Montreal

What needs to be fixed in Quebec's daycare system

Quebec's daycare system is hailed as model and while it has allowed more women to join the workforce, its popularity has led to a shortage of spaces. As the province looks to address the problems, here is a breakdown of the issues.

CBC Quebec has spent the past month digging deep into some of the biggest challenges, and successes of the day

Quebec's public daycare program was introduced in 1997 by the Parti Québécois and the current family minster says he wants to 'complete the system.' (Carl Boivin/Radio-Canada)

Quebec Family minister Mathieu Lacombe says the daycare system needs to be "put back on track" and he wants to "complete the system" which was first introduced in 1997 by Parti Québécois Family Minister Pauline Marois. He promises to table a new bill in the fall.

According to the Family Ministry, there are 51,000 children on waiting lists, mostly for subsidized spots. Several parents, mothers especially, have reported being unable to return to work because they can't find child care after their parental leaves.

Those who are invested in the system agree it should offer quality care to children, and that everyone who wants a spot should be able to get one.

CBC's Quebec AM and Breakaway have done a series of interviews exploring the current system — its successes and what needs to improve.

Here is a compilation of those conversations:

Private daycares ready to offer subsidized spots

A four-year-old boy at the Centre de la petite enface Pomme Cannelle in Quebec City. (CBC)

In mid-June, Lacombe held two days of public consultations about child-care services.

One group representing about 600 private daycares, the Coalition des garderies privées non subventionnées du Québec, presented a brief saying they are ready to be converted into Centres de la petite enfance (CPE) or offer subsidized spots.

They also called for a moratorium on any new private daycares. Private daycare owner and board member, Anto Khoren spoke with Alison Brunette

LISTEN | Private daycares want to be converted to subsidized spots: 
The Family Minister is holding public consultations about childcare services. One group representing private daycares told him they are ready to be converted into CPEs or offer subsidized spots. They also called for a moratorium on the construction of any new private daycares. Private daycare owner and board member, Anto Khoren spoke with Alison Brunette. 13:39
Quebec has a shortage of daycare spots and a shortage of daycare workers. (CBC)

CPEs say staff shortage forcing closure of groups

CPEs are often referred to in research as the best quality daycare within Quebec's system. They offer $8.50 per day spots and tend to have the most resources, including for children of vulnerable backgrounds and with special needs.

Isabelle Lebrun is a CPE and co-ordinating bureau director and she sits on the board of the Quebec council for early childhood education services.

Earlier this year she had to call the parents of a little boy with special needs to say he had to stay home because she didn't have staff to care for him.

"When you work in this job, it's the worst thing, you know. We are there to offer quality services."

She says colleagues have closed whole groups or even daycares due to a lack of staff.

Lebrun spoke to Quebec AM's Alison Brunette.

LISTEN | Improving the daycare system: a perspective from within a CPE: 
Isabelle Lebrun has been working in the daycare system as long as so-called universal daycare has existed in Quebec. She explains to Alison Brunette what needs to change to offer quality care to kids, and why the current staffing shortage forces her to make tough calls to parents. 10:27

Vulnerable children or with special needs poorly served, says union

According to the family ministry 51,000 children are on waiting lists for a spot, mostly in subsidized care. (Darryl Dyck/The Canadian Press)

During the public consultations, the minister heard from several groups who said children who come from vulnerable backgrounds or have special needs receive unequal care depending on the kind of daycare they attend.

The CSQ union branch that represents daycare workers says more funding is needed to serve vulnerable children, and that the rules and even language around requests for services for special-needs children need to change.

Vice-president of the CSQ, Anne Dionne spoke with Breakaway guest host, Peter Tardif.

LISTEN | Better daycare for vulnerable children or with special needs: 
As the province rethinks the daycare system we’ll hear what the CSQ union representing daycare workers says needs to be done to make sure all kids have quality care, especially if they are from vulnerable backgrounds or have special needs. Anne Dionne joins Peter Tardif. 10:46
Family minister Mathieu Lacombe has promised to table a new daycare bill in the fall. (Radio-Canada)

The numbers

Subsidized spots cost $8.50 per child per day. There are three kinds of subsidized daycare, and two kinds of private daycare where parents can get a tax deduction for up to $38 of fees per day per child. The return is based on family income and does not take into account the number of children per family in care.

According to the Family Ministry, as of March 31, there were 307,490 recognized daycare spots in Quebec:

  • 32 percent, or 98,014 spots in CPEs.
  • 15 percent, or 47,789 spots in subsidized daycares.
  • 30 percent, or 91,604 spots in subsidized family-run daycares.
  • 23 percent, or 70,083 spots in private unsubsidized daycares.

Thousands of children also attend home daycares that are not recognized and are less regulated by the Family Ministry.

Many parents experience anxiety over a return to work with no daycare spot in sight. Others have to stay home until they find a spot. (getty images/istockphoto)

Anxiety and sleepless nights over lack of subsidized spots

Beyond the numbers, there are parents barely coping with the reality of daycare shortages.

