Lock down now or watch the numbers: How should Manitoba prepare for the COVID-19 third wave?

As COVID-19 case numbers soar in other parts of Canada, a Manitoba infectious disease expert says the province should be tightening restrictions before a third wave takes hold and case numbers get out of control.

Now is the time for restrictions, one expert says, but vaccines and pandemic fatigue factor into decision

This week Manitoba’s Chief Public Health Officer Brent Roussin said 'There is a third wave coming our way.' How Manitoba should be preparing for that third wave is up for debate. (Jaison Empson/CBC)

As COVID-19 case numbers soar in other parts of Canada, a Manitoba infectious disease expert says the province should be tightening restrictions before a third wave takes hold and case numbers get out of control. 

"Better that we do this now than do it in three weeks or four weeks, when we've guaranteed to have another hard lockdown and guaranteed to have another wave of deaths," said Dr. Anand Kumar, who's also an intensive care unit physician in Winnipeg. 

Ontario, Alberta, British Columbia and Quebec are among provinces fighting a third wave — one largely driven by more infectious variants. 

Ontario has issued a provincewide stay-at-home order, while other provinces have recently increased public health measures. 

"There is a third wave coming our way," Dr. Brent Roussin, Manitoba's chief public health officer, said this week. The rise of variant cases in the province is concerning, he said.

Manitoba had identified 339 variant of concern cases in the province as of Thursday, including 298 cases of the B117 variant first identified in the United Kingdom. Variants make up roughly a quarter of Winnipeg's recent cases, Roussin said. 

WATCH | Dr. Joss Reimer urges the public to get vaccinated ahead of third wave:

Dr. Joss Reimer says Manitoba is in the beginning of its third wave

1 year ago
Duration 0:32
Dr. Joss Reimer, medical lead for Manitoba's vaccine task force, said Friday the province is in the beginnings of its third wave of COVID-19 cases and urged the public to get vaccinated as soon as possible.

Souradet Shaw, an epidemiologist and assistant professor at the University of Manitoba, said Manitoba has made the right choice to loosen restrictions slowly, following a provincewide lock down that included restrictions on gatherings, indoor dining at restaurants and the sale of non-essential goods.

We're always two weeks to a month behind, and so when the signals are there, there shouldn't be hesitancy​​​​- Souradet Shaw

But Shaw doesn't think they should be eased further until it's known what impacts variants are having in the province. 

"We're in a better position than other provinces, but it's best to sort of take the cautious approach." 

Souradet Shaw is an epidemiologist and assistant professor at the University of Manitoba. (Shelley Shaw)

He said while the idea of increasing restrictions proactively until there's enough vaccination in place to mitigate a third wave does have merits, other factors such as pandemic fatigue play a role in policy decisions like this. 

"I think tightening, I'm not entirely sure that would be palatable to the population." 

Still, he says there are some things that should be done now, such as increasing testing and ramping up vaccine efforts. He said that includes both getting more people immunized and ensuring people at risk — including essential workers and their families, racialized communities and multi-generational households — get the shot. 

WATCH | Manitoba doctor talks pandemic restrictions and a third wave:

Manitoba doctor talks public health restrictions and a third wave

1 year ago
Duration 1:36
Dr. Philippe Lagacé-Wiens, a medical microbiologist and physician at St. Boniface Hospital, explains why he thinks it's a good idea to tighten public health restrictions in Manitoba ahead of a third wave.

And he said the province needs to shut things down quickly — while also increasing economic and psychological and emotional supports — if hospitalizations, case numbers and test positivity rates start to increase consistently.

"I think the last thing we want to do is wait too long and then do half-measures in terms of restrictions," said Shaw. 

"The virus and its variants are always going to win. We're always two weeks to a month behind, and so when the signals are there, there shouldn't be hesitancy."

Call for COVID-zero strategy

Roussin said Thursday the current public health measures will stay in effect until the end of the month. However, he said more restrictions could be added if needed. 

Kumar said the time is now. 

He said there are basically two different strategies that have been used around the world to deal with COVID-19 since the start of the pandemic. 

Dr. Anand Kumar, ICU attending physician for the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, poses for a photograph in an intensive care ward at the St. Boniface Hospital in Winnipeg Friday, August 28, 2009. (John Woods/The Canadian Press)

One approach, he said, is implementing aggressive measures when health-care systems are at risk of being overloaded. 

The other he describes as essentially a COVID-zero strategy— implementing tight restrictions early, getting case numbers under a target number and keeping them there. 

That's something Manitoba could still do now, he said.

"You push it hard now before the numbers go up," he said. "You get the numbers down under 20 and then again you try to keep it under 20 and rather than 200 being your panic point, you let 40 be your panic point."

Kumar said over time a COVID-zero strategy results in fewer deaths, more economic activity and a more targeted approach to shutdowns if cases start to creep up. He uses Australia and New Zealand as examples of countries who have done it. 

He said Atlantic Canada has also been successful at keeping case numbers low. 

"It's a much more aggressive approach early on," said Kumar. "The problem is that I suspect politically that it's difficult to do because the need for it isn't obvious…. The need only becomes obvious when things are out of control."

He worries things could escalate quickly with more infectious variants of concern circulating in the province. 

"B117 in particular, is probably at least 50 per cent more infectious," said Kumar.  "So in fact, even if we think that we're making the change early enough to blunt what's going to happen, chances are we're underestimating what's going to happen."

Dr. Philippe Lagacé-Wiens is a medical microbiologist and physician at St. Boniface Hospital. (Philippe Lagacé-Wiens/Facebook)

Dr. Philippe Lagacé-Wiens, a medical microbiologist and physician at St. Boniface Hospital, said the signs show a third wave is coming and rethinking some of the measures in place now could help reduce case numbers down the road. 

"We're looking at the barrel of a third wave that's hitting all around us," he said "It's pretty certain that it's going to arrive in my opinion, and folks are tired, folks are unable to cope with the amount of hospitalization that would be expected. So to wait for it too long would be disastrous."

He would like to see capacity in places such as shopping centres and inside restaurants reduced from 50 per cent back down to 25 per cent.

It also doesn't make sense to him that people aren't required to wear masks when at a religious service as long as they're seated with their households, physically distanced and not singing or chanting. 

"Everywhere else you have to wear a mask indoors," he said.

Lagacé-Wiens said when restrictions were imposed last year early on in the pandemic, the province saw very little of a first wave. Working hard now to keep case numbers down, he said, gives Manitobans a much better chance of having a better summer.

With a third wave washing into the province, what is the next step?

1 year ago
Duration 2:15
A call this morning to tighten restrictions before a third wave of COVID-19 hits the province. Manitoba's Chief Provincial Public Health Officer, Dr. Brent Roussin said this week, he expects to see a third wave and new public health restrictions could be added if needed.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?