Manitoba

Postmedia blamed for missing local coverage for years after announcing community newspapers closures

The editor of a Postmedia newspaper says she's reeling after being told the newspaper that has been published for 79 years will cease to exist starting next week.

Winkler mayor says Postmedia papers weren't covering community, simply an advertising carrier

In Manitoba, Postmedia will close the Altona Red River Valley Echo, Carman Valley Leader, Interlake Spectator (Gimli), Morden Times, Selkirk Journal, Stonewall Argus & Teulon Times, Winkler Times, and the Prairie Farmer. (Erik White/CBC )

Lori Penner will miss the weekly calls she gets at Altona's Red River Valley Echo, from people asking her to check the newspaper's archives for a little tidbit from the community's past.

"I still get people calling and saying, 'Can you look up an old newspaper clip that my grandpa was in?' Or 'Can you look up a photo of a sports team from 1981?'" she said.

Penner learned yesterday that her newspaper is one of eight Manitoba Postmedia-owned newspapers that will shut down. The newspaper and digital conglomerate says the papers are closing because of declining ad revenue.

The newspaper chain also is shutting down seven community newspapers in Ontario. 

"I'm still kind of reeling from it," Penner said. "I knew that our ad revenue was down, as is the case with every paper these days. I had really hoped that we could pull through. COVID didn't do a lot of good for a lot of papers."

Penner will prepare the last edition of the Red River Valley Echo next Thursday. It's in its 79th year of production.

"A small-town community paper — it's an institution. I think it will be very, very missed," she said.

It's "terribly sad news" for Greg Vandermeulen, editor of the Carillon in Steinbach, Man., who has worked for five of the Postmedia newspapers since 2003.

"When you lose these types of papers, and this number of papers, it definitely just leaves a hole in these communities," he said.

The loss will be particularly hard for cities and towns that aren't served by another newspaper, he said.

"They hold local councils, local school boards … accountable. They're also the main source of information for everybody who lives in those communities. They're also a place where you tell a good story — you read and share the triumphs of the community."

Cuts over the last few years have had an impact on the newspapers' ability to properly cover their communities, Vandermeulen said.

"The reporters that worked in them, on the ground, were doing the best job they could possibly do," he said.

Local coverage missing: Winkler mayor

The mayor of Winkler, Man., said in his community, other news media sources have been filling a void left by Postmedia years ago.

"Postmedia has not been very successful in running the paper locally, because the local piece of it was missing for several years," said Mayor Martin Harder.

"I heard a lot of complaints about how the paper itself just became an advertising carrier rather than content that was local," he said.

"For us, we will see no noticeable difference," he said, pointing to the success of competing newspaper Winkler Morden Voice, which is locally run.

For us, we will see no noticeable difference- Winkler Mayor Martin Harder

The majority of the closures will happen in places where another newer and community-owned newspaper has come around, said Ken Waddell, chair of the Manitoba Community Newspapers Association.

Locally run newspapers have been holding up better during COVID-19 than those owned by corporate entities, said Waddell, who is also the publisher and owner of the Neepawa Banner.

"Our newspapers' advertising has held up pretty good. I understand there are some that have lost advertising, but … I think it's more of a last straw rather than a fundamental cause," he said.

"You need the stuff in the local newspaper that you're never going to see anywhere else. The soccer clubs, baseball games, 4H clubs, the local council news, the school board.… You're never going to read that in a paper in another town."

Postmedia president and chief executive Andrew MacLeod told CBC Manitoba's Radio Noon that the papers were losing a lot of money and weren't viable anymore, especially during a time when the newspaper industry has seen an "unprecedented" decline in ad revenues. 

"We were forced into this decision," he said.

He regrets the company won't be able to support these communities anymore by providing them with local news, he said. 

The company will explore ways it can maintain a digital presence in the affected communities, but the physical papers are likely a thing of the past, he said.

About the Author

Marina von Stackelberg is a CBC journalist based in Winnipeg. She previously worked for CBC in Halifax and Sudbury. Connect with her @CBCMarina or marina.von.stackelberg@cbc.ca

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now