Still risk of major outages even after Muskrat Falls, says report on N.L. power supply
Liberty report says developing of current staff, and recruitment of new staff, needed at Hydro
More power supply — even after Muskrat Falls is complete — and a major overhaul of Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro is needed to secure customer power reliability, according to a report released Friday.
These two major concerns are not necessarily being currently considered by Hydro, the Liberty Consulting Group, commissioned by the Public Utilities Board (PUB), said in its report.
- Customers won't pay for NL Hydro's mistakes, PUB says
- Still high risk of power outages despite new generation, says #darknl review
The report is a second phase of its initial review released in 2014, which determined the 2014 outages — widely referred to as DarkNL — were caused by insufficient generating resources and failure of key transmission equipment.
Muskrat Falls won't solve Hydro's problems
Liberty said the problems experienced by Hydro "were as much or more due to organizational issues as they were due to system inadequacies."
The new investment will not eliminate those organizational issues, or the outages that flow from them.- Liberty report
"The new investment will not eliminate those organizational issues, or the outages that flow from them," the report stated.
"It is therefore urgent that Newfoundland's investment be protected and optimized with improvements to Hydro's operating, planning and other technical capabilities."
Liberty stated in its report that the challenges facing the Muskrat Falls project are so great, a major transformation of the Crown corporation is required to overcome them.
The group suggests developing the skills of current staff as well as recruiting outside workers with the necessary skills.
Power needed pre Muskrat Falls
Liberty doesn't believe the Holyrood generating units — even if they are returned to full capacity — can be relied upon until the controversial hydroelectic Muskrat Falls project is in service.
Original estimates expected Muskrat Falls to deliver first power in 2017/18, but that date is now expected to be the winter of 2020/21.
"While it had long been contemplated that Muskrat Falls would preclude the need for more supply until the 2030s, this is not likely the case," the report stated.
"Liberty expects that new supply will be needed before Muskrat Falls is in service, to mitigate near-term supply issues, and after Muskrat Falls is in service, to mitigate the impact of extended outages of the Labrador-Island link."
Additional power needed post Muskrat Falls
In a reliability analysis completed by Hydro for the Labrador-Island link, it's possible a full outage — lasting 29 hours, on average — could happen every three years, according to the report.
However, Liberty said Hydro is likely underestimating that number.
"With sufficient backup supply, the duration of customer outages will be limited to a few hours, regardless of the length of the Labrador-Island link," the report stated.
"If there is not sufficient backup supply, there will be additional customer impact, including likely rotating outages for the balance of the Labrador-Island link outage … Adequate backup capacity should be available to prevent extensive and extended loss of load."