New Brunswick

Take politics out of education, says teachers' union leader

The head of New Brunswick's teachers' union says the voices of teachers have finally been heard, following the release of a report by the auditor general calling for stability in the provincial education system.

Auditor general’s report detailed instability in New Brunswick's education system

George Daley, president of New Brunswick Teachers' Association, says he wants politics out of the education system. (Catherine Harrop/CBC)

The head of New Brunswick's teachers' union says the voices of teachers have finally been heard, following the release of a report by the auditor general calling for stability in the provincial education system.

Kim MacPherson found that schools are failing to hit performance targets because frequent changes in education strategy "create instability and shift focus away from educating students."

"The system needs to stabilize," MacPherson said.

Her report explained that a student who started school in September 2004 would have experienced five different strategies, each with its own priorities, by the time they graduated.

George Daley, president of the New Brunswick Teachers' Association, offered another statistic: 37 major changes in the past 35 years.

"I now understand why I never felt I could never get my feet under me: because everything was always changing," Daley said.

"There was a new target, there was a new way of doing something, there was a new program, there was a new district office I had to deal with. It was always there."

Assessments indicate students continue to fail to meet targets. Auditor General Kim MacPherson says each time government makes changes to the education plan, it filters down and impacts student performance. 11:06

Daley said the contents of the audit, which also touched on a lack of accountability for school districts, were not surprising. What did surprise him was hearing a government official articulate what he and his members have been saying for years.

"I think there are teachers out there today that are going to read this auditor general's report and say, 'You know, my voice has been finally heard,'" he said.

Policy changes and reversals

The policy changes cover everything from inclusive teaching practices to beefing up security standards, and there have been plenty of reversals, too. Gym teachers and shop class were nixed and restored, while the entry point for French immersion has changed several times.

MacPherson slammed the decision by then-premier Brian Gallant's Liberal government to return to a Grade 1 entry point for French immersion because it gave school districts only one year to implement the change.

Auditor General Kim MacPherson says frequent system changes and lack of accountability have taken a toll on student learning. (CBC)

The education system is still dealing with a shortage of French immersion teachers, said Daley.

Working in a system in constant flux has worn on teachers trying to meet the needs of students without adequate support or funding from the province, he said, suggesting that's leading to earlier retirements and younger people turning away from the profession.

Leave politics out of it, says Daley

The "well-intended" reforms often developed from an election promise or new report that promises to improve the system without understanding its complexities, Daley said.

Change can be a good thing, he said, but it has to be "well thought out, researched, planned, properly implemented," rather than change sparked by political motives.

He want to get politics out of education.

Daley said the role of elected officials should be to establish "realistic goals" for education and then follow up with appropriate funding.

"After that, the decision of how it's applied, what's done, has got to fall back into the hands of the professionals and the educators," he said.

"We need to listen to our teachers, we need to listen to the people in the system."

With files from Catherine Harrop and Jacques Poitras


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.