Trudeau's scheme to dismiss some carbon tax plans shows he wants a fight: Manitoba premier

Justin Trudeau's government is making its case for re-election by pitting itself against the provinces who oppose his carbon tax, Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister asserts.

Our green plan better than federally approved strategies in Quebec and Newfoundland, Brian Pallister says

Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister, right, says it's obvious Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is formulating a re-election strategy by tangling with the provinces, including Manitoba, who did not support his green plan. (Trevor Hagan/The Canadian Press)

Justin Trudeau's government is making its case for re-election by pitting itself against the provinces who oppose his carbon tax, Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister asserts.

Pallister is disgruntled his made-in-Manitoba green plan got the thumbs-down when other climate plans he deems insufficient, like Quebec's and Newfoundland and Labrador's, were approved. 

"The politics in this is evident," said Pallister​.

"They believe they have a coalition of urban Ontario, Quebec east and B.C., and they think they can win the next election on that basis. I don't want to sound cynical, but I've seen this too many times from Liberal governments." 

Pallister held court with media Wednesday afternoon to decry what he characterizes as the divisive tactics of the federal government.

He said governments should be working together to fight climate change, not bickering over a "two-tiered carbon tax structure."

Manitoba being dismissed: Pallister

Pallister said Quebec's cap-and-trade program is much less stringent than the flat $25-per-tonne price he proposed before he withdrew the carbon tax — a main tenant of his green plan — because Ottawa wasn't satisfied.

He added Newfoundland and Labrador is receiving concessions for its plan because of its under-construction Muskrat Falls hydroelectric project, but Manitoba isn't being recognized for the clean energy it produces.

Watch Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs Dominic LeBlanc explain the backstop on Power & Politics:

Dominic LeBlanc on imposing a carbon tax on provinces

4 years ago
Duration 8:56
'Climate change is real, people expect their governments to take action,' says the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs.

"They will not give us consideration for either getting out of coal, which we've just done, or our hydroelectric investments, which we're in the middle of investing," Pallister said.

"We're not getting credit for what we're really doing and Newfoundland is getting credit for something they may do. This does not make sense."

On Tuesday, the federal government followed through on its threat to slap a carbon tax on the provinces without an adequate emissions pricing plans of their own: Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Ontario, and New Brunswick.

'Lack of leadership on pricing pollution'

In a statement Wednesday, Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs Dominic LeBlanc said the federal government tried to give Manitoba the flexibility to come up with a plan. 

"Earlier this month, Manitoba [cancelled] their own plan to price pollution. In making pollution free again, they joined the Harper-Scheer Conservatives who have no plan to fight climate change," LeBlanc said. 

"We are disappointed with the Manitoba government's lack of leadership on pricing pollution. As we've said all along, if provinces refuse to make polluters pay, we will — and we'll give the money back to Canadians," he said.

"We know that making polluters pay is good for the economy and good for the environment, which means that it's good for the middle class."

To offset most of the added costs of the carbon tax, annual rebates will be sent to Canadian families.

In Manitoba, the average family will pay $233 more in 2019 as a result of the carbon tax, and get a $336 rebate in the first year of the plan. That's a net rebate of $104, based on average costs and rebates.

The $20-per-tonne carbon tax, along with the rebate to each Manitoban, will rise every year until the $50-per-tonne target is reached in 2022. 

How the new carbon plan works

4 years ago
Duration 1:31
The federal Liberal government will slap a carbon tax on fuels in provinces and territories with no adequate emissions pricing plans of their own. But how will it work? The National explains.

Pallister said Wednesday his government would decide within a couple weeks whether it will proceed with a legal challenge. The province may strike out on its own, rather than intervene in the case pursued by Ontario and Saskatchewan, he said.

Propensity to quit

It is Pallister, not Trudeau, who should be blamed for making politically motivated decisions, Manitoba Liberal Leader Dougald Lamont said.

"He shouldn't be talking about suing people. He should be at the table trying to negotiate something, but that's not what happened — he walked away."

NDP Leader Wab Kinew said the carbon agreements Trudeau reached with other provinces shows a desire to negotiate.

"It sounds like the premier gave up too easily," he said.

Pallister said he has not had formal discussions with Ottawa on the carbon tax since Manitoba's surprise decision earlier this month to scrap his plan. He said discussions between the governments in recent weeks have centred on assurances Ottawa would still give Manitoba $67 million to help reduce carbon emissions, as previously announced.

The $20-per-tonne carbon tax will result in an approximate cost increase of 4.42 cents a litre for gasoline, 3.91 cents per cubic metre for natural gas and 3.10 cents a litre for propane, according to the federal government.

"What Ottawa is proposing to do, as I understand it, is kick it back on a per capita basis — and that isn't a plan."

4 years ago
Duration 2:05
The carbon pricing scheme Ottawa will impose is not as revenue-neutral as the federal government insists, Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister is arguing.


Ian Froese

Provincial Affairs Reporter

Ian Froese is a reporter for CBC Manitoba. You can reach him at


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Account Holder

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?