Manitoba·CBC Investigates

Province changes how it counts kids in care, reports lower number than Manitoba child welfare agencies

While the Manitoba government reports 10,328 kids in care, the province's four child welfare agencies say their tally of kids in care is actually closer to 11,150.

10,776 kids in care, province says after change to how number is tallied, but agencies say total is 11,143

Changes made by the province's Families department have raised questions from Manitoba's children's advocate and the Opposition NDP about the true number of kids in care, and how to quantify the progress made by the current government. (Joanne Levasseur/CBC News)

At first glance, it looks like the number of children in care in Manitoba decreased from just over 10,700 to 10,328 last year — a figure touted by the Families minister as the first decrease in the number of children in care in over a decade.

But dig a little deeper and there is a different story, where the province has made changes to how it tallies that number — and the result has raised questions about how many children are actually in care.

The province has moved from collecting self-reported numbers from child welfare agencies to using a central database to keep track of how many kids are in Child and Family Services care in Manitoba.

That has the province reporting 10,328 kids in care, plus another 448 in "non-paid" care — while Manitoba's four child welfare agencies say according to their annual reports, the number is actually closer to 11,150.

NDP Leader Wab Kinew says changes to how the numbers are presented affect how the government measures progress when it comes to the number of children in care. (Gary Solilak/CBC )

"I think the more cynical and perhaps more accurate read on what's happening here is that the government is deliberately undercounting the number of kids in care for political purposes," says Opposition NDP Leader Wab Kinew.

"If you change the methodology, halfway through, any claim to progress doesn't hold water.… It is going to be important that there is a real benchmark to measure the progress here."

Using data compiled from Manitoba's Families department's annual reports and the annual reports of Child and Family Services mandated agencies, CBC News has looked at how the changes have created the discrepancy.

What changes were made?

The government changed the way it defined "children in care" in 2017, by removing the category called "non-paid care" from its final tally — reducing the number of kids in care by 638.

Children in non-paid care are those who are living with a parent, guardian or family members who have legal status as wards with CFS.

It was a move similar to one attempted by the then NDP government in 2016, when it tried to remove the number of kids in voluntary placements from the total number of kids in care.

That change would have removed 700 children from the total number. It would also have excluded kids who are brought into the system under new customary care legislation — both were to be reported in a separate category.

Progressive Conservative MLA Ian Wishart, the Families critic at the time, said the counting change did nothing to improve on the number of kids in CFS care.

"They're trying to make it look like they're reducing the number and making progress downward, but the reality is they are still responsible for that many kids in one form or another," he said.

"It's a bit of an exercise in public relations, to put it bluntly."

The NDP backpedalled following the criticism, and vowed to continue to report all categories.

Change in 'interest of transparency'

The latest move to take "non-paid care" children out of the count was done in the "interest of transparency," a provincial spokesperson said.

"We believe a child reported to be at home with their families or guardians, where reunification plans are in progress, and without financial supports for their care should be counted separately from all other children in care," a spokesperson for the Families department wrote in a prepared statement.

The spokesperson said the department has "started reporting our number in two ways."

"The first is the self-reported number by the authority. The second is to separate by definition (children in care, living in an out-of-home placement, financially supported by the government)," he wrote.

"Both totals are clearly indicated and explained on the report."

Daphne Penrose, the Manitoba advocate for children and youth, says that the government should count all children with legal status as wards of Child and Family Services as children in care. (Jeff Stapleton/CBC)

Daphne Penrose, Manitoba's advocate for children and youth, believes strongly that a person living in "non-paid" care — who has legal status as a CFS ward — is still a child in care and should be counted as such.

"The legal status is the legal status, and if it rests with an agency and the guardian is not the parent [but] the agency, that is considered to be a child in care," she said.

Not all the non-paid care situations mean the child is on the path to reunification with their birth family, she said.

"Sometimes they are kids who are missing, sometimes they are kids who are in custody, so it's important to understand that isn't a hard and fast rule that they are all at home being reunified," she said.

