How the COVID-19 crisis in Quebec's nursing homes unfolded
More than 1,000 of the 1,340 Quebecers who have died from COVID-19 were seniors in care
The first health-care worker at a Quebec long-term care home to test positive for COVID-19 had, like thousands of other Quebecers, recently returned from a trip abroad during the province's early March break.
Her case was reported March 14 by the health board for the Lanaudière region, just northeast of Montreal. In retrospect, it was a warning of how easily the coronavirus could enter seniors' residential institutions, known in the province as CHSLDs.
One day before, in what had seemed like an harsh measure to some, Premier François Legault had banned visits to all seniors' homes when he declared a public health emergency.
It was already too late.
Outbreaks were reported at a number of residences in the following days. On March 18, Mariette Tremblay, 82, a resident of a private seniors' home in the same Lanaudière region, died of COVID-19 and became Quebec's first known victim of the pandemic. She had had a visit from a family member back from a trip.
Infection spread through a Sherbrooke seniors' home, too, after a family reunion.
Vectors of the coronavirus — family and health-care staff returning from abroad — had entered the CHSLDs, home to the province's most vulnerable to the disease, long before Legault called for an end to visits.
But a failure to respond quickly and effectively in the weeks since has allowed COVID-19 to spread almost unhindered in dozens of homes, according to interviews with health-care workers, union representatives and a review of documents that demonstrate a lack of clear directives.
Workers on the front lines describe chaos inside the homes as increasing numbers of staff and residents fell sick, including a lack of protective equipment for themselves and residents who had not yet caught the disease.
They also say whatever measures were in place to prevent spread of the virus weren't fully respected. Some workers who tested positive say they were ordered to return work before the end of their quarantine.
Now residents of those homes account for the vast majority of the COVID-19 death toll in Quebec. Of the 1,340 dead tallied so far in Quebec, 1,057 were seniors in care.
The crisis is far from over. More than 80 homes considered "critical" by the province, a number that has doubled in the past week.
At least 4,000 health-care workers have tested positive for COVID-19 and another 5,500 are absent from work, making it difficult for many CHSLDs to provide the most basic care.
One emergency room doctor at Montreal's Jewish General Hospital has described how patients are being wheeled into the ER, not sick from COVID-19, but because they are dehydrated and malnourished.
Slow to adapt after focus on hospitals
When a woman who had been travelling in Iran was reported to be the first case in the province Feb. 28, the province said the threat was still minimal — and the focus was on preparing hospitals.
"All the measures that are necessary to protect the population, to protect the workers and take care of the patients, if it occurs, are there," Danielle McCann, the provincial health minister, said at the time.
But as it became clear the bigger threat was in long-term care homes and other kinds of seniors' residences, the province was critcized for being slow to reallocate resources and staff.
Alain Croteau, a union president representing workers at the Centre-Sud-de-l'Île-de-Montréal health agency, described the response as "very chaotic, very disorganized."
By March 30, two weeks after the ban on visits to hospitals and seniors' homes, the province announced the number of cases had surpassed 3,000.
That day, it announced $133 million in emergency funding for CHSLDs and other kinds of seniors' establishments.
"We will be able to hire more staff, buy more protective equipment and more disinfectant," said Quebec's minister for seniors, Marguerite Blais.
In the weeks that followed, however, it became clear many residences were still operating without enough gloves, masks or gowns.
Workers in Laurentians bought their own, for instance. So did nurses in Laval, fundraising with colleagues on social media and buying N95 masks and Bauer visors from friends of friends.
Directives published March 25 by Laval's health board stated staff in CHSLDs don't have to wear N95s, even when treating COVID-positive patients, unless the patients are on oxygen machines.
"The reason for that remains nebulous to me," said Jessika Côté, an emergency room nurse in Laval. She was reassigned to work at a hard-hit seniors' residence, CHSLD Sainte-Dorothée, where at least 74 patients have died and more than 90 per cent of residents have tested positive.
