'This is love for Tina': Crowd marches for change in honour of Tina Fontaine in Winnipeg

A child's cry cut through a moment of silence as more than 1,000 people huddled in the cold at The Forks in Winnipeg to reflect on the life of Tina Fontaine, one day after a jury found the man accused of killing the Indigenous teen not guilty.

More than 1,000 people gather to support family after man found not guilty in teen's death

      1 of 0

      A child's cry cut through a moment of silence as more than 1,000 people huddled in the cold in Winnipeg to quietly reflect on the life of Tina Fontaine, one day after a jury found the man accused of killing the Indigenous teen not guilty.

      The group gathered at the courts in downtown Winnipeg on Friday morning to march in honour of Fontaine, whose 72-pound body was pulled from the Red River on Aug. 17, 2014, wrapped in a duvet cover weighed down by rocks.

      NDP status of women and families critic Nahanni Fontaine, right, consoles Thelma Favel after making an emotional speech. (Bryce Hoye/CBC)

      "My son and my husband, we did what we could to bring justice to my baby girl," Thelma Favel, Fontaine's great-aunt who spent more than a decade raising her, told the crowd through tears.

      "We just want this violence to stop. Make it safer for younger children in this world. Tina I know is here beside me right now and is looking upon you guys and is appreciating everything you are doing," Favel said.

      "I can't express how much gratitude I have for each and every one of you."

      Watch Thelma's emotional speech to the crowd:

      Thelma Favel gets emotional as she thanks the hundreds of people who took part in the march to hounour Tina Fontaine. 1:40

      A jury acquitted Raymond Cormier, 56, of second-degree murder on Thursday after 11 hours of deliberation.

      The verdict was met with despair and anger by family and Indigenous leaders.

      "The CFS [Child and Family Services] system has definitely failed Tina Fontaine, the Winnipeg Police Services failed Tina Fontaine and Canadian society failed Tina Fontaine," said Kevin Hart, the Assembly of First Nations regional chief for Manitoba. 

      "Everybody right now across this country should be ashamed of themselves for the injustice that just occurred here."

      'We want justice'

      That message of accountability was present in the many speeches at the march Friday, but so too were calls for unity.

      In a prayer, march co-organizer Thelma Morrisseau said this was a day of "love and peace and unity for our daughter, our granddaughter, our niece, our little sister that we have lost."

      "We all feel it too because it could have been our daughter, it could have been our granddaughter. We don't want this to continue. We want it to stop."

      Watch Morrisseau call for peace and unity:

      Organizer Thelma Morrisseau says Tina Fontaine's great-aunt Thelma Favel wants marchers to walk with sacred thoughts. 0:41

      Sounds of drumming, traditional song and shouts of "we want justice" echoed through downtown during the nearly three-hour long event, which wound past the Canadian Museum for Human Rights and ended at Oodena Circle, the sacred site at the confluence of the Red and Assiniboine rivers at The Forks.

      ​"I want you all to look around you — this is love for Tina," said University of Winnipeg professor Niigaan Sinclair as the crowd at Oodena Circle cheered.

      Not two weeks ago, Sinclair stood in the same spot and spoke out against injustices facing Indigenous people after Saskatchewan farmer Gerald Stanley was acquitted in the shooting death of Colton Boushie.

      Sinclair said Indigenous women are disproportionately affected by violence and Canadians need to empower them.

      "We have to hear from them [women] and we have to hear from the children, too. Those brave voices are the ones we need to step beside and stand beside them today."

      Zoey Travese, 10, of Shoal Lake First Nation, attended the march with her mother and family.

      Zoey Travese attended the march with family. (Jeff Stapleton/CBC)

      As an Indigenous girl not much younger than Tina was, Traverse says her mother often warns her to be careful and not to "dilly dally" on her walk to and from school.

      "I'm kind of feeling scared," she said.

      Dakota Wapash held a sign that read "No Justice, No Reconciliation" as he walked to The Forks.

