Montreal·CBC Investigates

They parked. They shopped. They got towed: Anger and frustration at a Montreal strip mall

Over the course of two days last week at a shopping plaza in Montreal's Saint-Laurent borough, CBC watched as a tow-truck operator removed vehicle after vehicle. "This is not normal," said Pierre Abraham Mulamba, who was charged $116 for a towing after he briefly left the plaza property.

Drivers of towed vehicles in Saint-Laurent shopping plaza forced to pay on the spot to locate their cars

Montreal drivers frustrated by strip mall’s towing policy

4 months ago
Duration 2:00
A CBC News investigation found some drivers who parked at a Montreal strip mall had their cars towed within minutes and were told to pay a woman in an idling SUV to locate their vehicles. The company managing the strip mall defends the policy, saying it’s in place to prevent commuters who take the Metro from using the lot for the day.

A few weeks ago, Pierre Abraham Mulamba stopped at a shopping plaza in Montreal's Saint-Laurent borough.

He had to go to the pharmacy at Galeries Norgate, near Montreal's Côte-Vertu Metro station, but first dashed across the street to get money from an ATM.

When he returned a few minutes later, his SUV was gone.

Mulamba spotted a sign for the towing company which manages the parking lot.

When he called to ask for their office's address, a woman told him, "No, no, no, no. Look in that parking [lot], there's a guy sitting in a Honda," Mulamba recalled. "So, I found it a bit strange."

He was told if he paid, they'd tell him where his vehicle was. The man in the Honda had an Interac machine, and Mulamba was charged $116.

WATCH | Cars parked at Galeries Norgate quickly get towed away: 

Drivers argue with towing company after cars taken away

4 months ago
Duration 0:58
Cars are towed minutes after they're parked at a Montreal shopping plaza, with confused drivers seen having to pay on the spot to find out where their car is.

Mulamba expected he'd find his SUV in a towing yard or garage, but to his surprise, it had been left on a nearby residential street.

"This is not normal," said Mulamba.

After picking up his car, he decided to go back to the mall to watch what was going on.

He saw a spotter pointing out cars to the tow-truck operator.

In less than an hour, Mulamba said, he watched six cars get towed. 

To ensure it wasn't just a one-off incident, he returned a few days later and witnessed the same pattern. 

He confronted the man collecting payments in the parking lot. 

"I told him, 'I will expose you,'" said Mulamba. He contacted CBC News, concerned about the large sums of money the company is charging unsuspecting shoppers.

Vehicles rapidly removed from lot

Over the course of two days last week, CBC observed the tow-truck operator removing cars at a rapid pace, in some cases hooking up the car and whisking it away in 10 or 15 seconds.

In a single hour last Wednesday, the operator towed five cars from the lot, each time depositing the vehicle on a nearby street.

There are several white-and-red signs posted in the plaza parking lot, warning shoppers unauthorized vehicles will be towed. At the bottom of each sign, it says parking is reserved for clients of the strip mall's stores.

CBC spoke to several people who had their cars towed over the two-day period. 

In two cases, the drivers said they had never even left the shopping plaza. In other cases, the drivers had only left for five or ten minutes to go to a shop across the road and had intended to continue shopping at the plaza when they returned.

The company that manages the parking lot at Galeries Norgate, a strip mall in Saint-Laurent, has posted signs warning people unauthorized vehicles will be towed. (Benjamin Shingler/CBC)

To get back their vehicles, they were told to pay a woman in an idling SUV to learn the location of their car. The fee ranged from $87 to $133.

Under Montreal's towing bylaw, drivers can be charged a towing fee of $89. The tow-truck operator can charge an additional $30 for storage of the vehicle, but only six hours after the vehicle was towed. 

Towing companies are also prohibited from withholding the location of the car from the owner until they pay.

'It wasn't even 5 minutes'

Ali Amjad was among those who had their cars towed when CBC was on site last week. He said when he found his car gone, he initially thought his vehicle had been stolen.

He said he had stopped at the mall to exchange money, but the bank hadn't yet opened. He crossed the street to go to Western Union, but found it, too, closed. 

By the time he returned, his car had disappeared.

"I was so shocked: it wasn't even five minutes," said Amjad.

He was charged $133, which he had to borrow from a friend who works in the plaza.

By the time he returned to the SUV to pay, a line had formed.

