New Brunswick

Public health specialist sees 'weakening' of New Brunswick system

The New Brunswick government's decision to dismantle the Office of the Chief Medical Officer of Health could put peoples' lives in danger, according to a public health expert.

Removal of duties from central office has already been shown not to work, Montreal professor says

Dr. Ak'ingabe Guyon, a public health and preventive medicine specialist, says the the New Brunswick government's decision to remove a lot of public health duties from the Office of the Chief Medical Officer of Health suggests a lack of understanding of what public health is all about.

The New Brunswick government's decision to dismantle the Office of the Chief Medical Officer of Health could put peoples' lives in danger, according to a public health expert.

"Weakening a prevention system is never, ever a good solution," said Dr. Ak'Ingabe Guyon, a public health and preventive medicine specialist and assistant clinical professor in the school of public health at the University of Montreal.

And fragmenting the office of the chief medical health "would seriously be weakening public health," she said.

Before he was dropped from cabinet, former health minister Victor Boudreau announced in August the provincial government was restructuring the office and spreading some operations to other government departments.

Boudreau did not offer any specific reasons for the move, saying only that it was to "improve collaboration" and allow the province to "pool together similar professional sets of expertise within government." 

Boudreau's successor, Benoît Bourque, has not provided an explanation either.

But Guyon said the recent changes could be the result of a misunderstanding of what public health does, since often it's not very visible.

"We know what happens when we go to a hospital," she said.

"We don't always know the background work that happens so that our water is safe, our food is safe."

She said the system also prevents avoidable diseases and outbreaks, such as measles, and it attempts to curb the use of tobacco.

"Prevention should never be seen as an expense, it's really an investment," she said.

The work of public health and agri-food inspectors will now be looked after by the Department of Justice and Public Safety.

At the end of August, Victor Boudreau, who was health minister at the time, announced the province was spreading public health responsibilities among several departments. (CBC)

The public health practice and population health branch will become part of the Department of Social Development and the healthy environments branch will be integrated into the Department of Environment and Local Government.

Guyon said scientific evidence is very clear in that governments do not increase efficiencies by "dismantling a public health team."   

"There are already teams, they should be maintained, they should be strengthened," she said.

"This saves lives but it also saves money."

Quick reaction essential 

And in a major health crisis, Guyon said, it's even more critical to have a clear command system and to have cohesive teams in prevention in public health. 

"People need to know each other well in advance of crises to be effective when something happens and you need to react within seconds, minutes, hours." she said.

There are several features that make a strong public health system, she said, such as staffing with dedicated professionals and a good investment in  public health.

Provinces to emulate 

Provinces like British Columbia, Ontario and even Quebec demonstrate a strong public health system, she said.

Ontario learned the hard way about the dangers of weakening the system during Walkerton E. coli contamination tragedy, when seven people died and more than 2,300 became ill in May 2000.

In 2002, Justice Dennis O'Connor issued a report saying Canada's worst E. coli outbreak could have been prevented by the Ontario government.

"[It] turned healthy people into very ill people," she said.  ​


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.