Montreal

Lawsuit to challenge Quebec back-to-school plan

Lawyer says the provincial government's decision to make in-class learning mandatory violates the parents' charter rights.

Lawyer says government's decision to make in-class learning mandatory violates charter rights

Julius Grey says the motion he'll file in Quebec Superior Court in the coming days will argue requiring children to attend classes in person violates their parents' charter rights to make decisions that affect their health and safety. (CBC)

A group of parents is moving forward with a legal challenge aimed at forcing Quebec to offer remote learning services to families who don't want their children returning to classrooms during the COVID-19 pandemic, the lawyer representing them said Monday.

Julius Grey said the motion he'll file in Quebec Superior Court in the coming days will argue that requiring children to attend classes in person violates their parents' charter rights to make decisions that affect their health and safety.

"There are certain decisions that cannot be made by the government for people," Grey said in a phone interview.

"Of course the government can make basic curriculum decisions — for instance, people who wanted to protect their children from the study of science were always rebuffed — but they cannot make these fundamental decisions about life, death, security."

The province's back-to-school plan offers online learning services only if a child or someone in their household has a medical condition that puts them at risk of health complications.

But children without a medical exemption will have to attend classes or be home-schooled, Education Minister Jean-François Roberge repeated Monday.

"If [they] present a risk for health, of course we will help those kids to learn at home with the help of teachers and support staff,'' he said at a news conference. "But if the kids don't have some sickness related to COVID-19, the best place is to go to school, of course."

On Monday, Roberge announced $20 million in funding aimed at temporarily hiring about 350 teachers and specialists to help children who have fallen behind due to the disruptions caused by the pandemic.

Politimi Karounis, a mother of two, is one of the parents involved in the lawsuit. She believes the health measures in the government's plan are inadequate.

She said sending her children to school "would mean my child is in a class for five or six hours a day, with 35 students, without a mask, without social distancing, when at home I can guarantee several basic security measures.

Grey said parents have many reasons for wanting to keep their children out of crowded classrooms, ranging from elderly grandparents or sick siblings at home, to simple anxiety.

He said many parents don't have the capacity to home-school, and don't want to pull their children from their normal classes without a guarantee they'll be able to return next year.

Grey said the government is "clearly capable" of providing distance learning, since it is doing so for children who have health exemptions.

"They are providing Zoom education for those children who qualify under the narrow exemptions they have," he said.

"There's no reason they wouldn't provide it for all those parents who, for better or worse, for good reason or bad reason, say they are not comfortable sending their child to school."

Grey is seeking an emergency hearing on the matter in the hopes of getting a decision in the next few weeks.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?

now