MUHC seasonal bed closures will mean longer waits for surgery, doctor warns

With the number of available beds at the MUHC dipping to 719 for a total of 14 weeks of the year, an oncology surgeon predicts wait times for cancer surgery could double, and elective surgeries could face even longer delays.

14 weeks of 'seasonal bed closures' could double summer wait times for cancer surgery, some predict

Quebec Health Minister Gaétan Barrette refused to stop to answer reporters' questions on his way into a Liberal caucus meeting on Tuesday. (CBC)

With the number of available beds at the McGill University Health Centre (MUHC) dipping to an unforeseen 719 for a total of 14 weeks of the year, an oncology surgeon at the hospital predicts wait times for cancer surgery could double, and elective surgeries could face even longer delays.

The bed closures, spelled out in a PowerPoint presentation to MUHC managers recently, amount to 10 weeks over the summer, two weeks over the Christmas/New Year's holidays and two weeks in the spring, for a total of 14 weeks.

MUHC staff left scrambling

Doctors at the hospital have been left reeling by the news and are scrambling to figure out how to provide patient care with a dramatic decrease in the number of available beds for what adds up to a quarter of the year.

"Instead of my cancer patients waiting for three weeks for surgery, they'll wait five or six weeks during the summer," one oncology surgeon said, under the condition of remaining anonymous.

The new MUHC opened in April 2015. (Graham Hughes/Canadian Press)
"As a cancer surgeon, I get first pick of surgical days available — but it will still be fewer."

That surgeon said the bed cuts are certain to affect patients with less pressing conditions even more.

"Patients who have surgery that is required within three months, maybe that will be pushed to four or five months," the doctor said.

The seasonal bed closures affect all sites of the MUHC except for Lachine Hospital and will have an impact on general medicine, surgery, pediatrics and the Montreal Neurological Institute.

At heart of dispute: 2007 clinical plan

The full extent of the closures comes a week after the leak of a strongly worded letter sent to hospital staff in February from Ewa Sidorowicz, the MUHC's director of professional services and associate director general of medical affairs.

In  that letter, Sidorowicz said a request for transitional funding to help in the year of the move to the new Glen site had been rejected by the Health Ministry – amounting in a $32-million "spending correction."

In that Feb. 10 letter, Sidorowicz said that "correction" would translate into cutting the number of beds across the network from 832 beds to 799. 
Mario Di Carlo, co-chair of the MUHC central users' committee, said seasonal cuts that will reduce the number of available beds to 719 is certain to affect patient care. (CBC)

Keep in mind that until January, 2016, the MUHC had 853 permanent beds.

However, a clinical plan signed between the hospital and the Health Ministry in 2007 required the MUHC to decrease that number to 832 beds.

Once these latest seasonal bed closures are factored in, the average number of available beds across the MUHC network is 779.

CBC obtained a copy of the 2007 clinical plan through Quebec's access to information laws.

In it, the MUHC says it plans to reduce the number of acute care beds to a total of 832, based on an "average occupancy rate" of 85 per cent.

Imagine, a brand new hospital, $1.3 billion later ... and units closed even before they were ever used or inaugurated.- Paul Brunet, patients' rights activist

The plan does not make clear that the MUHC's budget would be based on that "average occupancy," however, Mario Di Carlo, the co-chair of the MUHC central users' committee, says that's how the Health Ministry has chosen to interpret it.

"We know the patient is going to fall between the cracks," said Di Carlo."It's going to affect care."

"I don't understand how they expect to do this without any impact on patients."

With so many fewer beds, Di Carlo is worried that patients will be rushed out of the hospital or left in limbo because the network that was supposed to be set up in the community simply isn't there.

"The MUHC slogan is best care for life. So how are we going to do this in this kind of context? I don't know," said Di Carlo, adding that the users group is closely monitoring what's happening.

"We don't want any fatalities on our hands."

No comment from Gaétan Barrette

Health Minister Gaétan Barrette refused to take questions Tuesday, briskly walking past waiting reporters on his way to a caucus meeting.

A spokesperson for the minister simply referred CBC back to the 2007 clinical plan.

It is a recurring refrain: Despite outcries about fewer elective surgeries, an overburdened emergency room and a concern the MUHC will be unable to deal with a sudden influx of patients, Barrette has repeatedly referred disgruntled doctors back to that clinical plan.

"It always goes back to, 'We would like to stay as we were,'" Barrette said on Feb. 4. "Well, they signed. They agreed on something. And when you sign a paper, it has a value."

'Outdated' plan

Paul Brunet, the chairman of the Quebec Council for the Protection of Patients, said the problem boils down to the MUHC's administration being stuck applying a plan that many people believe is outdated.

He said the bed cuts amount to a breach of service.  

"Imagine, a brand new hospital, $1.3 billion later, and not having appropriate services – and units closed even before they were ever used or inaugurated," said Brunet.

Brunet said he would not be surprised if a senior MUHC administrator were to get the axe in the coming weeks.

He said Barrette is unlikely to tolerate weeks of leaked memos, which has put the Ministry of Health on the defensive.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?