Amjad said one man, told he owed $120, was angrily arguing with the woman collecting payments. He said two others refused to pay and said they were going to call the police. 

"It was a bad experience," said Amjad, who recently moved to Montreal from South Africa. 

A driver looks at his bill after his car was towed from the parking lot at Galeries Norgate. The woman in the SUV is collecting towing fee payments for the company that manages the parking lot. (Charles Contant/CBC)

Md Riaz Uddin was more fortunate. Uddin said he returned from the pharmacy, located in the shopping plaza, and came back to find his car being hooked up to a tow truck.

He was able to get the driver to unhook the car without paying, but he was upset it had happened in the first place.

"This is really ridiculous, and it's not fair to the people," said Uddin.

Dongmo Ernest Joël witnessed another man struggling to find his car after it was towed last week and stopped by to help. He'd had his own car towed last November, while shopping at the strip mall's pharmacy. He said he thought about calling the police but didn't, because he didn't have faith they would do anything.

Plaza manager defends towing

The strip mall's parking lot is managed by Solutions des Parcs de Stationnement du Québec Inc. (SPSQ), but the actual towing is done by another company, Gestion RSCM.

Last October, the Journal de Montréal reported similar complaints about the same two companies from customers at a Tim Hortons parking lot in nearby Côte-des-Neiges–Notre-Dame-de-Grâce.

SPSQ manages the parking lots of many apartment complexes and commercial spaces around the city.

An employee who answered the phone at SPSQ said the company's owner, Shant Edgar Grigorian, would not comment and referred questions to the manager of Galeries Norgate. The owner of Gestion RSCM, Megerditch Batmanian, did not return a request for comment.

Online reviews of the Galeries Norgate include complaints about cars being towed at the plaza that date back more than a year.

Reviews of the shopping plaza frequently mention overzealous towing. (Google Reviews)

Christopher Arnaoutelis, the vice-president of operations for Crofton Moore, the real estate developer which manages Galeries Norgate, confirmed its contract with SPSQ stipulates cars should be immediately removed if the driver is seen leaving the mall's lot. 

He said the policy is meant to stop people who take the Metro from using the plaza as a parking lot for the day. (None of the people towed with whom CBC spoke had taken the Metro.) 

Arnaoutelis said the rule also applies to those who shop in the plaza and then briefly shop elsewhere.

"This is something we've got to do because anybody could go into the mall, go into the dépanneur, buy a pack of cigarettes or a stick of gum and then leave and go somewhere else and leave the car there all day. It doesn't work that way."

This is a mock-up of a revised sign for Galeries Norgate. There's no timeline for when the signs will be posted in the strip mall's parking lot. (Submitted)

He concedes a few people have had their cars towed in error. When asked about the apparently arbitrary amounts people were charged, Arnaoutelis said the towing operator knows the bylaws, but if there are questions, the customer should keep proof of payment and contact Crofton Moore.

"We've been towing cars there every day, and we haven't gotten any notification from the city that we're contravening the bylaws," said Arnaoutelis.

Saint-Laurent borough Mayor Alan DeSousa said he is aware of complaints, and the borough asked Crofton Moore to add better signage to warn shoppers of the risk of being towed if they leave the property.

Following CBC's inquiries, Crofton Moore shared a mock-up of the sign. It's bigger, clearer and includes a picture of a tow truck. There is no date as to when the signs will be installed.

Past investigations, warnings about tow companies

Towing companies have a history of malpractice in Montreal and the surrounding region. 

A CBC investigation in 2016 found a Laval towing company had racked up dozens of complaints with the Office of Consumer Protection for its questionable business practices, including the use of intimidation and threats. 

A year later, Montreal police arrested 13 people connected with the same company, accusing them of seizing vehicles parked in violation of rules advertised on private or commercial properties and keeping them until owners paid up.

Police carried out raids in Montreal's Saint-Léonard borough in 2016, in connection with what police alleged was an illegal towing operation on 'a massive scale.' (Kalina Laframboise/CBC)

Montreal's ombudsman's office has raised concerns in the past about such practices. In a statement last week, spokesperson Pierre Tessier said the ombudsman is still following the situation closely.

Montreal police would not confirm whether there had been complaints about the Saint-Laurent shopping plaza, but police did say tow-truck companies that don't comply with the law will be charged.

Anyone with a complaint can call police at 514-872-6531 or email inspection.remorquage@spvm.qc.ca.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now