Montreal

Learn French in 6 months? Quebec-commissioned report shows why that's nearly impossible

A report commissioned by the Quebec government — and then kept hidden — lays out in detail why many newcomers are likely to require more than six months to learn French, contrary to new rules put forward in the province's updated language law.

New language law flies in face of research detailing challenges facing asylum seekers

Protesters are seen marching through downtown Montreal last month. Bill 96 was adopted into law soon after, on May 24. (Graham Hughes/The Canadian Press)

A report commissioned by the Quebec government — and then kept hidden — lays out in detail why many newcomers are likely to require more than six months to learn French, contrary to new rules put forward in the province's updated language law.

The study was ordered by the province's Immigration Ministry in 2019 and presented in April 2021, a month before the Coalition Avenir Québec government introduced Bill 96.

It was never made public, and was obtained by CBC News under access-to-information legislation.

As part of the qualitative study, researchers interviewed 58 adults who had recently arrived in Quebec from countries around the world. The most common were Syria, Afghanistan, Pakistan and Burundi.

The focus in particular was on what changes could be made to a government-funded French program to improve outcomes for those without a strong educational background. Some of those interviewed were unable to read in their native language.

The challenges documented in the report range from practical aspects of settling in a new place, such as finding a job and a place to live, to dealing with the trauma newcomers experienced in their home countries.

Garine Papazian-Zohrabian, associate professor in educational psychology at the Université de Montréal, conducted the research with the help of her students.

Garine Papazian-Zohrabian is an associate professor in educational psychology at Université de Montréal. She says new immigrants to Quebec are often leaving behind difficult and dangerous situations and need more than six months to be able to learn basic French. (Submitted by Janet Cleveland)

Papazian-Zohrabian said she was surprised and disappointed when she first saw what was in Bill 96. 

"They asked for it, they paid for it and they disregarded the report that came out of it," Papazian-Zohrabian said in an interview, referring to the provincial government.

The study was never published on the Immigration Ministry's website, in contrast to other commissioned research.

In a statement Monday, spokesperson Gabriel Bélanger said the study was not made public because it was created for "administrative purposes."

In response to CBC's question about whether the study was used to help draft Bill 96, Bélanger said it was shared with the province's newly formed French language ministry, which is responsible for implementing Bill 96, on June 10.

That's the same day CBC submitted questions to the Immigration Ministry.

'Inhuman' and 'discriminating'

In Papazian-Zohrabian's view, "disregarding the needs of the most vulnerable immigrant population" is "inhuman, and at the same time, it's also discriminating."

Papazian-Zohrabian originally relayed her frustration in an interview with La Presse last month. The Immigration Ministry did not share the report with the journalist, Rima Elkouri.

Totaling 147 pages, the document includes a list of recommendations to assist immigrants in learning French. 

The first recommendation is to give learners the time to settle in Quebec before beginning French courses.

Others include working more closely with community groups to help newcomers, particularly those dealing with past trauma, and reviewing the learning approaches by French-as-a-second-language courses.

Despite Papazian-Zohrabian's concerns, and those raised by other experts and community groups who work with newcomers, the legislation was passed last month without modification to the six-month clause. 

Dina Souleiman, executive director of the Welcome Collective, which helps asylum seekers in their first months — getting them furniture and other basic essentials — said the new rules present "another obstacle we're going to add to helping somebody integrate."

"I don't think you need to be a professional in this field to understand that it doesn't make any sense," she said.

Confusion around how law will be applied

Under the new rules, refugees and immigrants moving to Quebec will be allowed to access services in English or another language for the first six months after their arrival.

After that, government services will be provided exclusively in French, save for exceptions in a few areas, such as health services and public safety.

Quebec Justice Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette, recently appointed the province's first minister of the French language, has been the pointperson on Bill 96. (Jacques Boissinot/The Canadian Press)

It's not yet clear how the rules for new immigrants in Bill 96 will be enforced.

Élisabeth Gosselin-Bienvenue, a spokesperson for the minister responsible for the French language, Simon Jolin-Barrette, recently told CBC that legislation won't begin to be applied for another year. 

Over the next six months, the province will set up the French language ministry, and that ministry will come up with a linguistic policy for the entire public service and all municipalities and government organizations.

Papazian-Zohrabian said she is hopeful that whoever wins the next election will be "flexible and understanding" in their application of the law.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Benjamin Shingler is a reporter with CBC in Montreal covering health and current affairs. He previously worked at The Canadian Press, Al Jazeera America and the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now