The 2nd change

The waters were further muddied in 2018 when the Families department announced, on page 151 of its annual report, the number of children in care will be presented "differently than prior years."

Instead of self-reported data collected from child welfare agencies, it would instead use numbers taken from its centralized system, called the Child and Family Services Information System.

"Reported numbers that mandated CFS agencies provide in their annual reports may differ from the Department's annual report," warned an internal memo, a heavily redacted copy of which was obtained under a Freedom of Information request.

The results presented by the agencies in their subsequent annual reports differ significantly from the government's reported figures.

The province sent a release in September noting the number of children in care had decreased to 10,328 — the first decrease in 15 years — while also noting there were 448 kids in non-paid care.

It was a reduction from the previous year — which saw the largest spike in children in care in almost a  decade. Even under the province's numbers, there are still more children in care today than there were as of March 31, 2016.

Counting the figures in the annual reports of the four CFS-mandated agencies shows 11,143 children in care as of March 31, 2018 — 367 more kids than the numbers released by the government, including children in non-paid care.

Families Minister Heather Stefanson said the decision to use numbers from the province's centralized system is about transparency and presenting more accurate numbers.

She argues the province knows "exactly who the kids are that are in care," by using the database.

"Is the system perfect? No. And it is really not about whether or not the numbers are going up or down — it is to ensure we have the accurate number there," she said.

"I don't think there has been complete transparency in the numbers when there is a self-reporting system, because there is a lot of duplications and inaccuracies."

What do the authorities say?

The CBC reached out to the four authorities — the Northern, Southern, General and Métis Child and Family Services authorities — to ask them about the numbers.

The Southern First Nations Network of Care said the province's sudden change resulted in almost 200 more kids counted in their tally of children in care.

Manitoba Minister of Families Heather Stefanson said the changes are about transparency and getting a more accurate read of how many children are in care. (CBC)

"There were some challenges in collecting information not available on [the Child and Family Services Information System] to ensure the case counts were consistent between the province, the Southern Network and its agencies," the authority wrote in a prepared statement.

It said under the previous system, where it would take the information from its 10 agencies and submit the information, it had been "consistent and accurate."

The General CFS Authority said it chose to include additional information, such as supervised adoption placements.

The Northern CFS Authority also cited challenges in using the centralized information system — which has historically been difficult for northern communities to use due to lack of internet access. 

An analysis of the Northern, General and Southern authorities' figures over the past five years show their numbers matched those in the province's annual report, until the government intiated its first changes in 2017.

What's next?

Stefanson insists this is not a change to the way kids in care are counted.

"I do not believe there is a change in how the counts are [done] for children in care. It has been in place for many, many years now," she said.

"What has happened is there used to be a not very transparent process before we took office."

A Families spokesperson said the department will not commit to releasing the numbers compiled by the agencies because it is no longer collecting the information.

Chris Adams, a former pollster and political author, says sometimes governments have to "recalibrate" the way they collect data — but need to publicly address that changes have been made.

"[The changes] might be a more accurate number for what was happening in society or with programs," he said.

They are not numbers. They are kids, and we need to understand we are accountable to those numbers and we want to know what is going on.- Daphne Penrose

But there could be an issue "if the dial is moving and we don't exactly know if that was because the methodology changed, or because something in the program was changed," said Adams.

"You might be able to be glad about the numbers changing, but at the same time you have to preface your remarks by saying the measuring tool has changed."

Children's advocate Penrose says the key is to figure out why there is a discrepancy, and ensure there is consistency in the way the numbers are reported.

"They are not numbers. They are kids, and we need to understand we are accountable to those numbers and we want to know what is going on," she said.

"More important than the number is that children — if there is a decrease in the number of children in care — that it happens because children are safer at home and able to be at home safely," she said, and "that it is not just the matter of meeting a target."

About the Author

Kristin Annable is a member of CBC's investigative unit based in Winnipeg. She can be reached at kristin.annable@cbc.ca