Manitoba

The price of Winnipeg's water: one reserve's man-made misery

Using gravel carved out from Shoal Lake's ancestral land, crews built a dam to ensure Winnipeg's water supply remained untainted. On one side, contaminated water flows to the residents of Shoal Lake 40 reserve. On the other side, clean water flows to Winnipeg.

For 17 years, residents of Shoal Lake 40 have been under a boil water advisory

Shoal Lake 40 residents have dubbed a road, carved out of the wilderness and used when frozen during winter, as Freedom Road. In spring and summer, however, it is an impassable muddy mess. The community dreams of an all-weather road but estimates it would cost about $30 million. (Chinta Puxley/Twitter)

More than 30 years have passed, but Janis Redsky can still see the flashing lights of the ambulance she desperately needed.

She was pregnant and crippled by searing abdominal pains, stranded on her reserve Shoal Lake 40 — an island carved off a century ago for construction of an aquaduct to provide water to the city of Winnipeg.

The ambulance sat on the opposite shore, less than a kilometre away, as Redsky and her husband tried to find a way across.

"All we could do was look at the ambulance — a physical view of help waiting across the water," recalls her husband, Stewart, breaking down into tears.

After an hour, Redsky watched it turn around and drive away. It would be another two hours before Redsky made it to a hospital in Kenora, Ont.

By then, she had lost the baby. She needed to be revived on the operating table and spent 10 days in hospital. She is unable to have any more children.

"I love children. We did lots of fostering but it's not the same," said Redsky, who is a daycare teacher.

"It still traumatizes me to this day," says her husband. "I always wonder if we had help immediately, if those three hours would have made a difference."

Cut off on an island

Redsky's ancestors lived on the shores of Shoal Lake along the Manitoba-Ontario boundary at the turn of the last century when a delegation from Winnipeg came looking for a fresh-water source for the Manitoba capital some 140 kilometres away.

News reports from the time noted the delegation believed the spot was largely uninhabited, "with the exception of a few Indians."

Heavy equipment moved in and Shoal Lake residents moved out, on to a peninsula across the bay. That land became an island when crews cut a channel to divert tannin-laden, boggy water coming from Falcon Lake away from the aquaduct intake for Winnipeg.

Using gravel carved out from Shoal Lake's ancestral land, crews built a dam to ensure Winnipeg's water remained untainted. On one side, contaminated water flows to the residents of Shoal Lake 40 reserve. On the other side, clean water flows to Winnipeg.

A running water system was built for Shoal Lake 40 in the 1990s but it did not meet standards and there was a cryptosporidiosis outbreak in 1997.

For 17 years, its 270 residents have remained under a boil water advisory, the second longest-running advisory of its type, according to Health Canada.

Freedom Road

The band believes having an all-weather road is key to solving its water problems, as supplies could be trucked in to build a treatment plant at a reasonable price.

"Having a road means a water treatment plant. It means an economy, it means survival as a community," said Cuyler Cotton, a policy analyst with the First Nation.

Shoal Lake, where Winnipeg gets its drinking water, has no zebra mussels, but some experts say it's ripe for an infestation of the invasive water pest. (Roxanne K. Greene)
But the problems with a lack of a road run deeper than clean water.

Every year, people in Shoal Lake 40 fall through the ice trying to get into the community. In Redsky's case, emergency medical help was delayed.

"People have died in that water," Cotton says.

A century later, residents are still waiting for a historic wrong to be set right.

The community estimates an all-weather road would cost about $30 million. The federal government, Manitoba and the City of Winnipeg have all chipped in $1 million each for a feasibility study, but there are no firm commitments beyond that.

Residents have dubbed it Freedom Road. It's already been carved out of the wilderness and is used, with caution, when frozen during the winter. In spring and summer, however, it is an impassable muddy mess.

Stewart Redsky says he has been lobbying for Freedom Road for so long that his family calls him a "broken record."

"It's tough with the community being in a state of hopelessness," he says. "It's a challenge to live and survive each and every day."

'Complex issues'

Next year, Linda Redsky's foster son will have to leave the reserve to attend high school. Without year-round access to the reserve, he will have to board in Kenora.

At least he will have access to clean water, she says. He suffers from severe eczema and other skin conditions.

We're living in these conditions because of something that we didn't do.- Linda Redsky

The reserve spends $100,000 a year on bottled water to drink, but people still bathe and do laundry in the untreated water. When she runs a bath, Redsky covers up the faucet with a facecloth so the tub doesn't fill up with debris.

"You feel angry when you think about it," says Redsky, who has fallen through the ice twice trying to get home. "We're living in these conditions because of something that we didn't do."

Aboriginal Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt declined to be interviewed about Shoal Lake.

One of the first things Kevin Chief did when he was appointed Manitoba's minister responsible for Winnipeg was visit Shoal Lake 40. The community has been through feasibility studies before but Chief says it's different this time.

"We would not commit $1 million if we were not serious and committed to getting this road completed," says Chief. "It's a priority for me, it's a priority for my government."

Winnipeg Mayor Brian Bowman says the city has committed $4 million to Shoal Lake 40's Freedom Road but stopped short of committing cash. Winnipeg wants to be a "responsible partner" with the First Nation, he says.

"These are complex issues and it involves Winnipeg's water supply," Bowman said.

"It's also imperative that the government of Canada step up to contribute to the health and accessibility of the First Nation."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.