New Brunswick

Fredericton High School dress code defended by superintendent

The superintendent of the Anglophone West School District is defending the dress code that's in effect at Fredericton High School amid accusation that the long-standing policy promotes “rape culture.”

Anglophone West School District superintenent David McTimoney will meet with dress code opponents

Dress code defended

8 years ago
Duration 2:10
The superintendent of the Anglophone West School District is defending the dress code that's in effect at Fredericton High School amid accusation that the long-standing policy promotes “rape culture.”

The superintendent of the Anglophone West School District is defending the dress code that's in place at Fredericton High School amid accusations that the policy promotes “rape culture.”

The Fredericton Youth Feminists recently released a video that takes aim at the high school’s dress code.

The group says the dress code promotes a rape culture by blaming female victims for attracting male aggression.

David McTimoney, the district superintendent, said the dress code is necessary to help establish self-respect and respect toward others in the school.

“To me, it comes down to respect for self, respect for others, when we talk about student attire or for that matter the adults in the building who are working and the clothing that they choose,” he said.

FHS dress code

When at school, all members of the education community are expected to dress in a neat, clean, modest and 
appropriate manner. Examples of inappropriate dress are such items that expose undergarments, clothing that 
promotes drugs/alcohol, profanity, sex, discrimination or violence. From the time you enter school in the morning 
until you leave at the end of the day, all hats and inappropriate headwear are to be removed.

The superintendent also said he disagrees with the group’s premise that the dress code promotes a rape culture.

“I have to 100 per cent say that the Anglophone West School District is not an organization that would support or condone a rape culture,” he said.

The school’s dress code states that all members of the school community are “expected to dress in a neat, clean, modest and appropriate manner.”

The group’s video and the reaction has prompted a meeting with the district’s administration next week.

“It's very clear that these ladies would like to be heard and I'm someone who needs to listen to them,” he said.

As for changing the dress code, McTimoney said it's too early to say whether that might happen following the meeting.

"I understand that these students are saying, 'Well, who is it that judges what is respectful and what is not?'" he said.

"That's where I think it's important that we sit and chat about that, and talk about perspectives that perhaps they haven't thought of, as well as perspectives that I may not have thought of and school administration may not have thought of."

Fredericton Youth Feminists released a video that says the Fredericton High School's dress code unfairly targets young women and promotes the idea that sexual assault should be blamed on the woman.
Lisa Dawn Hamilton, a psychology professor at Mount Allison University, studies youth sexuality.

She said dress codes that claim to be gender neutral are effectively biased against females.

And she said enforcement of these policies creates their own set of problems.

“The teachers have to say, ‘You're showing too much leg or I can see your stomach or I can see your bra straps,’” she said.

“And so the teachers themselves are both policing their bodies, but also sexualizing these young women who might have just been wearing shorts that were available to them at the store.”

The Fredericton Youth Feminists are also circulating a petition, which has now collected more than 1,000 signatures, that calls for a district-wide sexual harassment policy.

McTimoney said the district doesn't tolerate harassment and all complaints are taken very seriously.

There has also been discussion about a student walkout on Friday at Fredericton High School in protest against the dress code.

The superintendent said the walkout would be unnecessary.

“It seems to me that this particular group is interested in getting the attention of the school principal and the school district in trying to promote change and what they see as an unacceptable policy,” he said.

“I think with all of the attention that has been received, they have achieved their goal. They have got that attention. To me, it would be very disappointing if students decided to do that. It’s not necessary; it won’t change anything.”


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?