Justin Trudeau gets a grilling from Winnipeg elementary students

At a visit Thursday with École Robert H. Smith School students in Winnipeg, Justin Trudeau faced some tough questions.

'Why did your dad give everyone in Western Canada the middle finger?' Robert H. Smith student asks

Student asks PM Trudeau why his dad gave the west the middle finger

CBC News Manitoba

4 years ago
At a visit with students at École Robert H. Smith School Thursday Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was asked by a child why his father gave western Canada the middle finger. 0:37

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau faced some tough questions at a visit Thursday with École Robert H. Smith School students in Winnipeg.

After being asked by one student to pick a favourite place in Canada, another spoke up before Trudeau could answer.

"Why did your dad give everyone in Western Canada the middle finger?" one student asked the prime minister.

Trudeau replied jokingly to the first child's question.

"Salmon Arm, British Columbia," he said, referring to the location where, while on a train in 1982, Pierre Trudeau famously gave the middle finger to a group of B.C. protesters angry about high unemployment.

"My father had an approach to politics that not everyone agreed with," said Trudeau later.

"In politics, you have to make big decisions and whenever you make big decisions there's always going to be people who agree with it and people who disagree."

Trudeau stopped at the school Thursday afternoon after 450 Robert H. Smith students, from kindergarten to Grade 6, sent handwritten letters and poems inviting him to a school assembly during his Winnipeg visit.

"You absolutely made my day when I got the letters," Trudeau told the assembly of cross-legged kids. "It was such a pleasure for me to read them."

Trudeau is taking part in a whistle-stop tour across Canada designed to reconnect with citizens and answer questions in town halls. Winnipeg's town hall forum took place at the Duckworth Centre at the University of Winnipeg later on Thursday.

After Trudeau's visit, students told CBC meeting the prime minister was "surreal" and "amazing."

"It was probably the best experience of my life," said 11-year-old Jayden Gepta. "I got an actual chance to talk to him and he gave me a hug."

"He's done a lot of good things in Canada," said Grade 4 student Sofia Bieber.

Trudeau experiences Jollibee

Trudeau's time in Winnipeg included a brief midday stop at the city's new Jollibee, the first Canadian location in a fast-food restaurant chain which is popular in the Philippines.

Roughly 80 people were packed into the restaurant, including Liberal MP Kevin Lamoureux and Liberal MLA Cindy Lamoureux. The father and daughter represent nearby constituencies with large Filipino populations.

A cheer went up in the small restaurant as Trudeau arrived. He posed for a picture with staff, saying "I won't delay orders that much."

He stopped to have pictures taken with virtually every group that was seated before proceeding to the next event.

Trudeau's visit to Winnipeg followed stops in Regina and Calgary, where the prime minister was challenged Tuesday on his commitment to growing the Albertan economy while also transitioning away from fossil fuels to meet climate change goals.

Earlier in his whistle-stop tour, the prime minister faced harsh criticism in Ontario over the prices of electricity as well as the backlog of issues associated with problems with the Phoenix pay system in New Brunswick.

with files from Susan Magas, Erin Brohman and The Canadian Press


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?