LaSalle student recovering from broken jaw after school altercation

Montreal police are investigating after an altercation at LaSalle Community Comprehensive High School left a 12-year-old with serious injuries to his face.

Student’s mom blames staff at LaSalle Community Comprehensive High School for lack of supervision

Kyle Charpentier-McWhirter, 12, underwent surgery to have his jaw wired shut after an altercation at school. (Photo courtesy: Crystal McWhirter)

Montreal police are investigating after an altercation at LaSalle Community Comprehensive High School left a 12-year-old with serious injuries to his face.

“He had the jaw wired shut,- Crystal McWhirter, mother of 12-year-old Kyle

Kyle Charpentier-McWhirter had to undergo surgery, and his jaw is wired shut.

“He had two breaks to the jaw and a fracture to the chin, along with a majority of his teeth that are shattered and broken,” said his mother Crystal McWhirter.

“He had the jaw wired shut, a metal plate and screw incisions inside the mouth — in the chin.”

The 12-year-old has to undergo another surgery next week.

Charpentier-McWhirter says he thinks another boy choked him, until he fell unconscious.

“He grabbed me right here and told me to stop, so when I turned around he choked me,” he said.

Mother blames high school

McWhirter has many questions for officials at LaSalle Community Comprehensive High School.

She says she's angry there was a one hour delay before getting Kyle to hospital, and she says better supervision could have been prevented such serious injuries.

“Something should have been done before Kyle was actually unconscious. Where was everybody? My son was attacked and he was assaulted in the school. So as far as the school [goes], there needs to be more supervision and surveillance,” McWhirter said.

Proper protocol followed, school officials say

Officials at both the school and the school board say staff did everything right  and an appropriate number of staff monitors were present.

The situation was handled very well, -Suanne Stein Day, head of the LBPSB

“The hall was monitored by two staff at the time — as is policy. All schools have support staff monitoring. I’m very confident the school had proper supervision in place,” said Suanne Stein Day, the head of the Lester B. Pearson School Board.

“The situation was handled very well. It's never easy when a fight breaks out in the school. It's never easy when a child gets injured, but our administrators are well-trained to deal with it.”

Possible criminal charges

McWhirter, who plans to file a police report, says school officials told her the student involved in the altercation with her son has been suspended indefinitely.

Meanwhile, Montreal police say they are looking into the incident.

They say their investigation could lead to an arrest, and possible assault charges.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.