Federal languages commissioner wants Quebec to do more to help Anglos

The Quebec government has rejected a renewed call by Canada's official languages commissioner that it create an office of anglophone affairs to better serve the province's linguistic minority.

Graham Fraser sees 'no indication' province will create new agency for Quebec's 600,000 anglophones

Commissioner of Official Languages Graham Fraser says Quebec's English community has a problem with successive governments and as a result, it has limited clout with the provincial government. (The Canadian Press/Adrian Wyld)

The Quebec government has rejected a renewed call by Canada's official languages commissioner that it create an office of anglophone affairs to better serve the province's linguistic minority.

Graham Fraser told Canadian Press he met with the three Liberal anglophone members of Quebec's National Assembly and said there was "no indication" the governing party would create a body dedicated to Quebec's 600,000 anglophones.

The government's reaction is not a surprise to community groups in Quebec who often complain the Liberal government's rhetoric about the province's anglophones doesn't match its actions.

The Liberals publicly acknowledge the importance of the province's English speakers — as opposed to their predecessors who were, at times, openly hostile to Quebec's largest linguistic minority.

Control 'slowly eroding'

But members of Quebec's anglophone minority say local control over institutions at the heart of their community is slowly eroding, as is their influence over public policy regardless of the government in power.

"The English community has a problem with successive governments," Fraser said. "They tend to be taken for granted whoever the government is. As a result, they have limited clout with Quebec City."

The Liberal government says its three anglophones MNAs  Immigration Minister Kathleen Weil, Native Affairs Minister Geoffrey Kelley and David Birnbaum, parliamentary assistant to Premier Philippe Couillard sufficiently represent Quebec's English community.

Fraser and the heads of anglophone community groups in the province disagree.

Sylvia Martin-Laforge, executive director of the anglophone lobby group Quebec Community Action Network, says having three anglo MNAs in Quebec City is "absolutely not" enough.

Her organization has access to politicians, but she said English groups need direct access to the bureaucracy.

"What we need are inside coaches," she said. "Somebody whose job it is to work with me in the provincial government."

She said a glaring example of why anglophones need an inside partner is the recent introduction of Bill 10, which critics say will further erode local control over the English-language hospital network.

Bill 10 amendments do not protect anglo institutions: rights group

8 years ago
Duration 2:52
The Quebec Community Groups Network says amendments to the Couillard government's health reform bill do not go far enough to protect anglophone health institutions.

Health Minister Gaetan Barrette's legislation would reform the governance of health institutions, which the government says will save millions of dollars as it works towards balancing the budget.

But centralizing services makes the anglophone community nervous.

Any control it gives up is control given to Quebec City, which doesn't have the interests of anglophones as a priority, said Martin-Laforge.

The English-speaking community is particularly sensitive to perceived threats against its governance of schools and hospitals, which are considered pillars of its identity and culture.

Giving up any control over schools or hospitals to francophone Quebec City is considered unacceptable.

"The community built its institutions all of them," Martin-Laforge said. "We bought the land, we built the buildings, we did all the work. If we don't have institutions we have nothing."

Building institutions 

Birnbaum used to be part of building those institutions.

A former head of the Quebec English School Board Association, he told The Canadian Press that an anglophone affairs office is not the solution.

"I'm not sure the answer is to set up a political entity which is specifically tasked with the concerns of the English-speaking community," he said.

He said Couillard is the premier of all Quebecers and Bill 10 will "go a long away" to addressing the concerns of the anglo community.

The bill is still in committee stage, he explained, and he asked that anglophones remain patient as he's spent hours working on amendments to the bill.

He said it's important that people recognize the distinction between the Liberals and the Parti Québécois because his government "understands that English-speaking Quebec is an ally."

"I understand that it has to pay dividends, but it's important to note the distinction." 

Birnbaum said Quebecers will soon see some dividends as he expects Couillard to introduce a plan to recruit and encourage more anglophones into the Quebec civil service.

"Often making progress is simply preventing further erosion  that's a tough reality but it's often the case for minority communities," he said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?