Manitoba government proposes fining people who drive on closed highways during storms, floods

Before the first snowflakes fall in Manitoba, the government introduced a new bill which would see people slapped with a fine if they ignore highway closures due to bad weather conditions, flooding or construction.

People could face fines of $2,000 to $5,000 for driving on closed highways under bill introduced Tuesday

A sign across a snowy highway says Road Closed
Road closure signs are seen posted along stretches of Highway 1 between Headingley and Portage la Prairie in a January file photo. The province is seeking to deter people from driving on closed highways by making it explicitly illegal to do so. (Jaison Empson/CBC)

Before the first snowflakes fall in Manitoba, the government introduced a new bill which would see people slapped with a fine if they ignore highway closures due to bad weather conditions, flooding or construction.

Infrastructure and Transportation Minister Doyle Piwniuk introduced Bill 46, also known as the Highway Traffic Amendment Act, during question period at the Manitoba Legislature on Tuesday.

The minister cited an accident that took place west of Virden, Man., over the winter after a heavy snowfall.

"There was an accident because of a semi-truck driver that wasn't supposed to be on the highway and it overturned one of our plow trucks," Piwniuk told reporters after question period.

"We want to make sure that people stay off the highways when they're actually closed because the fact is, it puts everybody else at risk, especially our first responders."

A snowplow clears lanes on the Trans-Canada Highway just outside of Brandon, Man., in an April file photo. Infrastructure Minister Doyle Piwniuk says a plow was tipped over when a semi truck was driving on a closed highway outside of Virden over the winter. (Riley Laychuk/CBC)

In May, another instance of a person disobeying road closures led to an urgent call to RCMP.

A 21-year-old driver had to be rescued from his sinking car after ignoring barricades and driving into a flooded area just north of St. Adolphe, Man.

Officers and firefighters found the car and rescued the man, but he was slapped with a $237 fine under the Highway Traffic Act for disobeying the barricades.

The top and back of a car can be seen above water that surrounds the vehicle on all sides. Some trees can be seen in the distance.
A man had to be rescued from this car after he drove past barricades and straight into a flooded section of road south of Winnipeg in May. (Submitted by RCMP)

If passed, those found in violation of the new law could be on the hook for a fine for at least 10 times that charge — between $2,000 and $5,000, the bill says.

The new law would prohibit people from driving on closed highways — unless they are driving an emergency vehicle, operating infrastructure equipment or authorized by a police officer.

The legislation would also hold accountable whoever causes or permits a vehicle to be on the road when its closed. For instance, the employer of a truck driver could be held liable for the driver using a closed highway.

Piwniuk said this legislation comes after the RCMP raised a number of concerns about the "dangerous behaviour that puts lives at risk," he said.

RCMP spokesperson Sgt. Paul Manaigre said police don't keep track of the number of people who drive on closed highways because there is no specific criminal offence for it at this time.

"Currently officers would have to examine other sections of the Highway Traffic Act that may fit the situation such as imprudent driving, careless driving or perhaps even dangerous driving under the Criminal Code," he said in an email.

Manaigre said there were a few times over the winter when there were numerous road closures and people disobeyed emergency orders.

"It may not be a fine that you will see being issued often, but it is a tool that we can use to hopefully get the message across that the practice of ignoring the road closure notice can be dangerous and now comes with a high cost," he said.

Efficiency given extra year to hit its targets

Meanwhile, the government also introduced its annual bill to implement various tax and other measures from that year's budget, as well as other financial changes like the inflationary relief cheques for low-income seniors and families with children.

The new edition of the Budget Implementation and Tax Statues Amendment Act also extends the amount of time the Crown corporation devoted to conserving energy can carry out its goals.

Efficiency Manitoba will be granted a one-year extension toward its three-year efficiency plan, which was set to expire in spring of 2023. Finance minister Cameron Friesen said the pandemic delayed some of the corporation's initiatives. 


Rachel Bergen is a journalist for CBC Manitoba and previously reported for CBC Saskatoon. Email story ideas to

With files from CBC's Ian Froese