Charlie Hebdo Paris shooting vigils held in Montreal

Like thousands of people around the world, Montrealers gathered to honour the victims of the fatal shooting at the Charlie Hebdo Paris newspaper.

Mayor Denis Coderre lowers Montreal flag to half mast at city hall

Charlie Hebdo Paris shooting vigils held in Montreal

8 years ago
Duration 2:19
Like thousands of people around the world, Montrealers are gathering this evening to honour the victims of this morning's fatal shooting at a Paris newspaper.

Like thousands of people around the world, Montrealers gathered to honour the victims of the fatal shooting at the Charlie Hebdo Paris newspaper. 

Mayor Denis Coderre invited Montrealers to City Hall Wednesday evening for a candlelight vigil. 

He said the flag of Montreal will also be lowered to half-mast.

"We have a duty to protect our freedom of expression. We have the right to say what we have to say,” said Coderre.

At Montreal’s French Consulate on McGill College Street, hundreds of people came to show their support for the shooting victims. 

A third vigil was held at the French Union on Viger Street. 

Reaction in Quebec

The Consulate General of France in Quebec issued a statement earlier today. 

“There are no words strong enough to condemn the attack that took place this morning in Paris. It is not only freedom of expression under attack, but democracy as a whole,” the statement reads.

Quebec Premier Philippe Couillard is denouncing the attacks on a Paris newspaper headquarters, calling them "unacceptable and intolerable."

Three masked gunmen stormed the offices of satirical weekly newspaper Charlie Hebdo on Wednesday, killing 10 journalists and two police officers. Another 20 people were injured, including four critically, in the shooting.

"Our first thoughts are with the victims, their families and the people of France," Couillard said in a statement.

"Our ties with France and the French are profound, sincere and historic. We share not only a common language, but also values of liberty and democracy. On behalf of all Quebecers, I express my condolences and salute their courage during this difficult time."

The flag at the National Assembly in Quebec City was lowered to half mast.

Parti Québécois interim leader Stéphane Bédard also offered his condolences, telling reporters the shooting represented an attack on journalism, one of the pillars of democracy.

François Legault, head of the Coalition Avenir Québec, came under hot water on Twitter for making light of the news. He suggested a character from the popular TV show Homeland should pursue the attackers.

He later sent out a statement condemning what he called a "barbaric act."

Freedom of expression 

While it remains unclear what prompted the attacks, one Montreal Muslim leader said certain depictions of the Prophet Muhammad in Charlie Hebdo went too far.

Salam Elmenyawi, president of Muslim Council of Montreal, argued the cartoons would qualify as hate speech under Canadian law.

Elmenyawi called the shooting “very sad,” but said there should be “certain limits when it comes to religion, and attacks on religion, that may harm social fabrics and societies in general.”

"Of course we respect very much freedom of expression, but there are certain limits when it comes to religion," he said in an interview.

“Satire is sometimes much more effective even in insulting a community than any other method. This kind of method can be very, very serious because it can cause psychological damage to a community.”

He said Muslims would feel offended if any prophet — not only Muhammad, but also Jesus, Abraham, or David — were depicted negatively. 

Djemila Benhabib, a former PQ candidate and an outspoken critic of religious extremism, was friends with one of the victims.

She described Stéphane Charbonnier​, better known under his cartoonist name of Charb, as a man of courage.

She said he would want people to continue to talk, write and draw about religious extremism.