Andrew Scheer treads a thin, blue line by courting Quebec nationalists

In the wake of the province's secularism law, the Bloc Québécois's stubborn popularity could make life difficult for the Tories in Quebec.

Why the Bloc Québécois's stubborn popularity could make life difficult for Tories

Conservative Party Leader Andrew Scheer tours the grounds of the Saint-Hyacinthe agricultural fair on Tuesday. Scheer is travelling around Quebec all week. (Ivanoh Demers/Radio-Canada)

When Andrew Scheer, the federal Conservative leader, walked onto the grounds of an agricultural fair in Saint-Hyacinthe, Que., on Tuesday, he took one look at a combine and immediately felt at home. 

"That's an image that's close to my heart," said the Saskatchewan MP, pointing to the mammoth piece of harvesting machinery that dots the fields of his home province.

Saint-Hyacinthe, population 53,000, is an hour's drive east of Montreal and hosts the largest agricultural fair in Quebec every summer.

It is also the site of a federal riding that many expect will be among the most hotly contested in the province.

Saint-Hyacinthe–Bagot is currently in the hands of the NDP. But the party's polling numbers in Quebec have dropped dramatically since 2015, and it will struggle to hold onto its ridings outside Montreal. 

The other federal parties, meanwhile, have been circling like vultures around the remnants of the 2011 Orange Wave. Scheer's visit on Wednesday was no accident. 

Scheer toured the fair with the Conservative candidate in Saint-Hyacinthe–Bagot, Bernard Barré, left. Barré is best-known to Quebecers as a boxing analyst. (Ivanoh Demers/Radio-Canada)

Saint-Hyacinthe–Bagot is one of several ridings in the Quebec heartland, between Montreal and Quebec City, where three-way races are shaping up ahead of the October election.

But unlike in 2015, it's not the NDP that will be joining the Liberals and Conservatives in the ring: it's the Bloc Québécois.

Back from the dead

The sovereigntist party was written off as good as dead a year ago, thanks to the kamikaze-inspired leadership style of Martine Ouellet which eventually led to a caucus revolt.

Since her ignominious departure, the party has found a new leader — Yves-François Blanchet — who has reunited the caucus and now has the Bloc polling just under 20 per cent, according to CBC's poll tracker.

In Saint-Hyacinthe, local Bloc candidate Simon-Pierre Savard-Tremblay says the party has benefited from what he calls Quebec's "new political context" — the unapologetically nationalist government of François Legault and the Coalition Avenir Québec. 

Exhibit A of the new political climate is, arguably, the CAQ's so-called secularism law, which bars teachers and other authority figures from wearing religious symbols at work. 

Though minority groups argue the law is discriminatory and have filed a constitutional challenge in Quebec Superior Court, it appears to enjoy widespread support in the province.

Simon-Pierre Savard-Tremblay, the Bloc candidate in Saint-Hyacinthe-Bagot, says the party will benefit from what he calls Quebec's 'new political context.' (Jonathan Montpetit/CBC)

Many of the fair-goers in Saint-Hyacinthe have yet to decide who will get their vote in the federal election. But many voted for the CAQ in the fall provincial election and support the religious symbols law. 

"We had to clear up what secularism is," said Raymond Aubé, a semi-retired technician, as he enjoyed a hot dog with his wife.

"Our premier did what we wanted."

Blanchet, who took over the Bloc in January, has vowed to defend the law from federal interference and to serve as a spokesperson for other parts of the CAQ's nationalist agenda.

"The table is set for us to make gains," said Savard-Tremblay, a 30-year-old political columnist who holds a PhD from a prestigious Paris university.

But as the Bloc uses the religious symbols law to amplify its own nationalist appeal, Scheer's task of winning seats in Quebec's heartland becomes more difficult. 

Like his Liberal and NDP counterparts, Scheer has expressed his opposition to the legislation, promising a federal Conservative government would never table similar legislation.

'Our party will always stand up for individual rights and freedoms. That is our position,' Scheer said when asked about Quebec's religious symbols law. (Ivanoh Demers/Radio-Canada)

But he, too, has made a show of burnishing his party's nationalist credentials in Quebec. 

Back in May, he recruited former Bloc leader Michel Gauthier to make the case to voters in the province that the Tories could be strong defenders of Quebec's interests. 

Some small-c conservatives in Quebec, moreover, seem to expect Scheer will be more favourable to the secularism law than Conservative premiers, such as Manitoba's Brian Pallister, who called it "dangerous" and "un-Canadian."

Éric Duhaime — a popular, and populist, Quebec radio host — wrote an op-ed in La Presse earlier this month that predicted a surge in support for the Conservatives come election time. 

"The message of Quebec conservatives, who respect Quebec's right to impose secularism, is agreeably at odds with certain conservatives elsewhere in the country," Duhaime wrote.

No place like home

On Tuesday, Scheer was again asked about his position on the religious symbols law.

"Our message to Quebec is that the Conservative Party will be there to champion Quebec's interests. On this particular piece of legislation, I've made my views on that known," he said.

Minority groups in Quebec and elsewhere in Canada have expressed frustration with what they see as a tepid response by all the main federal leaders to the law.

Last week, campaigning in a small city just up the road from Saint-Hyacinthe, NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh upped the tone of his criticism.

"There are a lot of people in Quebec who don't feel this is the right way to go, and I can be their champion," he said.

Saint-Hyacinthe, population 53,000, is an hour's drive east of Montreal, is host to the largest agricultural fair in Quebec every summer. (Jonathan Montpetit/CBC)

Scheer was invited to make a similar commitment to lead federal opposition to the law. He avoided pledging to go that far. 

"Our party will always stand up for individual rights and freedoms. That is our position," the Conservative leader said. 

"And as this process works its way through the courts, we'll watch it. But the message is: the federal Conservative party will never propose these types of initiatives at a federal level."

But if the Bloc continues to increase the volume on its support for the controversial law, Scheer may no longer get that warm, fuzzy feeling in places like Saint-Hyacinthe.

About the Author

Jonathan Montpetit is a journalist with CBC Montreal.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.