Rival accuses Bowman of pandering to firefighter union by attending Colorado memorial

A candidate for mayor of Winnipeg questioned whether a recent trip Brian Bowman made to Colorado — to attend a memorial for fallen firefighters in North America — was paid for by the Winnipeg firefighters union and if Bowman is in the pocket of union interests.

Diack takes aim at incumbent at CBC mayoral debate; mayor says his office paid for trip

Tim Diack (right) confronted Brian Bowman (left) on whether he accepted travel costs from the Winnipeg fire fighters union to attend a memorial on Sept. 15, 2018 during a live televised debate at CBC Manitoba on Oct. 11, 2018. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

A candidate for mayor of Winnipeg questioned whether a recent trip made by incumbent Brian Bowman — to attend a memorial for fallen firefighters — was paid for by the Winnipeg firefighters union and asked whether Bowman is in the pocket of union interests.

During the CBC mayoral debate on Thursday, Tim Diack referred to a past statement of Bowman's wherein he criticized a time when special interest groups and union leaders allegedly called the shots at city hall, then launched into his question.

"In September, you attended a two-day event in Colorado Springs, Colorado, held by the International Association of Fire Fighters. Who paid for that trip?" Diack asked Bowman, referring to the 2018 Fallen Fire Fighter Memorial.

Bowman denied the his trip to Colorado was paid for by the firefighters union. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

"It would have been resources out of my office that would have paid it," Bowman said.

"I was pleased to attend. That was a ceremony that occurs every year in Colorado Springs out of respect for the fallen."

A spokesman for the mayor's office said the city paid for all of the mayor's travel, including a hotel room, which was part of a block reservation made by the United Fire Fighters of Winnipeg. Communications director Jonathan Hildebrand provided a receipt to the CBC showing Bowman paid for the room.

Hildebrand said the only expense that may have been covered by the union was a buffet dinner provided to Bowman and others at the memorial.

'Ridiculous' mudslinging, says union

Alex Forrest, president of UFFW, said Thursday his union did not pay for Bowman's trip. Forrest said if any costs were covered, the union may have paid for service costs or meal costs that included the family of the fallen firefighter.

The Manitoban honoured in Colorado Springs in September was Jack Nicol, who died of occupational cancer as a result of exposure on the job, said Forrest.

"For any politician to be using this as a type of political mudslinging is absolutely ridiculous," he said.

Watch the exchange between Diack and Bowman:

Tim Diack questions Brian Bowman trip to Colorado firefighters event

4 years ago
Duration 2:40
Bowman says trip was paid for by city.

Bowman's trip to Colorado does not appear in his expense report, Diack said after the debate.

The candidate, who is a Winnipeg police officer, called it "poor leadership" on Bowman's part to "talk to the firefighters" in Colorado and not the police association.

"He hasn't talked to us since 2014. So no, he has not paid the same respect," said Diack. "I just think he's burned a bridge and he can't communicate well."

When given the opportunity to put incumbent Brian Bowman on the spot Thursday, Motkaluk, left, instead directed a question at fellow challenger Umar Hayat, right, who polls suggest has very little chance in the Oct. 24 election. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

Motkaluk misses hit on Bowman

Jenny Motkaluk, the candidate polls suggest has the best chance to unseat Bowman, passed on an opportunity Thursday to question the incumbent head-on.

As part of the CBC forum, candidates could ask another candidate of their choosing a direct question.

Instead of grilling Bowman, she asked Umar Hayat — a candidate who a recent poll commissioned by the Winnipeg Free Press and CTV suggests has one per cent of the vote — what was the first thing he would do if elected mayor. 

Watch Motkaluk ask Hayat her question:

Motkaluk chooses Hayat for question section in debate

4 years ago
Duration 2:15
Jenny Motkaluk passed over fellow frontrunner Brian Bowman

"My decision today was to not provide Brian Bowman with one extra second of air time in front of the voters of Winnipeg," Motkaluk said after the debate.

The format chosen by CBC, allowing all eight candidates time to speak, meant she was unable to get into a fulsome discussion, one-on-one with Bowman, said Motkaluk.

Hayat responded to Motkaluk's question, saying he would review Winnipeg's financial statements.