Even before the pandemic, CHSLDs across the province struggled to recruit enough nurses and patient attendants to provide quality care. Recognizing that poor pay could trigger absenteeism and make a chronic staffing shortage even worse, on April 1, the Quebec government boosted wages by eight per cent in public CHSLDs, and by $4 an hour in private long-term care homes.
But as conditions grew worse and more and more health-care workers started getting sick, workers who had tested positive for COVID-19 were ordered to return to CHSLDs before the end of a normally compulsory 14-day quarantine.
At CHSLD Laflèche, a long-term care home in Shawinigan, for instance, workers who had been exposed to COVID-19 were told to leave isolation early because there was no staff to replace them.
In early April, McCann defended the decision, saying it was "exceptional" and based on "scientific advice" provided by Quebec's public health institute.
"Leaving people all by themselves without services — we cannot do that," she said.
The government still has not banned outright the practice of health-care workers putting in shifts at more than one nursing home, despite warnings from workers of the increased risk of spreading the virus.
Côté, the ER nurse, believes there would be thousands fewer health-care workers absent or sick today if the province had provided workers with the right equipment and clearer directives.
When she arrived at CHSLD Sainte-Dorothée on April 3, Côté said managers didn't even know she was coming and didn't give her any training.
She was sent to one of the home's hot zones, where she scrambled to provide residents a minimum of care.
Côté says the CHSLD only provided a surgical face mask, a gown and a pair of gloves.
In the days that followed, she observed staff circulating between cold and hot zones without changing gowns — a major potential vector for the virus, she said.
Instead of changing gloves, many would simply wash or sanitize them, she said.
Côté said the circumstances only got worse in the days that followed — a heavier workload, more deaths, and COVID-positive patients being transferred back into areas where some hadn't yet caught the disease.
"They said that since most of the CHSLD was contaminated anyway, there was no point having designated zones," Côté said.
Côté said she and her colleagues cried every day.
"The co-ordinator would go from nurse to nurse, and we would all be in tears because we just couldn't anymore," she said.
Of the 25 ER nurses who were sent to work in Laval CHSLDs, Côté said, nine have since caught the coronavirus.
Côté is one of them.
As awful as COVID-19 can be, Côté said, it was a relief when she received her positive result over a week ago.
"I love my work, so I don't like saying this, but it finally gave me a break," she said. In a few days, she'll be going back to Sainte-Dorothée, where she's heard things are a little better.
Offers of help, unheeded
In recent weeks, as the crisis has become even more acute, Legault has repeatedly called on health-care workers to help staff the besieged nursing homes.
But many say they put their names forward early in the pandemic but weren't able to secure a position, with the hiring bureaucracy overwhelmed.
Natalie Stake-Doucet, the president of Quebec's nurses association, said she tried for weeks to offer her assistance at a CHSLD.
"It took, finally, talking directly to someone who I know who happens to be a manager and got me a job," she said.
"When I got there, it was devastation. I've never seen anything like it. It was shocking and sad and overwhelming," she said.
Stake-Doucet, now a PhD candidate and nursing instructor at the Université de Montréal, stopped working full-time as a nurse two years ago, in part out of frustration over the impact of cuts to the health-care network on patient care.
She blames health reforms imposed by the previous Liberal government on the breakdown in communication between health authorities and health-care workers on the front lines. She said the chronic staff shortages in the CHSLDs prior to the crisis have made the problem even worse.
In his daily briefings, Legault has said repeatedly that the time will come to examine all that went wrong. In a strikingly frank mea culpa a week ago, the premier said he takes "full responsibility" and is filled with remorse that "we didn't better care for the elderly, the most vulnerable."
On Friday, he said he is "not excluding" the possibility of taking over all private seniors' homes and creating a network of more spacious, better-staffed and more home-like residences for the aged across the province.
He said he'd learned "a big lesson" about the need for less crowding and more staff.
The outbreak of COVID-19 in Quebec's long-term care institutions, Legault said, has been like setting fire to hay.
"Everything burns rapidly," he said.