New Brunswick

Canaport LNG pleads guilty in bird kill case

Canaport LNG Limited Partnership pleaded guilty Thursday to two charges related to the deaths of thousands of songbirds that flew into a natural gas plant's flare in September 2013.

Charges dropped against Irving, Repsol in case that saw 7,500 songbirds die after flying into flare

The Canaport LNG terminal, located on Saint John's east side, is owned by Repsol and Irving Oil Ltd. (CBC)

Canaport LNG has pleaded guilty to federal charges under the Migratory Birds and Species at Risk Act in relation to the 2013 deaths of thousands of songbirds.

The birds were drawn to a 10-to-15 meter gas flare during a period of fog and low cloud.

An agreed statement of facts describes temperatures at the flare as approaching 1,000 C.

Foreseeable risk of serious environmental harm.- Paul Adams, Crown prosecutor

In a short court appearance today, charges were withdrawn against Irving Canaport GP Ltd. and Repsol Canada Ltd., two shareholders in Canaport LNG. 

The company was then sentenced to fines and penalties totalling $750,000. The money is to be directed to a variety of conservation, research and scholarship projects under the management of U.N.B., Nature Canada, Bird Studies Canada and the New Brunswick Museum. 

Crown prosecutor Paul Adams told the court the company was aware there was "foreseeable risk of serious environmental harm" before the September, 2013 flare incident.
A large number of red-eyed vireos were among the estimated 7,500 migrating songbirds killed by the flare at Canaport LNG. (Courtesy of the Migration Research Foundation)

In the statement of facts agreed to by Canaport as part of the plea deal, it said a 2008 report commissioned by the company noted a "combination of nocturnal flaring and unsettled [foggy] weather conditions during peak migration periods created the potential for a significant bird mortality event."

We accept full responsibility.- Pedro Boyra, Canaport LNG 

The statement of facts also said there had been a similar, though significantly smaller, incident two weeks before the major bird kill, when between 50 and 200 birds died. "Despite the known risk," said the document, "Canaport LNG failed to take all reasonable steps to minimize the risk."

An estimated 7,500 songbirds died overnight on Sept. 14 and 15, 2013, when they flew into, or near, the flare.  

Twenty-six separate species of migratory birds died in the incident, including a large number of red-eyed vireos, several types of warblers, including parulas, black-and-white, magnolias and redstarts, as well as thrushes and rose-breasted grosbeaks.

Four of the birds were Canada Warblers, listed as a "threatened species."

As part of its sentence, the company will monitor bird migration forecasts on a weekly basis.

Shortly after the 2013 incidents Canaport LNG completed a $45 million upgrade, which largely eliminated the use of flaring.

Canaport 'regrets the harm'

Canaport LNG issued a statement following today's plea. 

"Canaport LNG sincerely regrets the harm caused in this incident," Canaport LNG General Manager Pedro Boyra said in the statement.

"This has been a difficult and regrettable matter and we accept full responsibility. Since the incident more than two years ago, we have taken significant actions to prevent such an incident from reoccurring. It is constructive to have resolution in a manner that improves understanding of migratory bird populations and promotes conservation efforts."



To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?