Manitoba·Analysis

Did Brian Bowman err in sitting out the first 4 months of Winnipeg's mayoral race?

With two-thirds of the campaign over, Brian Bowman has yet to make a policy pledge. Has the incumbent mayor has committed a strategic error?

Incumbent's decision to forgo policy pledges has allowed room for challenger Jenny Motkaluk to get name out

Winnipeg Mayor Brian Bowman attended the relaunch of the original Pizza Pop in West Kildonan in June. The incumbent has been busy this summer, but has not made any re-election campaign policy pledges. (John Woods/The Canadian Press)

Throughout the month of August, incumbent Winnipeg mayoral candidate Brian Bowman was absolutely everywhere — except in front of a podium making campaign announcements.

With two-thirds of the mayoral race leading up to election day on Oct. 24 over, Bowman has yet to unveil a single policy plank in his re-election campaign.

To some voters, this may seem unremarkable. An incumbent mayor has less of a need to define himself, given that voters are very familiar with his name and image.

He also promised back in May, at the start at the mayoral campaign period, to forgo policy announcements until after the Labour Day weekend.

Mayoral candidate Jenny Motkaluk has been making policy announcements throughout the spring and summer. (John Einarson/CBC)

In recent Winnipeg election-campaign history, this is not business as usual — even in a campaign that started with a very well-known incumbent facing off against lesser-known challengers.

In 2014, the wide-open race to succeed Sam Katz saw candidates, including Bowman, float ideas early and often throughout the spring and summer.

The 2010 race, a head-to-head contest between Katz and former NDP MP and MLA Judy Wasylycia-Leis, was in some ways even livelier.

Even during Katz's first re-election campaign in 2006, when he faced relatively little opposition, the former mayor started making policy announcements in June, not September.

'Substantial stuff' coming: Campaign manager

Leaving aside the idea Winnipeggers deserved to hear more from Bowman and other candidates during this campaign — only business consultant Jenny Motkaluk and, to a lesser extent, former Winnipeg Transit driver Don Woodstock have actually been active this spring and summer — the question is whether the incumbent mayor has committed a strategic error by essentially ceding the policy arena thus far.​

"I don't think so. He was very busy meeting with people. It wasn't like he was holed up in the office," said Bowman campaign manager Kelly McCrae, a member of the mayor's office who's taken a leave to work on the candidate's re-election bid.

McCrae notes Bowman has been very busy all summer, meeting directly with voters.

The incumbent mayor's social media presence bears witness to this activity: pictures of Bowman attending Folklorama pavilions, visiting small businesses and attending street festivals can be found on the mayor's Instagram, Facebook and Twitter accounts.

McCrae contends now, as Bowman did in May, that Winnipeggers pay more attention in September, when kids are back in school, their parents return from holidays and election signs appear on lawns.

"Once the policies are flowing, there's going to be some substantial stuff and people will take notice," McRae said.

Pragmatic promises from challenger

As much as being an incumbent is an advantage — no sitting mayor in Winnipeg has been defeated since Stephen Juba knocked off George Sharpe in 1956 — owning a four-year track record gives Bowman something to defend.

And it can be more difficult to make policy pledges once you know how city hall actually works.

There is more room for challengers to make ambitious or even grandiose gestures, although the most visible among the candidates has largely made small and pragmatic promises.

So far, Jenny Motkaluk has only made a single enormously expensive campaign pledge: she wants to spend more than half a billion dollars on new electric buses. 

Not coincidentally, this big-ticket pledge has been the only Motkaluk announcement to provoke a strong response from Bowman, who called it wasteful and unrealistic.

Motkaluk's campaign has tried to use Bowman's support for reopening Portage and Main to pedestrians as a wedge to separate the incumbent from a contingent of his 2014 base. (Lyzaville Sale/CBC)

Motkaluk campaign manager Keith Poulson, a veteran of several federal Conservative and provincial Progressive Conservative efforts, said his candidate has made an effort to cost out her announcements.

"We're not pulling stuff out of the air," Poulson said.

More significantly, Motkaluk's team has tried to zero in on what many city hall observers perceive to be Bowman's primary weakness: a lot of his 2014 support came from conservative suburban voters, who may not be enamoured with some of the incumbent mayor's more progressive and urbanist policies.

Chief among them are Bowman's support for reopening Portage and Main to pedestrians as well as his intention to build more rapid-transit corridors.

During the first two months of her campaign, Motkaluk did very little but rail against those two ideas, trying to use them as a wedge to separate Bowman from a contingent of his 2014 base.

The strategy, devised with the help of policy analyst Brian Kelcey — a former Sam Katz adviser who quit and turned against the former mayor — appears to have allowed Motkaluk to set herself apart from the other Bowman challengers.

"For our purposes, we wanted to define Jenny as not just a name on a ballot. I think we've achieved that," Poulson said. "Basically, every conversation we have [with voters] now is her versus the incumbent."

Motkaluk has a lot of work to do if she wishes to knock off an incumbent mayor. It may be that when voters get to know her better, they may not find her as appealing as they find the charismatic, friendly Bowman.

Or it may be Bowman's campaign erred in sitting out the first four months of a six-month race.

Now that it's September, there is no time left to defer policy to later in the campaign.

About the Author

Bartley Kives

Reporter, CBC Manitoba

Reporter Bartley Kives joined CBC Manitoba in 2016. Prior to that, he spent three years at the Winnipeg Sun and 18 at the Winnipeg Free Press, writing about politics, music, food and outdoor recreation. He's the author of the Canadian bestseller A Daytripper's Guide to Manitoba: Exploring Canada's Undiscovered Province and co-author of both Stuck in the Middle: Dissenting Views of Winnipeg and Stuck In The Middle 2: Defining Views of Manitoba. His work has also appeared in publications such as the Guardian and Explore magazine.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.