Crime stealing voter attention ahead of Winnipeg election, poll suggests

In a year when meth use and theft dominate headlines, crime, not the state of Winnipeg's roads or opening Portage and Main, could very well be the most important civic election issue come October.

1 in 3 adults say reducing crime matters to them most: Probe Research

Cassidy Herring, with three-year-old son Elijah, moved to Wolseley earlier this year. He said he is not surprised a recent poll suggests crime is a growing issue among voters; since February, he has had multiple items stolen from his property. (Jaison Empson/CBC)

In a year when meth use and theft dominate headlines, crime, not the state of Winnipeg's roads or opening Portage and Main, could very well be the most important civic election issue come October.

A Probe Research survey, commissioned by CBC, found one in three respondents — 32 per cent — ranked reducing crime as the issue that matters to them most.

Twenty-five percent of respondents, or one in four, said repairing existing roads and bridges was the city issue they cared most about.

That's a different picture from 2014, when Probe found the majority of respondents said fixing the Winnipeg's crumbling streets and potholes was the most important issue for them.

Crime tops voter attention ahead of election


2 years agoVideo
In a year when meth use and theft dominate headlines, crime, not the state of Winnipeg's roads or opening Portage and Main, could very well be the most important civic election issue come October. 2:52

The results came as no surprise to Wolseley resident Cassidy Herring who said since February, thieves have stolen a bike and an extendable ladder from his yard. It's enough to make him consider installing a home surveillance system, he said.

"It feels violating," said Herring. "We've worked hard to get what we have."

Along with thefts from his yard, Herring has also noticed more drug paraphernalia, including syringes, left in the street.

"It would sure make a dent if more uniformed officers were just in the neighbourhood," he said. 

Poll suggests crime, roads equally important 

Overall, the August poll found crime is neck-and-neck with infrastructure as the most important issue for Winnipeg voters, said Scott MacKay, president of Probe Research. 

Six hundred adult Winnipeggers were surveyed online between Aug. 27 and Aug. 31 for the Probe poll. The researchers weighted results to represent Winnipeg's population for age and gender.

Sixty-three per cent of respondents said crime was among their top three concerns and 64 per cent said repairing existing roads and bridges were among their top three concerns. From that, MacKay concludes the two issues are equally important.

The poll has a margin of error rate of +/- 4 percentage points. 

The data shows a shift in Winnipeg, even compared to last year.

In a Probe poll from December 2017, 11 per cent of respondents said crime violence and vandalism were their top concerns. In the August poll, that number jumped to 24 per cent.

Winnipeg needs more police: union

Maurice Sabourin, president of the Winnipeg Police Association, has no doubts about why Winnipeggers are more concerned about crime. Inadequate funding for police coupled with the rise of methamphetamine use have led to more thefts, more violent behaviour, he said.

"We believe that the mayor and the council haven't done an appropriate job providing an appropriate police budget I will argue that is one of the main reasons why we're seeing an increase in crime," said Sabourin.

"We think that public safety is a major concern and it should be the top issue in this year's civic election."

In the last Winnipeg police annual report, violent crime rose 10 per cent in 2017 compared to the five-year average, while property crime went up 17 per cent. Drug possession charges are up 890 per cent compared to 2012 — a jump police say is due to meth use.

Maurice Sabourin, president of the Winnipeg Police Association, said the police budget needs to grow to reduce crime in the city. (Jeff Stapleton/CBC)

Calls involving persons high on methamphetamine tend to take longer and use up more police resources, Sabourin said.

In a joint written statement, Insp. Max Waddell and Deputy Chief Gord Perrier backed up the latter assertion. 

"An individual who is high on meth takes longer to medically clear when compared to other illicit street drugs," they said.

"Additionally, meth related calls are often associated with calls of violence, uncertainty and weapons-related incidents, therefore more time is required to safely take control of the situation."

Sabourin said Winnipeg police are struggling to meet the demands on the service

"Right now because there is no overtime spending, it's very restricted. Those cruiser cars are being sent home even when there's high volume of call in the cue," Sabourin said. "There is no time for proactive policing."

Waddell and Perrier dispute the idea there is no longer time for proactive policing. General patrol members tend to be busier in the summer months, they said, whereas in the fall and winter months, they tend to have more time for "self-directed proactive activities."

"Let's not forget that we have dedicated foot patrol and community support units that have high volumes of work that can be classified as proactive and direct engagement," they said.

More detox facilities needed 

Not all Winnipeggers CBC spoke with say more officers is the right response. Winnipeg teacher Leslie Mondor said she would rather see more funds diverted to mass transit than the police budget.

"I'm not as sure it's as big a problem as it seems," she said.  "A lot of crime would be resolved if we had more treatment centres for people with addictions."

Bronwyn Dobchuk-Land, a criminal justice assistant professor at the University of Winnipeg, agreed. 

"The money could be much better spent on supportive interventions," she said. "What we need are responses that help people stabilize their lives."

It's also important to recognize the difference between property crime, which rarely poses a threat to human safety, and violent crime, which statistically occurs most between people who know each other and in private homes, she said.

"I think we need to damp down on the panic around property crime," said Dobchuk-Land. 

Bronwyn Dobchuk-Land, a criminal justice assistant professor at the University of Winnipeg, is calling for more resources into detox centres and drop-in centres to support people with addictions to drugs to address root causes of crime. (John Einarson/CBC)

"The natural response is to say we need more policing. Policing doesn't prevent theft. The police can't be everywhere all the time. And if they were, we would live in a police state."

Dobchuk-Land said taxpayer funds would be better spent on adding more detox beds so people addicted to meth have somewhere to go to recover. She also called for better housing and suggested expanding 24-hour safe centres like the model at Magnus Eliason Recreation Centre.

"There need to be supportive responses to these behaviours and increasing policing and treating this like a crime problem instead of a drug problem, or a health problem or a lack of housing problem is really problematic and it's not helping."

Winnipeg's police budget increased in 2018 by $4 million to $291.5 million and made up 27 per cent of the total operating budget for 2018.

On mobile? Click here for the full poll.

More from CBC Manitoba:


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.