Montreal pit bull ban could be in place by September

The death of a Montreal woman who was mauled by an aggressive dog has prompted the city to seek a ban on pit bulls and other dangerous breeds.

Mayor Denis Coderre says existing pit bull owners will be allowed to keep their dogs

Montreal Mayor Denis Coderre said a ban on new pit bulls will apply across the city's 19 boroughs. (Natalie Nanowski/CBC)

The death of a Montreal woman who was mauled by an aggressive dog has prompted the city to seek a ban on pit bulls and other dangerous breeds.

Montreal Mayor Denis Coderre announced Saturday that he will seek approval from city council this September to go ahead with a ban on new pit bulls that would apply across the city's 19 boroughs.  

But unlike Quebec City, where a ban will force owners to get rid of their pit bulls by January, Montreal plans to allow existing owners to keep their dogs under certain conditions.

"I'm not comfortable to say that if we ban a breed, the current owners will have to get rid of their dogs, because you have good owners and you have good dogs, but it demands a balanced approach," Coderre said.

Under his proposal, pit bulls and certain other breeds will have to be registered, spayed or neutered and wear a muzzle in public.

Coderre said it remains to be seen whether dogs that are crossbred with pit bulls will fall under the legislation, but did mention that he believes they should.

Montreal Mayor Denis Coderre says the city is trying to create a balanced approach to dealing with pit bulls and other dangerous dogs. (CBC)

Taking a stand

Several municipalities in Quebec are re-examining how they regulate dog ownership in the wake of the death of 55-year-old Christiane Vadnais, who was found dead in the backyard of her east-end Pointe-aux-Trembles home June 8. Police believe she was mauled by a pit bull. 

Her family has since been calling for a ban on the dogs. They gathered Saturday Saint-Cyrille de Wendover, near Drummondville, Que., for Vadnais's funeral. 

Montreal's planned legislation will be designed to deal with pit bulls in the short term while being broad enough to cover other types of dangerous dogs, Coderre said.

"There is a situation regarding pit bulls that demands public authorities to take a stand," Coderre said.

Coderre did not clarify how the city would define a dangerous dog, other than to say that pit bulls would be among the breeds singled out.

In April, four Montreal suburbs announced plans to deal with dangerous dogs, which they defined as:

  • Bites, tries to bite, attacks or tries to attack a person or another animal.
  • While off its owner's property, manifests aggression towards a person or an animal by snarling, growling, showing its teeth, barking ferociously or acting in any way that suggests the dog may bite or attack.

Publicity campaign

In the meantime, Coderre said the city will begin a publicity campaign to ensure dog owners are aware of their responsibilities.

Dog owners are already supposed to register their animals with the city, but out of an estimated 145,000 dogs living in the city just under 14 per cent (20,123) are currently registered.

Dog owners are also supposed to inform the city if their dog bites someone. Between 2014 and 2016, 637 dog bites were reported to the city.

The city will hire more inspectors in order to increase patrols of the city this summer to ensure dog owners are respecting current municipal regulations.

The body of Christiane Vadnais, left, was discovered in her backyard after she was mauled by what police believe was a pit bull. (Facebook)

SPCA opposition

Montreal's SPCA criticized Coderre's proposal. They said it opens the door to banning specific breeds, which they say "supports the false premise that dogs that happen to look a certain way are inherently 'dangerous.'"

The SPCA considers breed-specific legislation a form of discrimination. It warned that such policies could lead to the deaths of otherwise well-behaved dogs.

"We are not going to let that happen here," Nicholas Gilman, the group's executive director, said in a news release.  

The SPCA said it is exploring options about how to prevent the ban from coming into effect, including legal challenges. 

"We know that the Montreal community understands that using hysteria, fear and prejudice as a means to push legislation forward is wholly unacceptable," said Alanna Devine, the Montreal SPCA's head of advocacy.

Owners react

Pit bull owners also expressed alarm at the regulations outlined by Coderre on Saturday.   

"I don't know how I feel about my pit bull having to wear a muzzle," Melissa Mira said in a comment on CBC Montreal's Facebook page. 

"We love to jog and play ball at the park... This is definitely going to affect our lifestyle..."   

John Truss, who owns a dog-training business in Montreal and owns five pit bulls himself, echoed the concerns expressed by the SPCA

"It's the breed-specific part of it that is the problem," Truss said of the city's proposed pit bull ban.

"You're essentially asking for a cull of all the pit bulls," he added. "That is really unfair because 99 per cent of them are really good dogs."

Mourners gather outside a church in Saint-Cyrille de Wendover, Que., for the funeral of Christiane Vadnais. Vadnais died after being attacked by a dog in her backyard June 8, 2016. (Radio-Canada)

Provincial legislation 

​Following her death, the province created a working group to review existing regulations surrounding pit bulls and come up with recommendations. 

The group met for the first time Thursday, but Premier Philippe Couillard has said Quebec will likely follow Ontario's lead and ban pit bulls across the province.

The working group is expected to come up with a list of proposals by August. Coderre said Saturday that he didn't want to wait for provincial legislation before taking action against pit bulls. 

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.