Quebec proposes cutting maintenance budget of half-empty schools

English school boards are worried that one of the cuts imposed by the province will hurt schools with dwindling enrolment.

Schools at less than 50 per cent capacity could lose maintenance funding starting this fall

Springdale Elementary School in DDO, on Montreal's West Island, is at 48 per cent capacity. (CBC)

English school boards are worried that one of the cuts imposed by the province will disproportionately affect English schools.

Quebec's Education Ministry wants to cut funding for maintenance and building upkeep at schools that are at less than half-full.

At the English Montreal School Board, that would affect more than a dozen elementary schools and at least three high schools.

At the Lester B. Pearson School Board, three elementary and three high schools fall into that category — including Thorndale Elementary School in Pierrefonds, which is at 44 per cent capacity.

"What are the schools supposed to do? Just let the schools fall apart?" said Sergey Gritsenko, a parent whose children go to Thorndale.

"It's hard that all these cuts are coming," said parent Lisa Labelle.

New provincial rules say any school operating at less than 50% capacity, and that has nearby schools that could take its students, would be cut off from maintenance and upkeep funding starting in the fall.

That would include cutting things like day-to-day upkeep as well as major repairs, such as a new roof.

The boards say some schools with low enrolment are kept open on purpose.

"There are some schools we've chosen to keep open with low enrolment because they're in underprivileged areas," said Suanne Stein Day, chair of the Lester B. Pearson School Board

The boards say if the cuts to maintenance take effect this fall, they'll have to absorb the maintenance costs because the law forbids them from closing any schools without holding a year-long consultation.

"The deadline has come and gone. There's not going to be any closures. That's for certain," said EMSB commissioner Sylvia Lo Bianco.

The budget measures have left boards wondering if the government is trying to force them to consider closing schools with dwindling populations.

"This, I see as a direct attack on the English schools," said Stein Day.

Education Minister Francois Blais said the government just wants to "identify" underused schools where it could cut costs.

"The objective is certainly not to close schools," Blais said.

Montreal elementary schools at less less than 50 per cent capacity:

  • Coronation School (EMSB): 22%
  • Dalkeith (EMSB): 27%
  • Edward Murphy (EMSB): 45%
  • Elizabeth Ballantyne (EMSB): 47%
  • General Vanier (EMSB): 46%
  • Gerald McShane (EMSB): 33%
  • Hampstead (EMSB): 41%
  • John Caboto (EMSB): 33%
  • Nesbitt (EMSB): 48%
  • Sinclair Laird (EMSB): 40%
  • St. Dorothy (EMSB): 35%
  • St. Monica (EMSB): 47%
  • Thorndale (LBPSB): 44%
  • Springdale (LBPSB): 48%
  • Verdun Elementary (LBPSB): 27%

Montreal high schools at less less than 50 per cent capacity:

  • John Grant (EMSB) 32%*
  • James Lyng (EMSB): 30%*
  • John F. Kennedy (EMSB): 24%*
  • Marymount Academy (EMSB): 39%
  • Rosemount (EMSB): 36%*
  • Royal Vale (EMSB): 28%**
  • Horizon (LBPSB): 50%
  • Lindsay Place (LBPSB): 43%
  • Riverdale (LBPSB): 45%

*Shares space with an adult education centre or vocational centre

**Shares space with an elementary school and EMSB Trades Division


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.