry fleet when they were built in Romania in 2015.

The province's 2 newest vessels have been plagued by breakdowns

The new MV Veteran arrived in St. John's in 2015. (CBC)

The MV Veteran and the MV Legionnaire were supposed to be the stars of the province's ferry fleet when they were built in Romania in 2015. Instead, the vessels have been plagued by broken parts and human mistakes.

And, for the last year and a half, taxpayers have been footing the bill.

Between 2015 and the fall of 2017, breakdowns were covered by Damen, the company that built the ships, after the province negotiated an extended warranty.

Early issues with the Veteran included a breakdown on the way from Europe to Newfoundland before it made its first run to Fogo Island.

Since then, it's been out of service dozens of times with everything from ramp malfunctions to thruster problems. Even the bathrooms have been closed for maintenance. 

The MV Veteran was docked in St. John's in March 2016 for repairs. (CBC)

The Legionnaire has had problems as well, but not as often. In the early days, when the Veteran broke down, Damen would do the same fix on the Legionnaire to head off similar issues.

The extended warranty ran out in the fall of 2017, and from then on, either the province or its insurance had to pay the bills.

"These are very large vessels. If you look at the Bell Island run, the very short distance across there — these vessels, people have told me, in some cases are oversized for the type of operations they're running," said Transportation Minister Steve Crocker as to why the ferries have so many problems. 

"Just mechanically, if you look at the Bell Island run, the vessel is in and out of gear a lot. It's harder on a vessel, or any vehicle when it's not getting long runs."

Transportation Minister Steve Crocker says the MV Veteran's extended warranty ran out in November 2017. (Paula Gale/CBC)

Crocker said he's been told the short trips and frequent use cause added wear and tear.

"We're putting the ramps down on these vessels more often than many vessels of that size would actually have the ramps going up and down. We're using thrusters more because of positioning and jockeying into wharfs and stuff. So that all has a wear and tear factor."

Since the province took over the costs of repairs, the bills have been piling up.

For regular maintenance on the Veteran, the province paid $481,099.

Emergency repairs when parts broke or failed cost $2,301,263.

The Legionnaire cost $176,000 for routine maintenance. Emergency repairs came to just $78,000.

The MV Legionnaire crosses the tickle on a foggy July day. (Submitted by Marilyn Warford )

Those numbers include thousands in docking fees at the shipyard, but not the additional cost of air service hired to accommodate passengers when the vessels are out of service.

Eugene Nippard, who until recently was the citizen's representative on the Fogo Island transportation committee, said human error is a factor in the frequency of the ferries' mechanical troubles.

"It appears that some of it might have been abuse," he said. "The crew, inexperience. Because that's a high-tech ferry. We might have mechanical issues with the ferry from the factory where it was built, but we had a lot of issues where it appeared that it was self-inflicted."

Eugene Nippard was recently the citizen's representative on the Fogo Island transportation committee. (Garrett Barry/CBC)

Nippard said he's been sitting in his seat on the Veteran while it's tied up at the wharf and vibrating so intensely he feels like he's falling out of the chair, which shouldn't happen while the vessel is idling.

Crocker acknowledged there have been some challenges.

"And we've had some things on the vessel that weren't designed in a way to mitigate human error," he said.

"We've had to, in some cases, make changes with alarms and alerts for different things on vessels that were, I wouldn't necessarily even call it engineering oversight, but things that could have been done with added caution."

The MV Veteran sits in port at Farewell. (Chris Ensing/CBC)

He gave an example of two filters with interchangeable parts located next to each other. An employee mistakenly added fuel to the wrong filter and wrecked the engine on the Veteran.

Crocker said it should have been impossible to do that because the filters should have had different parts that couldn't be used incorrectly. 

Extra repairs affecting department's work

"We do have money budgeted every year for this kind of situation," Crocker said. "But it becomes difficult on the department, and lots of times we have to go and find it in something that we're planning to do that we're probably going to have to delay to get these repairs done."

He said there are times the department has to reschedule refits on other vessels, so the repair work can come out of the refit budget.

"We go into that budget and find ways to actually put it into this vessel or that vessel."

With an aging fleet of ferries, sometimes repair work can't be delayed for safety reasons. Transport Canada requires a certain level of seaworthiness, and those refits have to be done on time.

That means unexpected repairs may have to wait, which can extend the time the big ferries are out of service. It also affects the province's insurance, which covers large expenses like the blown engine.

Bell Island ferry users protest the removal of the MV Legionnaire to Fogo Island to cover for the broken-down Veteran in 2017. (Ryan Cooke/CBC)

Crocker said he hopes the number of unexpected repairs drops as problems are discovered and fixed, and the crew becomes more familiar with the vessels' quirks. In the meantime, he said, he's waiting for the results of an investigation into the ferries' histories.

"Last year, the public accounts committee asked the auditor general to look into the purchase of these vessels and the challenges we've been having with them," he said. "So we're looking forward to seeing what the auditor general's review comes back with."

That won't mean the province gets its money back, but he said it could help find the root of the problems and prevent some of these expenses from piling up.

Read more from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.