New Brunswick

Conservationists call Liberal water strategy 'a sham'

A group of New Brunswick conservationists says the Liberal government's new water strategy process is "a sham."

Province released water strategy discussion paper followed by open house meetings

Conservation groups are angered that the Liberal government's new water strategy process is being rushed through without adequate involvement of the public.

A group of New Brunswick conservationists, led by The Council of Canadians, says the Liberal government's new water strategy process is "a sham."

The Department of Environment and Local Government released a water strategy discussion paper on March 1.

The document includes "draft goals" which are based on the results of two private workshops, attended by government agencies and departments.

Margo Sheppard from The Council of Canadians says the government is not engaging the public enough in the process.

"Less than two weeks later, five open houses were scheduled in rapid succession, with the sixth and last one occurring tomorrow [Wednesday]," said Sheppard. "Think you blinked and missed the boat? You are not alone."

Sharlene Paul from the Wolastoq Grand Council said she didn't know about the open house meetings until Tuesday.

Green Party leader David Coon says he has "no idea" why the Liberal government is developing a new water strategy now. (CBC)
Green Party leader David Coon says the province already has adequate regulations, even if some — like the watershed classification system — has existed for 14 years without ever being fully implemented.

"I have no idea what's going on here, where this came from, why they're pursuing it and why they are rushing through a process," said Coon.

"The premier could establish a select committee on water, [comprised of] all parties, with responsibility to hold public hearings, to hear from the public," he said.

Anti-Sisson mine campaigner Lawrence Wuest did attend an open house meeting. He said the discussion paper appears to ignore the concerns of smaller watershed organizations, like that of the Nashwaak River.

"The motivation for this step backwards is to remove obstacles from its industrial agenda," said Wuest.

"Which includes, most specifically, the Energy East pipeline, the Sisson mine, the Minco PLC manganese mine, and shale gas exploration and development."

14-year controversy

The most contentious aspect of water protection in the province continues to be watershed classification.

Since 2002, 19 watershed associations have submitted proposals for their watersheds to be officially classified and protected. As of today, none have been approved for classification.

Successive governments have said legal issues prevent the implementation of the regulation.

In 2008, Shawn Graham's Liberal government passed an amendment aimed at fixing a legal issue with the regulation.

The Department of Environment and Local Government says fixing the regulation today "would equate to an entire rewrite of that part of the legislation."

In a statement to CBC News the Director of Communications at the department, Jennifer Graham said:

"Some of the challenges include: the Clean Water Act does not provide sufficient authority to support the classification of surface waters;  the water quality standards in the regulation are vague and open to interpretation; and the water quality standards present difficulties for those entrusted with enforcement."

Ombudsman Charles Murray first raised concerns in August 2014 over the Department of Environment's refusal to enforce a regulation that allows for watersheds to be classified. (CBC)
New Brunswick Ombudsman Charles Murray has regularly criticized the government's lack of action on water classification.

Murray has called the regulation "the equivalent of having a smoke detector in your house without batteries."

The last of six water strategy open house meeting is on Wednesday afternoon, March 23, between 4:30 p.m. and 6:30 p.m. at the Fredericton Inn.

After that, members of the public have until April 29 to submit their comments via the Department of Environment website.

The government says it will then prepare a "What We Heard" document, which it will make public, before drafting a water strategy.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.