Quebec election debates leave out some leaders

Four campaign debates – one on Radio-Canada and three on rival network TVA – leave some leaders in the cold.
Workers prep the 2008 Quebec election campaign debate stage. Four television debates are scheduled for the 2012 campaign. (Canadian Press)

Some Quebec political party leaders are sparring over campaign debates announced today. 

A consortium of public broadcasters, including Radio-Canada and Télé-Québec, will air a French-language debate on August 19.

The debate will feature the leaders of Quebec's four major parties — the Liberals, Parti Québécois, Coalition Avenir Québec and Québec Solidaire. Upstart sovereigntist party Option Nationale is excluded from the main debate.

Rival private television network TVA will host its own set of one-on-one debates August 20, 21 and 22, between the Liberal, PQ and CAQ leaders.

Quebec's four main leaders will take part in a televised debate on CBC's French-language service August 19. (Radio-Canada)

Québec Solidaire and Option Nationale aren't invited to the TVA podium.

The co-founder of Québec Solidaire, Françoise David, said Thursday that TVA's exclusion "is unfair, simply unfair."

Québec Solidaire member Amir Khadir represented the party as an elected member during the last government. That should give the party standing in any high-profile debate, David said.

Option Nationale Leader Jean-Martin Aussant is also complaining about being left out of the campaign debates.

In a written statement, Aussant said Quebec election laws are very clear on the subject.

"Leaders' coverage has to be the same. If there is a leaders' debate, I have to be invited. I intend to make sure my rights are respected," he wrote.

Quebec's Electoral Office (DGEQ) said the legal provision Aussant refers to doesn't apply to leaders' debates, as they are considered to be public affairs broadcasts.

Election watchers meanwhile praised TVA's one-on-one debate format.

Montreal-based communications professor Maurice Charland predicts the tête-à-tête concept will deliver in-depth discussion of key campaign issues.

"When you have a debate with more people, I think you're going to have a tendency for more sloganeering," said Charland, who teaches at Concordia University.

TVA's debates will focus on four themes: the economy, governance, social policies, and national identity.



Radio-Canada/Télé-Québec, August 19

  • Liberal Leader Jean Charest.
  • Parti Québécois Leader Pauline Marois.
  • Coalition Avenir Québec Leader Francois Legault.
  • Quebec Solidaire co-founder Françoise David.



  • August 20: Charest vs Marois.
  • August 21: Charest vs Legault.
  • August 22: Marois vs Legault.