Beaconsfield moves closer to summer-long ban on leaf blowers

Beaconsfield is looking to ban the use of both gas and electric leaf blowers in the summer months in an effort to combat noise and air pollution, but not everybody is on board with the plan.

Anti-ban resident feels her views were ignored at Monday night's council meeting

Angelika Balinska Hansen and her husband Peter Hansen are opposed to a ban on leaf blowers. Balinska Hansen was one of several Beaconsfield residents opposed to a ban who attended a council meeting Monday, arguing the blower provides a quick, low-impact means of keeping her property clean. (Antoni Nerestant/CBC)

Beaconsfield is looking to ban the use of both gas and electric leaf blowers in the summer months in an effort to combat noise and air pollution.

Notice of the ban, which would run from June 1 to Sept. 30, passed at Monday night's council meeting. The council will likely cast its final vote on the measure at next month's meeting.

"We started looking at this because of the noise," Beaconsfield Mayor Georges Bourelle told CBC Montreal's Daybreak Tuesday.

But it was soon discovered that noise wasn't the only problem.

Debris particles, he said, remain suspended in the air and have a "big impact on people with health issues — particularly children; particularly the elderly."

"We are talking about a threat to our health and to the environment," Bourelle said. "We are talking about sweeping mould, sweeping fungal spores, sweeping insect eggs, weed seeds, fertilizers, animal feces and dust."

Bourelle said the city's environmental advisory committee has been studying the impact of leaf blowers over the last five years, and that committee "unanimously recommended to council that we restrict the use of leaf blowers, particularly during the summer months."

Bourelle said people will be allowed to use blowers in the spring and fall when they are most needed.
Beaconsfield's proposed leaf blower ban would prevent anyone, including both contractors and residents, from using a gas or electric leaf blower between June 1 and Sept. 30. (Pixabay/Pexels)

Residents rally against blower ban

Beaconsfield resident Angelika Balinska Hansen was one of several anti-ban residents that attended Monday night's meeting.

She uses her electric leaf blower on a "very low speed," she said, and if "anybody has a problem with breathing, they can always put on a mask."

The debris she is cleaning is all natural, she said, and wind kicks it up in the air just as much as any leaf blower.

Electric leaf blowers should at least be exempt from the ban, she said, because they do not create as much noise. She and her husband have health problems, she said, and the blower provides a quick, low-impact means of keeping her property clean.

Contractors, she noted, will hike up prices because of the extra time required to clean lawns without a blower.

Resident alleges anti-ban citizens 'mistreated' at meeting

Hansen said residents against the ban were treated unfairly during the meeting, whereas ban supporters were given preferential treatment. 

"It didn't go well at all," she said. "It was really upsetting. The mayor was really opinionated on the topic. He didn't let us voice our opinion. We were very dismissed and mistreated."

"It seems like our voice doesn't matter. It seems like the decision was already made."

Bourelle said the usual 30-minute question period ran for 90 minutes, and everybody was allowed to speak.

"There was no stopping of anyone that wished to make a statement," he said, noting some people were censured for rude behaviour. "Everybody had a chance to make a statement."

Contractors will have to change work methods under ban

Bourelle claimed the majority of citizens that attended the meeting supported the ban, and the city has even received support from a local lawn maintenance contractor.

However, not all contractors agree.

"As we're going around paths, walkways, swimming pools, driveways and such, we do leave a mess," Dan Olah said.  "Unfortunately, we can't clean it off unless we use blowers."

Olah is the owner of South West Garden and Snow, a West Island lawn maintenance company that does a lot of work in Beaconsfield.

Blowers push cut grass back pnto the lawn, and that, he said, is better for the environment than rounding it up, bagging it and shipping it to a landfill.

"The amount of spores and dust and such that actually get blown in the air is minimal because the blowers are kept close to the ground," Olah said. "Whatever is blown into the air falls quickly."

With files from Daybreak


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.