Fake shooting terrifies Winnipeg woman; changes to police training exercises demanded

The Canadian Civil Liberties Association is calling on Winnipeg's police chief to make changes to its police firearms training after a Winnipeg woman thought a mock shooting was real.

Canadian Civil Liberties Association says Winnipeg police need clearer policy on training exercises in city

Gabriela Aguero says Winnipeg police should be giving residents more notice before training exercises involving firearms. She's filed a complaint after witnessing what she thought was a shooting in an abandoned building across the river from her home. (Jaison Empson/CBC)

A Winnipeg woman who suffers from post-traumatic stress is still shaken after witnessing what she thought was a shooting, but turned out to be a police training exercise.

Now, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association is calling on Winnipeg's police chief to change the force's policy to prohibit firearms training in urban areas.

Gabriela Aguero was tending to her garden May 25 in the Wolseley neighbourhood when she heard gunshots.

"I heard about 10 or 20 shots being [fired] at the same time," she said.

She looked across the river and saw police in uniform at an abandoned building on Wellington Crescent. They had guns drawn, and were shouting and running.

"The first thing I thought is, 'a bullet is going to come to the other side of the river and I'm going to die,'" she said.

WATCH | Gabriela Aguero describes what she thought was a police shooting:

Winnipeg woman shaken after police mock shooting

CBC News Manitoba

8 months agoVideo
Gabriela Aguero says Winnipeg police shouldn't be conducting training exercises without warning the public. 2:20

It was only a police training exercise — but Aguero didn't know that.

She ran into her home, while her son took video on his phone of what he could see across the river.

Aguero said the yelling and shooting went on for 15 minutes.

Even now, Aguero said she's traumatized by what she saw — she has post-traumatic stress disorder after growing up in Argentina.

"I would hear shots being shot like that growing up in Argentina during the military government, and people were abducted," she said.

"There were many times in which as a child I heard shots like that. I don't think my children should grow up in a society that normalizes violence."

Aguero has filed a formal police complaint.

She also contacted the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, who wrote a letter to Winnipeg police Chief Danny Smyth asking the service to create a better policy for practice scenarios.

"It's very clear we have members in our community who are going to have different histories with the police," said Abby Deshman, who wrote the letter and is the criminal justice program director with the association.

"For those people, it is extremely traumatic for them to hear or witness gunfire."

Deshman said officers should not do this type of training right in the city — especially during a pandemic.

"People are on alert. People are nervous," Deshman said. "This is not a remote area where people aren't going to overhear."

At the very least, Deshman and Aguero said they want police to notify all residents and passersby in the area of what they're doing.

Police training in building for last 2 years

The Winnipeg Police Service declined a CBC request for an interview.

In an email, spokesperson Const. Jay Murray said police have trained in the abandoned building used for the May 25 exercise for the last two years.

Murray said 911 operators are always warned ahead of time, in case they get any calls.

Police also inform residents in the "immediate" area, Murray said, but would not elaborate on what sort of radius that involves.

But Deshman said police need to be doing a better job to communicate with residents.

"It is understandably terrifying to hear shouting and gunshots in your neighbourhood," Deshman said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.