Manitoba

Winnipeg fountains flowing again after neighbours grumbled

Winnipeg has turned on the taps for neighbourhood fountains that better resembled cement bowls this year than anything spewing water. 

City department says it won't help with growing algae, but it doesn't mean fountains are useless: councillors

These fountains are operating again, after the city reverted a previous decision to shut down 12 fountains in an effort to save money. (Submitted/Janice Lukes)

Winnipeg has turned on the taps for neighbourhood fountains that better resembled cement bowls this year than anything spewing water.

After an outcry from neighbours who blamed the decommissioned fountains for excessive algae levels, city council voted last month to revert an earlier decision to close a dozen fountains in retention ponds to save money.

Some of the fountains began spouting last week, said Waverley West Coun. Janice Lukes, who pushed for the reversal.

The councillor has been greeted by photos of functioning fountains in her email inbox, she said.

"People get very upset when they're paying taxes, higher taxes, on the backs of these ponds. They want to see the fountain," Lukes said.

The water and waste department shut down the fountains after being ordered to find financial savings from the city. The decision was supposed to save $320,000 over four years.

Residents blamed thick algae on the fact the city shut down several fountains in retention ponds. (Lyzaville Sale/CBC)

The city has been asked to find the money from salaries it isn't paying through vacancy management. 

A department official, however, told Winnipeg's executive policy committee last month that turning on the fountains will do nothing to control the algae or stop the mosquito population from booming.

Director Moira Geer attributed various other factors, including high temperatures, strong winds delaying the spreading of herbicides and heavy rains flushing nutrients into the ponds.

'Purely esthetic'

The fountains, she said, "doesn't have a function, it's purely esthetic."

Even if that's the case, water and waste chair Brian Mayes told the EPC meeting that labelling the fountains for only their esthetic purposes downplays its value.

"If you own a home near Fountainview Park, which is named Fountainview Park because there's a view of the fountain, there's nothing else in the park — there's no cafe, there's no cricket pitch," the St. Vital councillor said at the EPC meeting.

"If the one function in the park is a fountain, I think it does matter to people."

Mayes said in an interview Saturday that turning off the fountains was an inadvertent consequence of passing the budget, which he's pleased the city has rectified. 

The director of the city's water and waste department says the herbicide program was delayed this year due to high wind levels. (Submitted by Janice Lukes)

Lukes said the months without running fountains shows the downfall of only having select councillors poring over budget drafting documents every year. The process is restricted to the mayor's inner circle, known as the executive policy committee.

She dismisses the city's position that the fountains are solely decorative, arguing that even a little water circulation in these ponds would help with aeration.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now