Manitoba

Winnipeg mayor open to releasing ambulance video from emergency call that led to review

Mayor Brian Bowman says he supports releasing any new information that would shed light on an emergency call for an Indigenous patient last October, but there are legal and privacy issues that need to be addressed. 

Union representing Winnipeg firefighters says video from ambulance shows proper care was given to patient

The United Fire Fighters of Winnipeg says it wants the city to release ambulance video from an October 2020 call that led to a third-party review. That review suggested there was evidence of implicit bias and lack of concern for the injured Indigenous patient on the part of firefighters. (Jaison Empson/CBC)

Winnipeg's mayor says he supports releasing any new information that would shed light on what happened during an emergency call for an Indigenous patient that led to a workplace complaint and a third-party review.

However, Brian Bowman says there are legal and privacy issues that need to be addressed. 

The United Fire Fighters of Winnipeg wants the city to release the video from the ambulance on the October 2020 call, following a stinging report suggesting there was evidence of implicit bias and lack of concern for the injured Indigenous patient.

"I do support the release of as much information related to this matter as possible at the appropriate time," Bowman said during a news conference Wednesday.

"What [UFFW president Alex] Forrest is requesting, however, involves addressing legal and privacy protections afforded to his members, the patient, as well as other city unions and employees."

An investigation was spurred by a complaint from an ambulance paramedic who attended a call about a 23-year-old woman on Oct. 7, 2020, who had a self-inflicted stab wound to the neck.

The paramedic alleged there was a delay in transporting the patient to the hospital because of a disagreement between two firefighters at the scene about who should come along in the ambulance, and that one of the firefighters "blatantly refused" to help.

The firefighters' union says time-stamped video evidence from the ambulance on the call will show "the firefighters in question did not fail to provide proper medical care" or delay transportation for the patient to the hospital. 

"This incident is not an issue of racism, nor does it represent our long-standing commitment to fighting intolerance and promoting diversity within the fire service," the UFFW said in a Wednesday statement. 

A set of hearings are underway to determine whether any of the city of Winnipeg staff on the emergency call should be disciplined. They are all on leave while that process is going on. 

Mayor Brian Bowman says he's asked for a meeting with leaders from the UFFW and the Manitoba Government and General Employees' Union, which represents ambulance paramedics. (Jeff Stapleton/CBC )

Bowman singled out UFFW president Alex Forrest in a call with reporters on Wednesday, saying the union can lead the way by getting his members to sign waivers to allow the release of all materials from the call, including any video evidence.

"The starting place for Mr. Forrest would be to provide written consents of his members for the release of all of their information pertaining to this matter," Bowman said. 

Bowman wants meeting with unions on racism

Bowman says he's sent a letter this week to the heads of the Manitoba Government and General Employees' Union (MGEU), the UFFW and the Winnipeg Fire Paramedic Senior Officers' Association, inviting their leaders to meet with him, the city's acting CAO and WFPS Chief John Lane.

Bowman said so far, he has only received a response from the head of the senior officers' association.

The MGEU — the union representing ambulance paramedics — says it has also accepted the invite.

"Let's be frank — the two largest unions at the centre of this [are the] UFFW and MGEU," Bowman said.

"[They] don't always get along and they haven't for many, many years. And I'll say this: when they can't even acknowledge the existence of systemic racism, one has to ask, why not?" 

The MGEU released a statement on Wednesday, in which president Michelle Gawronsky took issue with the mayor's comments.

She said that it was MGEU that filed the complaint about the incident, which prompted the City of Winnipeg to conduct an independent investigation.

"A simple internet search of recent media coverage shows several MGEU statements against racism in the WFPS," Gawronsky said in the statement. 

"The mayor's suggestion that MGEU has not called out racism is an obvious lie, probably intended to distract from his failure to make any progress in dealing with workplace culture of the WFPS."

She urged the mayor to exercise his "legal responsibility as the employer" to ensure a workplace free from "these behaviours."

"The mayor has the authority to fix this problem. He should use it. Emergency services are too important to allow this situation continue."

Bowman also pointed a finger at the province of Manitoba, which has broad control of the ambulance paramedic service in Winnipeg.

"There is a tremendous amount of stress about the future of the service that's been the elephant in the room for many years," Bowman said.

"We've been looking for direction from the provincial government on what they would like to do with ambulance services, which is in their areas of jurisdiction."

WATCH | Mayor open to releasing ambulance video that led to review:

Mayor open to releasing ambulance video that led to review

CBC News Manitoba

2 months ago
2:24
Winnipeg's mayor says he supports releasing any new information that would shed light on what happened during an emergency call for an Indigenous patient that led to a workplace complaint and a third-party review. 2:24

now