Licences of 3 Manitoba long-term care homes 'under review' over inspector concerns

CBC News has learned that conditions at three long-term care homes have reached the point that Manitoba Health has taken the rare step of placing their operating licences “under review” based on concerns about the ability to maintain adequate staffing levels and infection control.

Maples and Parkview Place suspended from taking new residents until new plan in place

A stretcher is seen outside the Maples Personal Care Home.
The scene outside Maples Long Term Care Home on Saturday, Nov. 7, 2020. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

Operating licences at three Manitoba personal care homes, including one with an ongoing cockroach infestation, are under review over concerns about staffing levels and infection control, CBC News has learned.

Parkview Place and Maples Long Term Care Home in Winnipeg and Nisichawayasihk Personal Care Home near Thompson are supposed to fix these problems within "specified" timelines, and failure to do so could result in further restrictions on their licences, according to Manitoba Health.

Personal care homes in Manitoba with problems such as cockroaches, filthy conditions and short-staffing routinely pass inspections without being put under review. Prior to these three new cases, only two care homes under the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority were placed under review in the past five years, according to the province.

Even though fixes are supposed to be completed within "specified" timelines, a spokesperson for the province says "we have been flexible with the timeline in this instance due to COVID-19 outbreak status and related delays."

Yvette Mathieu's father was staying in Parkview Place care home, where he died of COVID-19. (Jill Coubrough/CBC)

Resolving problems at Parkview Place won't help Yvette Mathieu or her father — who spent his final days battling COVID-19 in the care home.

"I'm glad to hear that something is being looked at," said Mathieu, who doesn't want other families to go through what she experienced.

As Mathieu sat at her father's bedside in mid-October, she witnessed the effects of understaffing. She heard the din of call bells and ringing phones echo through the halls with staff seemingly nowhere to be seen.

"It was kind of chaotic," she said.

Despite being in a room with COVID-infected patients, Mathieu was given conflicting instructions about personal protective equipment and at one point was asked why she and her mom weren't wearing an extra mask. 

"We didn't have enough proper PPE," Mathieu said. "It sounds like we should have been wearing two ... face masks."

WATCH | Long-term care homes 'under review':

Licences of 3 Manitoba long-term care homes 'under review'

3 years ago
Duration 2:07
Operating licences at three Manitoba personal care homes, including one with an ongoing cockroach infestation, are under review over concerns about staffing levels and infection control, CBC News has learned.

When it came time to leave they had to flag down a nurse to show them how to remove their contaminated PPE to prevent infecting others.

"We could have just walked out of the room in the same PPE out to the front door and it wouldn't have been known," Mathieu said. "Because I asked, we were then given proper instructions to take it off in the room."

By the time Manitoba Health put Parkview Place and Maples "under review" on Dec. 11, COVID-19 had already wreaked havoc in the homes.

At Parkview, 163 residents and staff had tested positive for COVID-19 and 29 people had died. Maples had 228 infections and 51 deaths at that point.

A Parkview Place worker monitors the front door of the long-term care facility. 29 residents died with COVID-19 since the outbreak began in mid-September. It was declared over on Jan.12. (Lyzaville Sale/CBC)

A provincial investigation of Maples had already been called following a "nightmare" weekend in early November, when multiple ambulances were dispatched to treat a dozen residents during the outbreak. Eight seniors died at the home within 48 hours.

The crisis prompted a safety review by the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, which revealed staffing shortages, breaches in infection control measures and issues with recording feeding and nutritional information.

Members of the Red Cross were deployed to assist at the home for a month beginning in mid-November. They withdrew from the home on Dec. 12, a day after Maples' licence was placed under review.

The Red Cross did not deploy members to assist at Parkview Place.

Maples, Parkview suspended from taking in new residents 

Maples and Parkview Place are also suspended from accepting new residents since their respective outbreaks were declared over Jan. 12, according to a spokesperson for the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority.

The health authority has requested plans from each home "to ensure that a resumption of admissions is conducted in a safe manner," a WRHA spokesperson said, "including ensuring appropriate processes and staffing remain in place as new residents are admitted."

A spokesperson for Revera, the private, for-profit company that operates Maples and Parkview Place, said it's working to resolve the issues.

"Our hearts go out to the families and friends of the people we lost to the pandemic," Marie Fitzpatrick, a spokesperson for Revera said in an email.

"We appreciate the support and guidance of Manitoba Health and the WRHA and we will continue to work closely with them on licence renewals and plans to resume new admissions."

Nisichawayasihk chief disputes 'under review' status

There have been no COVID-19 infections at the Nisichawayasihk Personal Care Home, according to Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation Chief Marcel Moody, who says his community of 4,600 has only counted a single case of the disease.

The Nisichawayasihk care home was placed under review at the end of November because of concerns with nursing services, infection control, safety and security, according to a department spokesperson.

The "under review" status comes on the heels of a recently posted October inspection report which suggested a staffing crisis at Nisichawayasihk.

Nurses worked 12-hour shifts more than 50 consecutive days and two of the five nursing positions were vacant, according to the report.

"As far as I'm concerned, I think those standards have been addressed and we are moving on," said Moody, who disputes the "under review" status. He says a new director has taken over running the home.

"There's always issues with underfunding. We've been fighting the government for the last 10 years or more to adequately fund the building," Moody said in a telephone interview. 

A spokesperson for the province says the facility will remain under review until officials can confirm that concerns have been addressed.

"We will follow up with the regional health authority and the facility to discuss its 'under review' status," wrote a Health Department spokesperson. 

Indigenous Services Canada (ISC) provides funding to First Nations for personal care homes. A spokesperson for ISC says it's aware of the issues the province has raised, including the challenges associated with hiring and maintaining nurses and support staff.

"The hiring of nurses and support staff is a challenge as there is a province-wide shortage of nurses," said the spokesperson in an emailed statement. 

A spokesperson for the Northern Regional Health Authority says it continues to partner with the Nisichawayasihk Personal Care home to maintain the quality of care for elders.

"We did not provide staff as they were successful in recruiting their own," said a spokesperson for the NRHA.

In Winnipeg, Mathieu decided she wanted to speak publicly after her experience at Parkview Place.

"I was hoping it hadn't fallen off the radar," said Mathieu, who hopes vulnerable patients don't go ignored.

The WRHA says Maples is reporting progress with staffing and infection, prevention and control.

A spokesperson says staffing has "stabilized" across all shifts and the facility continues to "educate, reinforce and audit", infection control protocols and the use of PPE.


  • A previous version of this story stated only two homes were placed under review in the past five years. In fact, two homes under the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority were placed under review.
    Jan 25, 2021 4:15 PM CT