Rural Manitoba mother stunned by 64-minute wait for paramedics

A Manitoba mom wants rural ambulance service expanded, not cut, after it took paramedics more than an hour to reach her four-year-old daughter in May.

Aimee Sobry speaks out against province's plan to shut down rural ambulance station

Aimee Sobry and her husband Todd want answers after their daughter Cadee, 4, waited more than an hour for paramedics after being pinned underneath an ATV in May. (Submitted by Aimee Sobry)

A Manitoba mom wants rural ambulance service expanded — not cut as planned by the province — after it took paramedics more than an hour to reach her four-year-old daughter in May.

Cadee Sobry was riding an ATV that flipped on top of her, pinning her to the ground.

Her dad called 911 and paramedics were dispatched while her mom, Aimee Sobry, rushed home. She was about 20 minutes away, in Melita, and when she arrived, paramedics still hadn't arrived at the family's farm near Reston.

The slow response left the mother stunned.

"I beat the ambulance here to our yard by over 25 minutes. Our farm is not difficult to find," Sobry said, adding her husband called 911 again after waiting for 52 minutes.

She complained about the incident to Prairie Mountain Health and received a letter signed by a manager apologizing for the delay in care.

Prairie Mountain Health did not immediately respond to CBC's request for comment, but a government spokesperson said the province is asking the regional health authority to review the case.

Reston ambulance was on different call

Part of the issue was that the Reston ambulance had already been dispatched to another call so they sent ambulances from Melita and Virden, the letter said. The official couldn't say, however, why Melita paramedics had problems finding the family's farm.

Sobry said a neighbour told the family that paramedics showed up in their yard by mistake and were lost. The paramedics wouldn't say who they were looking for, so the neighbours couldn't direct them to the correct address.

Meanwhile, Mounties were dispatched and sitting a mile away from the accident scene.

Sobry said she's against the Manitoba government's recently announced plan to shut down 18 rural emergency medical stations that house ambulances.

The governing Progressive Conservative Party plans to shut down the paramedic station in Reston.

'Desperate need for rural care'

The changes were recommended in a 2013 report on the province's emergency medical services system. A government spokesperson said the province's plan will serve patients in emergencies more efficiently through five new stations that will be built.

"Our incident shows the desperate need for rural medical care," Sobry said. "If they're going to make all these cuts, it's only going to make it worse."

"There's no need of a Virden ambulance or a Melita ambulance taking an hour to get here," she said. "You can get to Melita by legal speed limit in 25 minutes, and I can get to Virden in under 20 minutes by legal speed limit.

"So how, how is it possible to take you 64 minutes to get here?"

With files from Susan Magas and Austin Grabish


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.