Screeching tires, injured pedestrians a regular event on dangerous Parc Ave.

Policymakers and residents of Montreal's Mile End are trying to figure out how to curb the high number of pedestrian accidents on Parc Avenue, after a collision Tuesday killed one woman and left another in critical condition.

Projet Montréal councillor urges action to slow down traffic after 1 woman killed, 1 hurt Tuesday

Police and residents talk about safety issues on Parc Avenue

6 years ago
Duration 1:04
SPVM inspector André Durocher said pedestrians are crossing against the light while residents hope cars can slow down.

Policymakers and residents of Montreal's Mile End district are trying to figure out how to curb the high number of accidents involving pedestrians on Parc Avenue, after a collision Tuesday killed one woman and left another in critical condition. 

A truck heading north on Parc collided with the two women at such high speed that witnesses say it left the vehicle badly damaged.

"I went to look at it, and it was pretty shocking to see how damaged the truck was," said Raphael Farkas, the manager of the Koodo shop near the intersection where the women were struck, at Parc Avenue and Bernard Street.

Police cordon off the area with tape as witnesses congregate at the scene where two women were hit by a truck in Mile End Tuesday. One has died and the other is in critical condition. (Radio-Canada)

Farkas told CBC Montreal's Daybreak that he's used to rushing into the street and helping people who've been injured.

"You could count the five or six times a day that you hear tires screeching," Farkas said.

"There have been many, many occasions where there have been less severe accidents that we've helped with."

Narrow the lanes, add traffic lights

According to the transport critic for Projet Montréal, Marianne Giguère, Parc Avenue's design practically encourages motorists to drive carelessly. She thinks lanes need to be narrower, more traffic lights need to be installed, and the existing lights need to stay green longer to give pedestrians more time to cross the five-lane-wide artery.

Projet Montréal's Marianne Giguère says dangerous behaviour should be expected and the city needs to put safeguards in place.

6 years ago
Duration 0:31
"We have to reduce the speed. There will always be pedestrians and cyclists doing dangerous things," Giguère said.

"When the lanes are wide, it invites the drivers to drive fast and easily forget they are crossing a dense borough with thousands of cyclists and pedestrians," Giguère said.

She said the blame doesn't lie with drivers alone, nor with pedestrians alone, since bad behaviour is universal. She does want to see the city do more to make sure accidents are less likely to be fatal.

To lower the chance of death, Giguère wants the city to:

  • Make the sidewalks wider.
  • Lengthen the duration of the "go" signal for pedestrians at traffic lights.
  • Reduce the speed on Parc Avenue with narrower lanes, speed bumps and textured asphalt surfaces.

City says it's done a lot already

Montreal city councillor Aref Salem, the executive committee member responsible for transportation, accuses Projet Montréal of playing politics with the latest pedestrian death.

 It's "political exploitation over the accident at this intersection," Salem said.

He said the Coderre administration has done a lot to improve safety at the intersection where the two women were struck Tuesday – installing special pedestrian lights and adding green arrows to give pedestrians priority.

Councillor Aref Salem, who is responsible for transportation on the city's executive committee, accused the official opposition of playing politics with the accident. (City of Montreal)

Police on site for 3 days

Right now, police aren't sure what triggered the accident. They say they will seek to confirm if the women were jaywalking, if the driver was driving too fast or if he drove through a red light.

André Durocher, an inspector with the SPVM's road safety division, said that several officers are stationed at the intersection, in keeping with police procedure following an accident, to educate passersby about crossing safely.

He said that despite the heavy police presence, pedestrians are still running across Parc Avenue when the light is yellow, and drivers still aren't yielding the right of way.

"There's a lot of education that needs to be done," Durocher said.

Police are at the street corner where the accident happened to educate pedestrians and cyclists about safety. (Arian Zarrinkoub/CBC)

He said the top examples of dangerous behaviour are:

  • Motorists: Failing to respect pedestrians' right of way.
  • Pedestrians: Running across the street without checking to see if it's safe.
  • Cyclists: Not yielding to pedestrians and not respecting stop signs. 

This is at least the second serious collision involving pedestrians at the same Parc Avenue intersection this year. A woman was seriously hurt in January.

Boisselle advises both drivers and pedestrians to exercise caution.

"Be very careful. Even if the light is green. Even if you have the right of way."

with files from CBC Montreal's Daybreak and Arian Zarrinkoub


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?