Front-yard vegetable garden brings 'a lot of smiles,' but City of Moncton wants it gone
Sylvain Ward says someone complained to the city about his garden
Sylvain Ward never imagined a project he built with his son would cause such a stir.
Ward designed a garden for his front yard, complete with wooden arches and planters that would eventually take the shape of sailing ships.
He is growing mostly beans and peas, and the arches save space, allowing vertical growth.
Ward, who is also a set designer, thought it would be a great way to meet his neighbours.
"We were in a pandemic, and in the pandemic we felt a little bit isolated, and we saw that the neighbours were walking a lot more than usual," Ward said. "So why not create something on our front lawn, to be in our front lawn instead of hiding behind the house."
Ward said many neighbours stopped by to have a look.
"We wanted to inspire a community feeling. We wanted to create something beautiful for the neighbourhood for the community and maybe inspire other people on the street to do the same thing." he said.
But someone registered a complaint with the City of Moncton urban planning department.
Ward said he received a letter on June 1, telling him zoning bylaws determined a front-yard garden is not consistent with the city's definition of "landscaping," and it would have to be removed.
Ward said he was surprised.
"We had a lot of thumbs up, a lot of smiles," he said. "It was really nice to have people smiling in front of our house while we were having a weird time during this pandemic.
"We like to say that maybe it was because our tomatoes were too loud at night."
Ward posted pictures of the garden on Facebook and received more than 175 comments, most of them positive.
He also tried to submit the garden as art, sending a 3D computer rendering of his design to the city. But he said that was also rejected.
Bill Budd, the director of urban planning, said in a statement that a garden similar to what was constructed in the front yard would only be allowed in the backyard.
The zoning bylaw "does not expressly contemplate fruit/or vegetable gardens as it is currently written," Budd acknowledged.
"As a result of this, urban planning will undertake some research on best practice used as it relates to the gardens and urban agriculture in other Canadian municipalities and explore how this may be incorporated in to the zoning bylaw," Budd wrote.
The city says the front lawn garden issue is under review, so Ward will be keeping the garden, at least for the time being.
Ward says his communication with the city over the last month has been positive, and he's hopeful the by-law will be changed.
As for whether people like his garden or not, Ward says beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
"It's entirely up to them if they think it's ugly, it's up to them. If they think it's beautiful it's up to them. Also I'm more than willing to discuss that with them." he said.
"We are doing something for us and if it pleases people that's great."
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?