Montreal·CBC Investigates

Pie-IX water main break exposes holes in emergency response plan

A CBC Montreal investigation shows borough crews weren't equipped to repair the water main break that flooded more than 600 buildings last October. And the city crews that could handle it don't work on Fridays.

Perfect storm of equipment deficiency and expertise gap left neighbourhood underwater

Pie-IX water main break reveals problems with city planning

Montreal

5 years agoVideo
0:33
A perfect storm of equipment deficiency and expertise gap left the neighbourhood underwater last October. 0:33

When Normand Viau's basement began to fill up with water, all he could do was sit on his steps and helplessly watch.

"It's a very bad feeling," said Viau, who ended up with a repair bill totalling around $50,000. 

"I didn't start to cry, but it was close to it. You can do nothing."

Viau was one of hundreds of homeowners whose basement flooded after a 48-inch water main burst on the corner of Pie-IX Boulevard and Villeray Street in St. Michel last October.

It took crews more than five hours to shut off the water. 

Now, a CBC Montreal investigation shows borough crews weren't equipped to repair the break and city water crews don't work on Fridays, when the flood happened. 

Critics say Montreal was far too slow to shut off the water main. 

"Five hours for us, would not be acceptable to close a water main," said Luis Miranda, the mayor of Anjou. "A big city like Montreal, they are centralizing everything. How come they don't have 24 hour service on this? That's not normal."

      1 of 0

      Delayed response

      According to a detailed chronology compiled by the city and obtained by CBC through an access to information request,  police got a 911 call just before 5 a.m. reporting water gushing out of a hole in the road between Villeray and Everett streets. 

      In Montreal, with about 1,000 water main breaks a year, each borough has its own water department.  On smaller, less complex breaks, they usually do the repairs themselves. 

      But the Pie-IX break was a big pipe on the main water network. For a break of that size, the borough has to coordinate with the city's lead engineer to come up with a plan to shut the valves down safely using specialized equipment.

      Some boroughs have this equipment and can do the work themselves. Villeray-St.Michel-Parc-Extension isn't one of them.

      "The fire department was there, our teams were there, but no one could actually do the work because we didn't have the equipment," said Sylvain Ouellet, Projet Montreal's water critic.

      The borough had to ask the city for the equipment as well as its specialized team to run it.

      But that team isn't scheduled to work Fridays. They are only on-call.

      "Every minute that passed, more and more basements are flooded," said Ouellet. 

      "It's great to have the blue collars on call, but blue collars, lots of them live outside the island."

      Neighbourhood underwater

      That morning, Ouellet, the city councillor for the Francois-Perreault district, remembers getting a call from a resident telling him the neighbourhood was underwater.

      He grabbed a pair of rubber boots to see for himself.

      "All this neighbourhood was like a lake," said Ouellet, gesturing to the streets of post-war homes behind him.

      "It was incredible, the water just kept going and going."

      More than 600 buildings were flooded when the main broke in October. (CBC)

      The city finally had some equipment and a crew in place by 7:15 a.m., but couldn't start work on the valve for another hour.

      A second team with more equipment arrived by police escort from the water department's headquarters in the southwest by 8:45 a.m., nearly four hours after the break was first reported. By 10 a.m., the valves were completely turned off.

      "It was just too long," said Ouellet. "It would probably cost less for the city in the end to have someone close by at all times to respond to this kind of emergency."

      Legal action

      The city of Montreal received 209 claims for flood damage related to the Pie-IX water main break, about a third of all water damage claims in 2015. As of this month, 26 of them had settled for a total of $86,240. The majority, 179, are still active.

      Viau's entire basement was destroyed, wiping out his home office, appliances and storage. His insurance covered the damage and everything has finally been rebuilt.

      Normand Viau describes the damage to his home

      Montreal

      5 years agoVideo
      0:46
      Normand Viau's entire basement was destroyed in the flood, wiping out his home office, appliances and storage. 0:46

      But now, he's worried it could happen again due to a lack of coordination and bad scheduling at city hall.

      "It's stupid, completely stupid," he said. "These guys don't work Fridays? What's up? You don't have an emergency plan?"

      I wouldn't have been flooded if it had been solved earlier.- Marie-Josée Marcotte, St-Michel resident

      Marie-Josée Marcotte, another resident who lives about a block away, said if crews had been available an hour or two earlier, it would have made a huge difference.

      "My house got flooded at the last minute, just before they started turning it off," said Marcotte, whose insurance company is suing the city. "I wouldn't have been flooded if it had been solved earlier."

      CBC repeatedly asked to speak to Chantal Rouleau, the executive committee member responsible for water infrastructure and Anie Samson, the mayor of St-Michel.

      Norman Viau's basement flooded after a water main broke in October. (Submitted by Norman Viau)

      Philippe Sabourin, a spokesperson for the city, says it's too early to comment because of the legal proceedings against the city.

      In an email, Sabourin said the city's water department is still investigating what happened to see if any improvements need to be made.

      The delay in closing a pipe of this size can seem long in the "eyes of a neophyte", Sabourin wrote, but city employees worked as quickly as possible to limit the damage and to get things back to normal.

      CBC Montreal Investigates

      Do you have a story you think CBC Montreal's investigative team should look into?

      Leave a message on our confidential tipline, send us an email or contact us on Twitter.

      Tipline: 514-597-5155

      Email: montrealinvestigates@cbc.ca

      Twitter: @CBCMontreal

      About the Author

      Leah Hendry is a TV, radio and online journalist with CBC Montreal Investigates. Contact her via our confidential tipline: 514-597-5155 or on email at montrealinvestigates@cbc.ca.

      Comments

      To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

      By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

      now