As Montreal booms, construction debris is getting dumped on prime farmland

Montreal's construction boom means thousands of truckloads of contaminated soil, twisted rebar and concrete need to go somewhere. And some, at least, is ending up on prime farmland, Radio-Canada's investigative program Enquête has found.

Truckloads of contaminated soil, metal and concrete dumped in countryside, Enquête investigation finds

Debris from the demolished Saint-Luc Hospital ended up on agricultural land in Saint-Rémi, south of Montreal. (Anne-Louise Despatie/Radio-Canada)

Overlooking lettuce fields in Saint-Rémi, south of Montreal, there's an open air dump site, littered with bricks and concrete and other demolition debris.

Montreal's construction boom — new hospitals, condos, bridges and roads — means thousands of truckloads of contaminated soil, twisted rebar and concrete need to go somewhere.

And some, at least, is ending up on prime farmland, in a region renowned as Montreal's fruit and vegetable basket, Radio-Canada's investigative program Enquête has found.

Take the debris from the demolished Saint-Luc Hospital. Some of it has ended up on agricultural land belonging to A. Barbeau and sons — a Saint-Rémi vegetable producer.

This agricultural land in Saint-Rémi, as seen in November, is owned by A. Barbeau and sons. (Jacques Taschereau/Radio-Canada)

Benoît Barbeau, one of the owners, said the dumping is legal, and the debris will become the foundation for a greenhouse.

Environmental lawyer Michel Bélanger disagrees.

"This is clearly a collection of debris that should be put elsewhere," Bélanger said.

Quebec's Environment Ministry has confirmed it found contaminated soil at the site last June, but it's offered no further details about its origin, saying the matter is still under investigation.

Contractors pass the buck

Pomerleau, the general contractor overseeing the construction of Montreal's French-language superhospital, the CHUM, told Enquête the subcontractor that trucked away the debris from the Saint-Luc demolition ensured it that everything was above board.

The landowner had the right to build a "farm road" with brick and stone, Pomerleau said.

Chunks of metal and concrete were found among the debris on the farmland in Saint-Rémi. (Jacques Taschereau/Radio-Canada)

However, the kind of debris found in Saint-Rémi can't legally be used for such construction, according to the Environment Ministry.

Pomerleau promised to make any necessary changes, if it turns out the subcontractor broke the rules.

Loads of soil carted off the site of the Noca condominium project site in Montreal's Griffintown neighborhood were also dumped on the Barbeau farmland.

A pile of bricks and stones were found at the same location. (Jacques Taschereau/Radio-Canada)

Like Pomerleau, the Noca site manager, DevMcGill, blamed subcontractors. The law, however, is clear, said Bélanger, the environmental lawyer: the company that generates the waste is ultimately responsible for where it goes.

And the owners of agricultural land do not have the right to pollute, even if it's their land.

Tailing the trucks

Soil decontamination is a cutthroat business in southern Quebec, and it's been likened to the Wild West.

"A new player has shown up in the market who claims to be a broker in contaminated soil, Marlène Girard, president of Énergie Carboneutre, told Radio-Canada back in 2016.

"These are people who obviously do not have a licence and who do not have the technology to treat the soil."

To confirm her suspicions, Girard hired private detectives to tail debris-laden trucks from construction sites in downtown Montreal to illegal dumping grounds, she said.

"My main motivation was my business, but I did not think I'd find something that big," says Girard, who believes the illegal spread of contaminated soil poses a threat to public health and to wildlife.

"It's found in streams; it's found in the air — and it's found on our plate."

Enquête also followed trucks in the winter of 2016 and observed debris being dumped in the countryside. It sampled soil from several farms and found some samples to be contaminated, others not.

The contractors confronted by Radio-Canada all proclaimed their innocence — insisting they hadn't dumped contaminated soil and it couldn't have come from them.

Police probe comes up empty

The provincial police also investigated complaints about the illegal dumping of contaminated soil. However, after two years of work, the Sûreté du Québec came up empty-handed.

Quebec's Director of Criminal and Penal Prosecutions made the decision last spring not to lay charges.

The failure to crack down on illegal polluters deeply troubles Alain Robichaud, co-president of Englobe, a major player in soil decontamination in Quebec.

"I still do not understand why the charges were not laid in these cases," he said. "It's a catastrophe."

Like his competitor Énergie Carboneutre, Robichaud hired private detectives to follow trucks in the spring and summer of 2018.

He provided a copy of the videos to Enquête.

This screengrab of a video shows a truck dumping possibly contaminated soil. (Submitted by Alain Robichaud)

In addition to the dumping of Saint-Luc debris, the videos show trucks going from other worksites dumping their loads elsewhere on the South Shore, including in Ormstown and Pointe-Fortune. Radio-Canada found construction debris at those sites.

What will it take?

"I am convinced that there are still hundreds of trucks roaming around Quebec, unloading contaminated soil in unauthorized places, with impunity" said Englobe's Robichaud.

"That's the tragedy of this story: it's still happening."

A twisted piece of metal was among the debris found on agricultural land in Ormstown. (Jacques Taschereau/Radio-Canada)

The law is clear, but according to Bélanger, the Environment Ministry's rules won't be enforced unless more resources are devoted to cracking down on illegal dumping.

"If we had examples that ended up being prosecuted, eventually more landowners and entrepreneurs would do things differently," he said.

Quebec Environment Minister Benoît Charette declined Radio-Canada's request for an interview, citing investigations still underway in his department.

About the Author

Marie-Maude Denis

Marie-Maude Denis is an investigative journalist with Radio-Canada's Enquête.

Translated by Benjamin Shingler and edited by Loreen Pindera

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.