Mayor Valérie Plante to deliver balanced budget along with 'a lot of pain'

"Christmas is over," says Projet Montréal Coun. Luc Ferrandez, explaining that an unexpected shortfall left by the previous Coderre administration means Wednesday's budget will be balanced, as promised, but accompanied by "a lot of pain."

'Christmas is over,' says Coun. Luc Ferrandez, while opposition proposes new independent budget office

Montreal Mayor Valérie Plante promised no property tax increases beyond the rate of inflation. Her colleague Luc Ferrandez hinted she will keep that promise — but not without 'a lot of pain' elsewhere. (CBC)

Montreal Mayor Valérie Plante's new administration is promising to deliver a balanced budget Wednesday, but one of Plante's councillors says an unexpected shortfall left by the previous administration means the budget will be accompanied by "a lot of pain."

Just days after Plante was elected mayor last fall, she said her Projet Montréal team was surprised to discover a gaping $358-million hole in the budget of the outgoing Denis Coderre administration.

Speaking to host Mike Finnerty on CBC Montreal's Daybreak Monday, Plateau-Mont-Royal borough mayor and executive committee member Luc Ferrandez said Plante's administration has found ways to make up that shortfall.

"We did, but with pain. With pain, with a lot of pain. It's not like there's surpluses of money and surprises and gifts for everybody, that's for sure," said Ferrandez. "Christmas is over."

Plateau-Mont-Royal borough Mayor Luc Ferrandez, a member of Valérie Plante's executive committee, said Monday that balancing the city's budget was no easy task. (CBC)

Ferrandez didn't elaborate, but he suggested that the administration was able to balance the budget without increasing taxes beyond the rate of inflation, as Plante promised.

Opposition proposes independent budget watchdog

The opposition at city hall, made up of former members of Équipe Denis Coderre, has consistently denied any problem with the city's books, saying Plante's team was using preliminary numbers and calling  it a shortfall is an "old trick."

Opposition leader Lionel Perez proposed Monday that the city create a new independent budget office, modelled after the parliamentary budget officer in Ottawa.

The office would provide objective financial data about the state of the city's finances and the estimated cost of proposed projects.
Montreal's opposition leader, Lionel Perez, says an independent budget office would "depoliticize" squabbles between incoming and outgoing municipal administrations over financial shortfalls. (CBC)

'Elevate the debate': Perez

Perez said that would end the common practice of new administrations blaming budget shortfalls on their predecessors.

"It would elevate the debate," he told reporters at city hall. "The population doesn't really care for this war of numbers.  This kind of proposition would be able to diminish, if not eliminate that."

Perez said he would introduce a motion calling for the new office at this month's council meeting.  He estimated it would require an annual budget of $5 million and a staff of 30 people.

He said many American cities including New York, Chicago, San Diego and Pittsburgh have such independent budget offices.

A spokesperson for Plante said Monday he agreed that more objective financial data and greater transparency would be good ideas.

However, he suggested that creating a whole new office was unnecessary and that the city's auditor general could provide much of that data.


Steve Rukavina


Steve Rukavina has been with CBC News in Montreal since 2002. In 2019, he won a RTDNA award for continuing coverage of sexual misconduct allegations at Concordia University. He's also a co-creator of the podcast, Montreapolis. Before working in Montreal he worked as a reporter for CBC in Regina and Saskatoon. You can reach him at