Some Winnipeg patients sick enough for hospital admission waiting days for in-patient bed

A Winnipeg hospital admissions bottleneck, which doctors attribute to staff shortages across the health-care system, has turned emergency departments into overflow wards, with a vastly reduced capacity to treat people with urgent issues.

Emergency departments have become overflow wards, compromising in-patient and urgent care, doctor says

Myrna Oliver, with her husband Brian, spent two-and-a-half days in Grace Hospital's emergency ward this week. She was slated to be admitted but left after the long wait for an in-patient bed. (Submitted by Brian Oliver)

Some patients deemed sick enough to be admitted to Winnipeg hospitals are waiting days in emergency wards for a bed in an in-patient ward.

This admissions bottleneck, which doctors attribute to widespread staff shortages across the health-care system, has turned emergency departments into hospital overflow wards, with a vastly reduced capacity to treat people with urgent issues.

Citing data from May 4, Manitoba Shared Health said the average time for an emergency department patient to be admitted to another ward at one of Winnipeg's three largest hospitals ranged from 11.6 to 15.4 hours.

That's on top of the 11 to 17 hours it took for the average patient at Grace Hospital, St. Boniface Hospital and Health Sciences Centre on that day to undergo triage and registration at an emergency department, wait to be seen by a doctor and then receive a determination they should be admitted.

Those average waits, however, belie a full range of admission wait times that can be measured in days instead of hours.

Emergency department data obtained by CBC News shows over the past three weeks, there have been times when the median wait for admission was more than 24 hours, with some patients waiting in emergency three or four days for a hospital bed — and in one extreme case, six days.

Patients deemed sick enough to be admitted to Grace Hospital waited another 11.6 hours, on average, to get a bed on May 4, according to Shared Health. Some patients are waiting far longer, doctors say. (Trevor Brine/CBC)

For Myrna Oliver, who suffers from cracked vertebrae, the wait in a hospital emergency ward proved too long to endure.

On Mother's Day, the 79-year-old resident of Twin Lakes Beach went to Grace Hospital's emergency department. The next morning, she was deemed ill enough to be admitted to hospital.

But after 36 more hours of waiting at Grace without being bathed or taken for a walk to ease her pain and stiffness — and having to use washrooms where her socks got soaked with urine from other patients  — she asked her husband to take her back to the apartment they have been renting near the hospital.

"It's like you're in a catch-22 system," said Brian Oliver, her husband. "If you stay, it's not good. If you go home, other than you're in your clean home environment in bed [you don't] improve."

He said he saw dozens of patients on beds lined up in the hallways of Grace's emergency department, all clamouring for the attention of hospital workers who are forced to avoid eye contact with patients just to ensure they can carry out all their duties.

"I feel very, very sorry for the nurses. These are people who are trained … to help," he said.

'Tired of constantly apologizing': ER doctor

Dr. Kristjan Thompson, a St. Boniface emergency doctor who also serves as president of Doctors Manitoba, said his emergency ward suffers from the same issue.

"I'm getting tired of constantly apologizing to folks who've waited in pain in our waiting room, who have been suffering a great deal," he said.

Thompson said on Thursday, 35 patients at St. Boniface emergency — which has room for 55 patients — were waiting to be admitted to either hospital or another facility, such as a personal care home. 

Fifteen of those patients had been waiting more than a day, 10 had been waiting more than 40 hours and one patient had been waiting 90 hours, or just under four days.

Dr. Kristjan Thompson, a St. Boniface emergency physician, is also president of Doctors Manitoba. He says a chronic lack of a capacity for hospital in-patient care has turned emergency departments into overflow wards. (Zoom)

The issue is a shortage of care capacity in hospitals that has forced emergency departments to become overflow wards, both for patients requiring in-patient medical care and for people who need intensive care, Thompson said.

"When there's a problem in the ER, it means that there's a problem everywhere in the entire system," he said.

"When the ICU is full, patients that need the most intensive and critical care receive it in the ER until a bed is found. When the hospital is full for patients that require in-patient care, they receive it in the ER until a bed is found."

Since hospitals are always full, he said, patients in emergency who are waiting for admission displace those who come to emergency wards for urgent treatment.

That, in turn, creates the long wait emergency wait times that have garnered headlines in recent weeks.

"I want folks to realize that this is a symptom of a much greater problem," Thompson said. "It's a sign that our health-care system is in a dire crisis."

Though COVID-19 made the problem more obvious, it predates the pandemic, he said.

"And it will continue to be a problem long after the pandemic if we do not address the core issues at play here."

Working on patient flow: Shared Health

Shared Health does not dispute Thompson's assertion the hospital system is struggling.

"These challenges are causing longer wait times for patients who have lower-acuity concerns as well as for patients awaiting admission to an in-patient unit," the provincial agency said in a statement last week.

Shared Health said it's trying to improve patient flow by placing doctors in triage, managing ambulance movements and improving lab turnaround times for patients who require admission.

Health Minister Audrey Gordon, meanwhile, blamed the capacity issues on COVID-19.

"The unprecedented global COVID-19 pandemic continues to affect patient flow causing challenges in Winnipeg emergency departments," her office said in a statement.

Thompson said the real issue is the inability to treat patients across the hospital system.

"It's in-patient capacity and a lack of staff upstairs or across our entire health-care system. That's the true bottleneck."

The numbers on waits for admission are "awful," he said, "and they're just getting worse."

Myrna Oliver ended up back at Grace Hospital's emergency ward on Thursday. Her husband Brian said as of Sunday evening she was lying on a bed in a hallway, still waiting to be admitted.

He said he would like the health minister to visit an emergency ward. 

"Has she ever come in at eight at night when the hallways are full of people seeking medical help?" he said.

"How can she not realize what a state of affairs our health-care system is in?"

Waiting days in emergency wards for a bed

3 months ago
Duration 2:45
Winnipeg hospitals have another wait-time problem. Some patients are waiting days for a hospital bed even after doctors decide to admit them. Myrna Oliver gave up on getting into Grace Hospital. Her husband Brian Oliver says she pleased to go home after she waited 36 hours for a bed.


Bartley Kives

Senior reporter, CBC Manitoba

Bartley Kives joined CBC Manitoba in 2016. Prior to that, he spent three years at the Winnipeg Sun and 18 at the Winnipeg Free Press, writing about politics, music, food and outdoor recreation. He's the author of the Canadian bestseller A Daytripper's Guide to Manitoba: Exploring Canada's Undiscovered Province and co-author of both Stuck in the Middle: Dissenting Views of Winnipeg and Stuck In The Middle 2: Defining Views of Manitoba.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?