New Brunswick

Brian Gallant's minority government defeated after losing confidence vote

Premier Brian Gallant’s minority Liberal government has been defeated in a confidence vote in the New Brunswick Legislature, setting the stage for Progressive Conservative Leader Blaine Higgs to be sworn in as premier in the coming weeks.

Progressive Conservatives and People's Alliance teamed up to topple the Liberal minority government

Brian Gallant loses confidence vote

5 years ago
Duration 1:34
New Brunswick Premier Brian Gallant lost the confidence vote in the legislature 25-23.

Premier Brian Gallant's minority Liberal government has been defeated in a confidence vote in the New Brunswick Legislature, setting the stage for Progressive Conservative Leader Blaine Higgs to be sworn in as premier in the coming weeks.

The house voted 25-23 for a throne speech motion amended by the PC Opposition to declare no confidence in the government.

Twenty-two PC MLAs and three People's Alliance members voted to defeat the government. Twenty Liberals and three Greens voted to keep it alive.

Earlier, a Liberal sub-amendment to the PC amendment, adding a new list of promises to the speech, was defeated by the same margin.

Two men shake hands. The man on the left puts his left hand on the man's upper arm while shaking with his right.
Premier Brian Gallant (left) shakes the hand of Opposition Leader Blaine Higgs (right) after the minority Liberal government was defeated on Friday. (James West/Canadian Press)
The PC no-confidence amendment then passed as written and was incorporated into the main motion.

The three votes followed a final speech by Gallant in which he took responsibility for a fragmented legislature and made a final plea for one PC or Alliance MLA to break ranks.

"One person can literally change the course of history for our province," he said.

Gallant's mea culpas

​The speech was dotted with mea culpas from Gallant: "I'm sorry for not doing better over the last four years to unite our province," he said.

Gallant said he should have talked more about the benefits of official bilingualism, and should have acknowledged as well that some New Brunswickers believed they were losing out because of it.

The election resulted in a fractured electorate split along language and geographical lines, he added, but also an impetus for parties to try harder to collaborate.

Gallant delivers his speech at the closure of the throne speech debate on Friday. Gallant's Liberal government was defeated. (James West/Canadian Press)
"If not, we risk dividing our province more than ever before," he said.

He later told reporters the speech was "definitely the hardest speech I've ever delivered."

"It's hard to admit when you were wrong," he said. "It's hard to admit when you could have done better, especially when it's about people and things you care deeply about."

Gallant said it's too soon to decide whether he'll stay on as Liberal leader and leader of the Official Opposition in the legislature, but he added he'll make that decision soon.

The Liberals' defeat in the legislature represented the climax of an inconclusive Sept. 24 election in which no party won a majority of seats and two relatively new parties took three each.

The Liberals captured 21, one fewer than the PCs, and exercised their right under British parliamentary conventions to try to govern.

That required being able to win the confidence of a majority of MLAs — something they scratched and clawed to obtain in the five weeks after the election.

Gallant also said he had become "too jaded and fell into some of the old adversarial ways of this place" during his years as premier.

He said he would not compromise his stance on constitutional rights to stay in power, citing his decision to eliminate regulations restricting access to hospital abortions and the fact he was the first premier to march in a Pride parade.

Gallant also pleaded a final time for opposition MLAs to support the throne speech, which he defended as a genuine attempt to incorporate their ideas — and which the Tories have derided as a shameless attempt to buy support.

Despite Gallant's plea, the PCs and the Alliance voted against it.

A visit (or 2) to Government House

Once the final vote was read out in the legislature, Gallant stood to accept defeat.

"I will go see the lieutenant-governor at her earliest convenience to inform her that I will be resigning as premier, and I will humbly suggest to her honour to allow the leader of the Conservative Party to attempt to form a government and attempt to gain the confidence of the house," he said.

"All members from our caucus wish the leader of the Opposition and his team the best of luck. Their success will be New Brunswick's success."

Progressive Conservative Leader Blaine Higgs signals to the gallery prior to the closure of the throne speech debate. (James West/Canadian Press)

Higgs and Gallant will have to meet and agree on a date for a transition — the day a PC cabinet would be sworn into office.

"It's been a long, long journey," Higgs said after the house adjourned.

He and Gallant shook hands as the sitting day ended. "He said, 'I want to work together,' and I said the same thing,'" Higgs told reporters.

Green Party Leader David Coon, left, and People's Alliance Leader Kris Austin, right, look on as Gallant delivers his speech. The Green Party supported the Liberal minority government, while the People's Alliance teamed up with the Tories to defeat the government. (James West/Canadian Press)
"I think we have to put the past behind us … because I'm sure there are areas where we have common ground and we have to find them. So I'll be looking."

Higgs said he considered the vote to be a sign that a PC minority government will win the confidence of the house and said he will try to work with all parties.

"We have to set some big lofty goals for our province and achieve them, not talk about them, but achieve them," he said.

'We're going for gold'

He said he hopes to swear in a cabinet next week, with a throne speech by Nov. 20, and to see his government last four years.

"We're going for the gold."

People's Alliance Leader Kris Austin said he'd work with Higgs "in the areas we agree on," and reiterated his promise to support a PC government on confidence votes for 18 months.

But he said that's contingent on some "give and take," including in the upcoming PC throne speech.

Austin said the party would decide how to vote "bill by bill" on other legislation.

"Some bills will get passed, some bills maybe we won't," he said.

Lt.-Gov. Jocelyne Roy Vienneau, shown delivering the throne speech on Oct. 23 at the legislative building, met with Gallant on Friday afternoon. (CBC)
Green Leader David Coon said he would now start working with the Tories to try to ensure his party's issues are on their agenda.

He said he was impressed by the "contrition" Gallant showed for issues he'd handled badly as premier.

"I think it was an important thing that he acknowledged that," Coon said.

Higgs also applauded Gallant's speech, which he said "came from the heart."

But he added the sentiment should have been there during the last four years, not just "in the dying days of a government."

The PC leader and premier-designate admitted that he was "impatient" during the five weeks of uncertainty since the election but ultimately came to understand that he had to let the parliamentary process play out.

Read more on New Brunswick's political situation

On mobile? Follow the live blog here


Jacques Poitras

Provincial Affairs reporter

Jacques Poitras has been CBC's provincial affairs reporter in New Brunswick since 2000. He grew up in Moncton and covered Parliament in Ottawa for the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal. He has reported on every New Brunswick election since 1995 and won awards from the Radio Television Digital News Association, the National Newspaper Awards and Amnesty International. He is also the author of five non-fiction books about New Brunswick politics and history.