      Dakota Wapash said he feels like the justice system isn't going to improve for Indigenous people, though he said he was inspired by the turnout at the march. (Bryce Hoye/CBC)

      He said he participated because he wanted to take a stand and "to let the people know that we're not going to put up with it anymore."

      "I feel like the system has failed all of us," he said, adding it felt fulfilling to stand up for the rights of Indigenous people at the march. "Proud to be here… I just want to see changes."

      Organizers also said the march was meant to underscore systemic racism and structural problems within Canada's justice and social services systems which critics say failed Fontaine.

      Watch three views on why the march is important:

      Marchers call for better representation on the justice system and ask how this affects reconciliation. 0:58

      Tina's body was found eight days after she was reported missing in August 2014. Originally from Sagkeeng First Nation, she had only been in Winnipeg for six weeks before she was found dead. During that time she came into contact with paramedics, police, security officers and staff at the Children's Hospital and Child and Family Services. 

      Tina, who jurors learned was sexually exploited during her time in Winnipeg, was in the care of CFS when she ran away and never returned. The department had been keeping her in a hotel in Winnipeg, a former emergency overflow housing practice the Manitoba government ended after Fontaine's death.

      'Feel I've failed as a social worker'

      Travis Bighetty, born in Pukatawagan Cree Nation in northern Manitoba, says he was in court when the Cormier verdict was read Thursday.

      As a social worker and a volunteer with the North End watch group Bear Clan Patrol, Bighetty says he felt in that moment he had failed Tina and that as an Indigenous man the system has failed him.

      Travis Bighetty says he was encouraged by the turnout and wants Canadians to work together to make life more just for Indigenous Peoples. (Jeff Stapleton/CBC)

      "I just felt sick, I felt disgusted to be part of that system, but coming here today, representing Bear Clan, being a part of the community, being a part of this family, I feel proud," he said. 

      "I feel connected, and I feel I've failed as a social worker but I am not going to fail as an Indigenous man."

      Leah Gazan, a social justice advocate and Indigenous studies instructor at the University of Winnipeg, said she was in Toronto when she heard the verdict and broke into tears.

      "We have a justice system right now that's clearly different, depending on who you are, between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Canadians," she said.

      "Our kids are not disposable. We need to take an active stance so they get a clear message that their lives matter and that people are watching and that they're loved."

      Gazan believes reconciliation is a long way off "in the absence of justice."

      "We need to go beyond conversations and rhetoric," she said. "There needs to be swift action, certainly, looking at the justice system and how it is stacked against Indigenous people and the systems that are supposed to protect our kids but are leaving them vulnerable."

      Thelma Fontaine clutches flowers and cries while surrounded by family and supporters at Oodena Circle at the Forks. (Jeff Stapleton/CBC)

      Bighetty said what has to happen now is that Indigenous people, including those involved in the child and family system, not be treated as "wards of the state."

      "We're not against the police, we're not against the justice system, we're not against CFS, but at the same time, we want to walk in solidarity with them, we want our voices heard," he said.

      "It needs to change from us being in the background to us not being at the front but walking together."

      Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister said his administration is working toward resolving long-standing issues in CFS.

      "Tina's death should serve as a call to action for all of us," Pallister said in a statement. "In our sadness, we must be motivated to make a difference."

      Meanwhile Sheila North, grand chief of Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak, who has criticized how the inquiry into missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls has been managed, said she remains cautiously optimistic it will serve a positive purpose.

      "At moments like this I think we're reminded that we are all human beings," she said.

      A child's cry cut through a moment of silence as more than 1,000 people huddled in the cold in Winnipeg to quietly reflect on the life of Tina Fontaine, one day after a jury found the man accused of killing the Indigenous teen not guilty. 2:03

      Live blog of the march

      About the Author

      Bryce Hoye

      Reporter

      Bryce Hoye is an award-winning journalist and science writer with a background in wildlife biology. Before joining CBC Manitoba, he worked for the Canadian Wildlife Service monitoring birds in Manitoba, the Northwest Territories, Nova Scotia and Alberta. Story idea? Email bryce.hoye@cbc.ca.

      With files from Shane Gibson, Jillian Taylor and the Canadian Press