New Brunswick

'It's very upsetting': Saint John officials disappointed with new NBM in jeopardy

The deferment of the new New Brunswick Museum could cost the City of Saint John the economic boost needed to revitalize its waterfront, according to officials disappointed with the Progressive Conservative government’s capital budget.

The new New Brunswick Museum project was left out of the 2019-20 capital budget

The new New Brunswick Museum project has been put on hold by the new PC government. (CBC)

The deferment of the new New Brunswick Museum could cost the City of Saint John the economic boost needed to revitalize its waterfront, according to officials disappointed with the Progressive Conservative government's capital budget.

The previous Liberal government promised $50 million toward the construction of the proposed four-storey, 120,000-square-foot building next to Market Square in the city's uptown.

That money was nowhere to be found in Tuesday's $600-million budget, which came in at two-thirds what the Liberals had forecast for the 2019-2020 fiscal year. The new museum was among several high-profile projects that were postponed.

"It's a dark day in Saint John to receive news of this magnitude," said Saint John-Rothesay MP Wayne Long, who said he's been working on the proposal for almost three years.

The MP said Ottawa earmarked $25 million for the museum, but the money would only be given if the provincial government triggered the project.

Saint John-Rothesay MP Wayne Long said 'it's a dark day in Saint John' after learning funding for the new New Brunswick Museum isn't in the capital budget. (CBC)

That's money "left on the table," he said.

Long said he understands the Tories' push for austerity measures and balancing the budget, but the New Brunswick Museum is a "treasure for our province" and would act as an economic generator for Saint John and spur development along the waterfront.

"It's an asset that's been ignored by several governments for many, many years," Long said. "We all knew something had to be done with the New Brunswick Museum, so for the provincial Progressive Conservative government to pull the rug out from under the museum is very, very troubling."

Finance Minister Ernie Steeves said continued large-scale deficit spending on infrastructure has worsened the province's net debt, and it needed to be reined in or the province could face a credit rating downgrade.

Finance Minister Ernie Steeves unveiled the 2019-20 capital budget on Tuesday. (Michel Corriveau/Radio-Canada)

"Ultimately, we have to manage our resources and be fiscally smart for the future," Steeves told reporters Tuesday. "There's over $600 million in this budget that's going to help New Brunswickers and that's amazing."

The finance minister said the postponed projects have not been cancelled necessarily and "We'll see where they are next year."

Museum collection under threat

Bill Hicks, CEO of the New Brunswick Museum, was disappointed but not defeated after learning of the news. Hicks said the board and senior management will meet soon and discuss next steps, which include returning to the more than two dozen studies completed over the years on finding a solution for the museum's new home.

The new building would have replaced the institution's current locations — the public exhibit location at Market Square and the archives in an older building on Douglas Avenue.

A proposed design for a new New Brunswick Museum building on part of the former Coast Guard site on Saint John's waterfront. The $100-million project is being re-evaluated by the new Blaine HIggs government. (New Brunswick Museum)

"It's very upsetting," Hicks said.

"The facility issues and the nature of the museum right now, there are some real issues. We have health and safety issues and threats to the collection at Douglas Avenue."

He said building issues at the Market Square location also threaten the collection.

Hicks echoed Long in saying the project would have been a revenue generator and job creator in the heart of the city.

Asked if moving the museum to another city is a possibility, Hicks didn't rule anything out but said Saint John and its harbour are a major hub in the province's cultural, political and economic history, making it the best place to tell New Brunswick stories.

The other postponed projects include:

  • A new Centennial Building and courthouse complex in Fredericton;
  • Route 11 upgrades between Cocagne River and Little Bouctouche River and between Glenwood and Miramichi;
  • planning for a new school in Moncton to replace Bessborough and Hillcrest schools;
  • the design of a new K-8 school in Campbellton;
  • and renovations to the Memramcook Institute.

With files from Julia Wright and Jacques Poitras

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.