Catherine Lévesque-Matte said the night before having to shell out $1,500 for two weeks worth of daycare for her three kids, she couldn't sleep. She knew her family couldn't afford it and the only option left was for her to quit her job working as a legal translator for the Quebec government.

It's a job she says she worked hard to get, and loves. If she quit, her family would lose the benefits that come with the position, and their house — they can't afford it on her partner's salary alone.

So stepping on her ego, she drafted a Facebook post and called out for help. She told Alison Brunette what happened next and why she is so frustrated with the current situation.

LISTEN | Anxiety and sleepless nights over lack of access to subsidized daycare: 
Catherine Lévesque-Matte's family budget will be in the red for the next months. Her three kids are in private daycare and she won't be able to make ends meet until her two eldest switch to subsidized spots. She tells Alison Brunette why she is frustrated by the current system and is calling for equal access for all parents. 7:59
Pauline Marois was family minister when $5 daycare was created in 1997 by the Parti Québécois government. (Radio-Canada)

Everyone wants quality childcare but what does that mean?

When universal daycare was first introduced by Pauline Marois in 1997, its goal was to provide equal care to all children in Quebec.

But Prof. Christa Japel, a psychologist and researcher at a Quebec early childhood think tank, the Observatoire des tout-petits, says the system has failed at that goal.

She joined host Alison Brunette to explain what quality care means and where Quebec's system most needs to improve.

LISTEN | What does "quality daycare" mean? 
When so-called universal daycare was set up in Quebec 25 years ago its goal was to create equal opportunity for all children. Psychologist, researcher and professor Christa Japel says Quebec has failed to achieve that goal. She explains to Alison Brunette what needs to change. 11:29
The CPE Abracadabra used its funding to build a play module for 18-month to 5-year-olds in the municipal park rather than a private yard. (Photo submitted by Audrey Caza/Town of Ste-Martine)

A solution: when a municipality and a CPE work together

Both the Federation of Municipalities of Quebec and the Union of Municipalities of Quebec say the Family Ministry should be collaborating more closely with communities when determining daycare needs in the regions.

One community that has done just that is Ste-Martine, south of Montreal.

It donated land for a CPE in exchange for evening access to a conference room the children use as a gym during the day.

More recently, the CPE installed a play module in the municipal park rather than a closed yard so all residents could have access to it.

Counc. Mélanie Lefort spoke to Marika Wheeler on Quebec AM.

LISTEN | Ste-Martine collaborates in "win-win" partnership to build CPE: 
Municipalities say they can be part of the solution for solving daycare the provincial daycare shortage. We hear how Ste-Martine worked with a local CPE to create new spots. Town councillor Mélanie Lefort joins guest host Marika Wheeler. 6:09
Jing Zhang has operated a subsidized home daycare for nine years. (Submitted by Jing Zhang)

Government invests in family-run daycares to get spots open fast

Those working in the daycare system say a major staffing shortage, exacerbated by low wages and few new recruits is one of the main challenges to offering more subsidized spots.

In early June, the family minister announced $200 million over five years to try to convince family-run daycares to open and stay open. The Family Ministry is counting on the relatively quick timeline in creating subsidized spots to make a dent in the shortage.

CBC journalist Marika Wheeler explains why the ministry is counting on these operators to fill the void, but also explores the challenging work conditions that are driving daycare operators to shut down.

LISTEN | Creating more subsidized daycare spots in Quebec: 
CBC Quebec's Marika Wheeler joins us to find out more about Quebec's plan to have more subsidized daycare spots. We'll hear about the tens of millions of dollars to fix the problem and reactions from daycare providers. 19:12
Economist Pierre Fortin has long argued that affordable, government-subsidized daycare is actually a revenue generator. (Pascal Michaud/Radio-Canada)

Provincial investment in daycare pays off big time says economist

Economist Pierre Fortin says investing in daycare has a big payoff and both Quebec and Canadian coffers benefit. For every $100 invested, he says, $175 come back to the government via sales taxes, income taxes, and money saved on child-care credits.

He also says it's an important program that allows about 100,000 women to participate in the Quebec workforce who couldn't otherwise, all while shoring up their long-term economic security.

He explained to Peter Tardif why the government should invest even more in subsidized, quality daycare in Quebec.

LISTEN | Subsidized daycare: A sure bet for the economy: 
Quality, subsidized daycare is good for kids and their parents, but what about the economy? Economist Pierre Fortin explains to Breakaway's Peter Tardif why having more subsidized spots is a sure bet for the government. 10:42

Got a daycare story or concern to share with us?

Email our lead journalist on the file marika.wheeler@cbc.ca

Or send a message by Facebook.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Marika Wheeler

CBC Quebec's travelling journalist

Based in Quebec City, Marika travels across the province telling the stories of people who live and work in la belle province for CBC Radio One and CBCnews.ca.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now