New Brunswick

National civil liberties group backs call for release of police shooting tape

The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has added its voice to a call to release body camera footage from a fatal police shooting in Rothesay.

Access to tape important so public can see police interaction with mentally ill man, group says

A police officer in Toronto tries on a body camera. (CBC)

The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has added its voice to a call to release body camera footage from a fatal police shooting in Rothesay.

The organization has been vocal about privacy issues that come with police wearing body cameras.

But having public access to the tape is important, so the public can see how police interacted with a man who was mentally ill, acting executive director Noa Mendelsohn Aviv said.

"There is a strong public interest in knowing what happened and a need for the public to be able to see for themselves."

Anne Bertrand, New Brunswick's access to information and privacy commissioner, has called for the release of the tape, saying that public interest outweighs privacy in this case.

Her decision came after a 15-month access to information battle by CBC News. Police had argued against releasing the video, citing privacy concerns.

The tape was recorded by the officer who shot and killed William David McCaffrey at his family's home in Rothesay in 2014.

Officer cleared of wrongdoing

Steve Palmer, chief of the Kennebecasis Regional Police Force, says he hasn't decided whether he'll follow a recommendation to release body camera footage from a fatal shooting in Rothesay. (Kennebecasis Regional Police Force)
When officers from the Kennebecasis Regional Police Force arrived on scene, McCaffrey was having a mental health emergency.

According to a description of the footage, police tried to reason with him.

When McCaffrey began to harm himself, an officer tried to use a Taser on him, but it didn't make contact with his skin.

He then lunged at police, with knives in his hands.

"Fearing for safety, one police officer discharged his firearm twice," Bertrand wrote in her report.

The Kennebecasis Regional Police Force asked RCMP to investigate the shooting. RCMP determined that reasonable force was used.

"The public's confidence in the past few years in policing has been eroding," Kennebecasis regional police chief Steve Palmer said in an interview.

"But at some point in time, I think they have to have some confidence in some people that are providing the oversight, that they're doing what's appropriate."

Body cameras not common in Canada

Noa Mendelsohn Aviv, director of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association's equality program, supports the call for releasing the video. (Canadian Civil Liberties Association)
But Mendelsohn Aviv says it isn't good enough for police to ask the public to trust them.

She wants to see the police force release the video so people can see for themselves.

"If police believe they were upholding the law and appropriately handling a situation, then they too should have an interest in releasing that video," Mendelsohn Aviv said.

Bertrand's decision could put police forces across the country on notice that body camera footage may find its way into the public realm, according to Christopher J. Schneider, an associate professor of sociology at Brandon University.

"This might actually contribute to police forces not wanting to use cameras," said Schneider, who researches the impact of body-worn cameras in policing.

A ruling that calls for the release of body camera footage could discourage police forces from using the cameras, according to Christopher Schneider, an associate professor of sociology at Brandon University. (Tiffany Green)
Though he supports Bertrand's decision, Schneider questions the public value of releasing the tape in this case, since the officer has already been cleared of wrongdoing.

"I'm not entirely sure what benefit is going to be gained by the public seeing this," he said.

Could discourage use of body cameras

A relatively new concept in Canada, body-worn cameras are much more common in the United States. Several states have laws that permit the release of footage captured on the cameras.

Bertrand suggested her ruling could be the first Canadian test of how to handle footage from a body-worn camera and she hopes it will serve as a precedent.

But many questions around the use of the cameras remain.

The Canadian Civil Liberties Organization has said the cameras are a key accountability tool.

The organization has also expressed concern about when officers are turning the cameras on or off and the privacy of the people who appear in the footage.

Bertrand's office doesn't have the power to make an order, and the Kennebecasis force isn't required to follow her recommendation.

Palmer, the police chief, has said he is studying the decision and obtaining legal advice on what to do next.

McCaffrey's family declined an interview request, asking for privacy.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?