Ed Ackerman suggested eliminating all fares for Winnipeg Transit riders. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

Candidates debate transit, sewer system

Candidates also shared ideas on public transportation and the way Winnipeg handles sewage treatment.

In a year when transit fares jumped 25 cents to $2.95 a ride, Ed Ackerman called for Winnipeg to make public transit free and allow citizens to build tiny homes near the rail lines.

Don Woodstock, a former Winnipeg Transit driver, said he would reduce fares to $2 and then eventually make fares free to make buses safer.

"You eliminate the fares and you don't have the problems," he said.

Umar Hayat said the city can't afford to make fares free.

Mayoral candidates, from left, Tim Diack, Umar Hayat and Ed Ackerman at Thursday night's CBC debate. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

Later in the debate, candidates challenged Bowman on Winnipeg's handling of wastewater. 

"I think it's absolutely horrifying that in 2018 we still dump raw sewage into our rivers with alarming regularity," said Motkaluk. She is promising to add back-up generators to sewage lift stations which, she said, will eliminate a third of all unintended outflows.

"You don't denigrate the name of our great city," Bowman said in his rebuttal.

Winnipeg has invested millions in modernizing the sewer system to replace combined sewers that hold both storm water and raw sewage, which reduces seepage into the natural waterways, said Bowman.

Last year Manitoba Sustainable Development gave the city until 2045 to capture 85 per cent of the diluted sewage that flows into city rivers during an average year. Wastewater engineers estimate it will cost Winnipeg $4 billion to eliminate all combined-sewer overflows.

Brian Bowman uses a paddle to answer a question at CBC's mayoral debate on Thursday. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

Debate goes to pot

With the legalization of marijuana set for Oct. 17, the candidates were asked for their opinions on pot and whether they plan to use the drug once it becomes legal.

Bowman said he hasn't' smoked pot and has no plans to try it once it's legal. He said his primary concern around legalization is the possible increase in costs to the city for public safety measures.

Motkaluk countered Bowman's worries over cost, saying the cost of policing illegal pot was already a burden on the taxpayer.

She said she sees legalization as a "great opportunity to potentially generate some revenue" and "make sure we get the illegal drugs out of the hands of the people who shouldn't have it."

Diack said he worries legalization will mean users may be more likely to drive while high but sees a potential for police to raise additional funds once pot is legal.

"What I like is that there are high fines," he said. "We'll be able actually to recoup quite a bit of our enforcement costs by issuing tickets to people who are dumb enough to smoke it in their vehicle."

Wilson said his late wife used marijuana while living with leukemia.

"I am not against this happening," he said. "We will not see mass terror in the city."

Ackerman said he thinks the federal government should reissue the $1 bill, instead making it with hemp and marijuana.

"So it can be rolled up and smoked," he said.

"That would be fantastic for foreign exchange, so there you go."

Paddle round

One of the unique features of Thursday's debate was the paddle round, in which candidates were prompted to vote yes or no to four quick questions. Here's how they voted:

QUESTION 1: Should we put put bike infrastructure on the back burner in our car city? 

YES: Motkaluk, Machiraju
NO: Ackerman, Wilson, Hayat, Woodstock, Diack, Bowman

QUESTION 2: After completing construction that has already started on the Southwest Transitway, should we scrap the rest of rapid transit? 

YES: Machiraju, Motkaluk
NO: Woodstock, Bowman, Hayat, Ackerman
MAYBE: Wilson, Diack​

QUESTION 3: Is it time for a major reinvestment in fixing up our aging recreation centres?

YES: all eight candidates

QUESTION 4: Should we reopen Portage and Main to pedestrians?

NO: 7/8 candidates
YES: Bowman

Watch the full debate:

Candidates answer question on crime

4 years ago
Duration 28:26
Candidates answer question on crime

Candidates on bike lanes, transit and Portage and Main

4 years ago
Duration 32:11
Candidates on bike lanes, transit and Portage and Main

Candidates on the downtown, transit fares and cannabis

4 years ago
Duration 33:47
Candidates on the downtown, transit fares and cannabis

With files from Bartley Kives and Shane Gibson


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?