First Nations children still face delays in accessing health care: report

First Nations children in Canada still face obstacles in accessing health and social services as quickly as other children due to continuing "bureaucratic confusion" and red tape on the part of governments, according to a report released today.

Governments' response to Jordan's Principle falls short, researchers and groups say

First Nations children still face delays in accessing health care: report

8 years ago
Duration 1:59
First Nations children in Canada still face obstacles in accessing health and social services as quickly as other children due to continuing "bureaucratic confusion" and red tape on the part of governments, according to a new report.

First Nations children in Canada still face obstacles in accessing health and social services as quickly as other children due to continuing "bureaucratic confusion" and red tape on the part of governments, according to a new report.

The report, released on Tuesday by Canadian and U.S. researchers along with the Canadian Pediatric Society, the Assembly of First Nations and Unicef Canada, says the federal government has fallen short on Jordan's Principle, its 2007 pledge to ensure First Nations children with complex health needs who are caught in jurisdictional fights between the federal, provincial and band governments are not denied access to public health services.

Jordan Anderson is seen in this 2003 image provided by the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs. Anderson, who was from the Norway House Cree Nation in Manitoba, was born in 1999 with a complex genetic disorder that needed specialized care. He died in 2005 at the age of four. (Submitted by the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs)
Under Jordan's Principle, which was endorsed by the House of Commons in 2007, First Nations children are entitled to receive the public assistance they need, regardless of disputes between levels of government over who should pay.

However, the report's authors say, First Nations children needing health and social services must still contend with what it calls an "ongoing inequity," as they cannot access the care and support they need as quickly as other children in Canada.

"There is growing recognition that the governmental response to Jordan’s Principle does not reflect the vision advanced by First Nations and endorsed by the House of Commons," the report states in part.

The report was prepared by researchers from McGill University, the University of Manitoba and the University of Michigan, in collaboration with representatives from the three organizations.

Agreement named after Manitoba boy

Jordan's Principle got its name from Jordan River Anderson, a young boy from the Norway House Cree Nation in northern Manitoba who was born with a complex genetic disorder that required specialized care.

After spending much of his life in a hospital setting, doctors decided he could return to Norway House, but  would need an enormous amount of home care.

The Manitoba and federal governments fought over who should pay for that care. The issue was never resolved, and Jordan, 4, died in 2005 in a Winnipeg hospital, hundreds of kilometres away from his family's community.

"Responsibility for services to First Nations children is often shared by federal, provincial/territorial and First Nations governments; in contrast, funding and delivery of these same services to most other children in Canada falls solely under provincial/territorial jurisdiction," the report says.

"Accordingly, First Nations children face unique challenges in accessing services, and Jordan’s Principle is an essential mechanism for ensuring their human, constitutional, and treaty rights."

After Jordan's Principle was endorsed by the House of Commons, the federal government helped develop federal, provincial and territorial policies and procedures for identifying similar cases and dealing with jurisdictional disputes.

Range of cases narrowed

But the new report says the current federal, provincial and territorial governments' response has narrowed the range of cases to which the principle would apply, and delayed payment for services tied up in jurisdictional disputes.

"Now it's been pruned back to a definition where there is no Jordan's Principle case unless the federal government and the province agree that there is a case," said Josée Lavoie, director of the Manitoba First Nations Centre for Aboriginal Health Research and one of the researchers involved in the report.

Elizabeth Bignell reads to her seven-year-old daughter, N'Tanis George, in Winnipeg on Tuesday. The pair moved to Winnipeg last year so N'Tanis, who has caudal regression syndrome and other health issues, can get the medical care and support she needs. (Meagan Fiddler/CBC)
The governments have also excluded First Nations from the implementation of Jordan's Principle, and they lack mechanisms for ensuring transparency and accountability, according to the report.

Unicef Canada, the Canadian Pediatric Society and the Assembly of First Nations are calling on the governments to work with First Nations to "develop and implement a response for First Nations children that truly reflects the vision of Jordan's Principle."

The groups also want the governments to "systematically identify and address the jurisdictional ambiguities and underfunding that give rise to each Jordan’s Principle case."

A spokesperson for federal Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Minister Bernard Valcourt told CBC News that Ottawa has reached agreements to implement Jordan's Principle with Manitoba, Saskatchewan, British Columbia and New Brunswick.

"These arrangements outline commitments to developing dispute avoidance processes to ensure continuity of care for children with multiple disabilities. All other provinces already have mechanisms in place to implement Jordan’s Principle," the spokesperson wrote in an email.

"While there are currently no outstanding jurisdictional disputes involving Jordan's Principle in Canada, we believe that the best way to ensure First Nation children and families get the support they need is by working with willing partners and continue engaging with provinces, territories and First Nations to collaborate on implementing Jordan's Principle."

'These kids are being left out'

Elizabeth Bignell says she and her daughter, N'Tanis George, 7, moved to Winnipeg last summer so N'Tanis could get the medical care she needs.

"I just want her to shine," Bignell said. "I want her to have every opportunity as other children do."

N'Tanis was born with caudal regression syndrome, which impairs the development of the lower half of her body. The condition has come with other medical problems for her.

Bignell said N'Tanis could not get the care she needed in their home community, the Opaskwayak Cree Nation in northern Manitoba, because their band does not receive the same federal health funding as other communities.

"A few times I was denied any kind of services only because of where she lives," she said, adding that N'Tanis needs access to specialized services not offered in their closest community, The Pas.

Cindy Blackstock, executive director of the First Nation Child & Family Caring Society of Canada, calls the results of the latest research tragic.

"We've seen internal government documents that also confirm that inside of the government, they know that these kids are being left out, and sometimes with very tragic consequences," she told CBC News.

Blackstock said her organization has a case before the Canadian Human Rights Commission asking Ottawa to broaden its criteria in Jordan's Principle cases. A ruling in that case is expected later this year.

Ontario's provincial advocate for children and youth, Irwin Elman, says he supports the new report and wants governments to take action.

"I am urging the provincial and federal governments to uphold their commitment to First Nations children and begin the hard work needed to transform existing programs and services for First Nations children and implement Jordan's Principle," Elman said in a news release.

Read the full report

Below you can read the full report, Without Denial, Delay or Disruption: Ensuring First Nations children's access to equitable services through Jordan's Principle.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?