Bill 3 pension reform talks between minister and unions 'constructive'

Municipal Affairs Minister Pierre Moreau and union coalition leader Marc Ranger are hashing out possible solutions to the standoff over attempt at pension reform.

Municipal Affairs Minister Pierre Moreau and union coalition leader Marc Ranger hash out possible solutions

Municipal Affairs Minister Pierre Moreau said improving financial conditions in the province may halve the $4 billion pension deficit. (CBC)

Municipal Affairs Minister Pierre Moreau on Tuesday said he won't be watering down Quebec's controversial pension reform bill after his conversation with union coalition leader Marc Ranger.

However, Moreau and Ranger said both parties are actively looking to solve the ongoing dispute between municipal employees and the government and had a constructive conversation.

"Right now, we're careful. We're not optimistic or pessimistic. We're trying to look at the real result. Right now, the positive thing is we're still talking," Ranger said on Tuesday.

The controversy surrounding Bill 3 boiled over in June when a number of firefighters retired en masse to fight pension reforms that would see municipal workers across Quebec contribute more to their pension plans to help make up for ballooning deficits.

Since then, some police officers and firefighters have protested the bill by wearing camouflage pants and plastering their cars and trucks with big red stickers decrying the reforms.

Criminal charges

Some municipal workers were also involved in a violent protest at Montreal City Hall that led to the trashing of the city council chambers. Forty-four people are now facing criminal charges related to the incident, including Montreal blue collar workers’ union head Michel Parent and firefighters’ union head Ronald Martin.

Bill 3 is currently undergoing a clause-by-clause examination at the National Assembly.

Moreau said improving financial conditions in the province may halve the $4 billion deficit. If that happens, major reforms may become less necessary. 

As a sign of protest, firefighters and police officers have plastered their vehicles with stickers denouncing the province's proposed Bill 3. (Radio-Canada)

Moreau said the government is watching the market closely.

"If the market is doing well, it's good news for everybody. That means that the effort that will have to be put on pension plans will be less than expected and therefore it's good news," he said.

No concrete result

Moreau and Ranger spoke Tuesday about their respective positions on Bill 3 and what could be done to resolve the standoff. 

Ranger said the unionized employees realized long ago that the pension plans needed to be stabilized.  He said the unions and the minister discussed the possibility of waiting to re-negotiate collective agreements.

“The goal is to find an intelligent solution that will respect previous contracts,” Ranger said.

Despite the modest progress, Ranger said there are no plans to put future demonstrations on ice, particularly a march planned for Sept. 20 from Lafontaine Park to Moreau’s Montreal office.

“There is still no concrete result,” he said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?